definition
Smith's Sympathy Requires Imaginative Projection
Hume and Smith both ground morality in 'sympathy' but conceive it differently: Hume treats sympathy as an emotional contagion mechanism that transmits feelings directly from one person to another, whereas Smith (rejecting this in the first chapter of The Theory of Moral Sentiments) argues we feel little until we imaginatively project ourselves into another's situation—you don't catch an angry person's anger, and identical signs of anguish (a paper cut vs. a dead spouse) elicit different sympathy—so Smith's account leaves room for judging whether an emotion is warranted, which Hume's contagion view does not.
definitionpending
Speaker
Dennis RasmussenEvidence Quote
“Because sympathy takes place in this more complicated way, we don't just catch people's feelings, whatever they happen to be. There's space for us to say whether their emotion is warranted.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:22:52 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...