sympathy
In Hume and Smith, the mechanism by which we come to share or respond to others' feelings; Hume sees it as direct emotional transmission, Smith as imaginative projection into another's situation.
As defined in Dennis Rasmussen on Hume and Smith and The Infidel and the Professor
Where it comes up · 7
- Friedrich Nietzsche by Bertrand Russell5 claims
- Dennis Rasmussen on Hume and Smith and The Infidel and the Professor3 claims
- Smith's Wealth of Nations3 claims
- PHILOSOPHY - David Hume2 claims
- Vernon Smith on Rationality in Economics 03/03/20081 claim
- 14 - The Virtues Of Cold Blood1 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 48 Hume on Religion and Ethics1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 16Search all claims for “sympathy” →
- Benevolence develops from sympathy, which involves feeling pleasure with another or pain with another, grounded in the association principle of resemblance—when you recognize similarities between your experience and another's, you form complex ideas involving both, and thereby feel not just for yourself but for the other.A History of Philosophy | 48 Hume on Religion and Ethics
- Adam Smith's account of benevolence in The Theory of Moral Sentiments is essentially a theory of reciprocity and social exchange: people are benevolent toward those who have been benevolent to them, and human sympathy lets us read each other by imagining ourselves in others' situations.Vernon Smith on Rationality in Economics 03/03/2008
- Critics who claim that Smith believes all people are always rational utility maximizers and purely selfish have misread him; Smith actually believes in moral sentiments like benevolence and sympathy, as shown in his other work, The Theory of Moral Sentiments.Smith's Wealth of Nations
- Emotional empathy (feeling what others feel, what Smith and Hume called sympathy) functions as a spotlight that zooms in on one person in the here and now, making it biased, corrupt, short-sighted and innumerate, so societies care vastly more about a single identifiable victim than about millions dying from diffuse causes like climate change.14 - The Virtues Of Cold Blood
- Smith believes that social cohesion, human benevolence, and concern for others transcending mere selfishness derive from a common sentiment—particularly sympathy—which is why people give charity without coercion.Smith's Wealth of Nations
- Hume and Smith both ground morality in 'sympathy' but conceive it differently: Hume treats sympathy as an emotional contagion mechanism that transmits feelings directly from one person to another, whereas Smith (rejecting this in the first chapter of The Theory of Moral Sentiments) argues we feel little until we imaginatively project ourselves into another's situation—you don't catch an angry person's anger, and identical signs of anguish (a paper cut vs. a dead spouse) elicit different sympathy—so Smith's account leaves room for judging whether an emotion is warranted, which Hume's contagion view does not.Dennis Rasmussen on Hume and Smith and The Infidel and the Professor
- Smith's ethical theory is derived from emotions rather than reason and has no rational foundation; ethics emerges from sentiment (particularly sympathy), not from logical argument—a position influenced by David Hume.Smith's Wealth of Nations
- Nietzsche would likely define the superior few as victors in war and their descendants, whom he regards as biologically superior to the vanquished, with superior individuals more likely to be noble in Nietzschean sense—having more strength of will, courage, impulse toward power, and less sympathy, fear, and gentleness.Friedrich Nietzsche by Bertrand Russell
- Nietzsche's ideal noble man is wholly devoid of sympathy, ruthless, cunning, cruel, and concerned only with his own power, with no conception that one who has conquered fear would not need to tyrannize over others or that men who have truly conquered fear lack the frantic quality of the artist tyrant.Friedrich Nietzsche by Bertrand Russell
- An ethic like that of Christianity or Buddhism has its emotional basis in universal sympathy, while Nietzsche's ethics rests in a complete absence of sympathy; Nietzsche frequently preaches against sympathy and demonstrates no difficulty in obeying his own precepts.Friedrich Nietzsche by Bertrand Russell