
Vernon Smith on Rationality in Economics 03/03/2008
What this covers
Vernon Smith talks with Russ Roberts about his book on constructivist and ecological forms of rationality. The conversation starts in the laboratory. In experimental economics markets built from textbook supply and demand, buyers hold private maximum prices and sellers private minimums. Untrained subjects in a double auction converged on the predicted price and volume, which astonished Smith in the 1950s. Asked how they did it, they gave blank stares. Roberts names the puzzle: individual traders reason sparingly, the market is surprisingly rational, and the theorists who modeled it reasoned intensively.
The range then widens. Airline deregulation and the unplanned rise of hub-and-spoke routing serve as a case study. Fred Smith bet his own money on a hub for Federal Express, yet rival airlines tried many other arrangements before the structure emerged. Smith also takes up the apparent conflict between Adam Smith's two books, resolving it by treating favor-trading and reciprocity as real exchange. Along the way come religious rules on stealing and coveting as encoded property rights, and Hayek's point that people must live in both small-group and extended orders. Neuroscience findings on how the brain encodes money, and sequential-game results in which cooperators out-earn equilibrium players, round out the empirical side.
The contentious turns concern policy. Smith argues that interventions assume behavior will not change, citing moral hazard in bailouts. He adds that people carry small-group intuitions about deliberate good into markets that work better left alone. He also defends commerce against the charge that it erodes virtue. Roberts presses what follows if no one can fully know how prices emerge: traditional policy evaluation becomes agnostic.
Smith argues that market order is ecological: rational outcomes emerge from repeated trial, exchange, and reciprocity without anyone modeling them, so constructed models and policy interventions often overreach.
- Experimental subjects with only private information reach competitive equilibrium without knowing the theory
- Airline hub-and-spoke and FedEx's Memphis hub emerged from market trial and error, not top-down design
- Exchange and reciprocity predate commercial trade and remain the base of human cooperation
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Experimental subjects who find competitive equilibrium cannot model their own decision process and give blank stares when asked how they did it, showing that humans can function well in rule-governed systems while being very poor at modeling the process that produces their success.
“The students have found the competitive equilibrium... And I often ask them, Well, now how did you do this? Well, there's just blank stares.”
Smith's lab experiment used a constructed supply and demand design with buyers given private maximum willingness to pay and sellers given minimum acceptable prices, and participants with only this private information still reached the predicted competitive equilibrium price and volume, which astonished him in 1956 and launched experimental economics.
“Will people be able to find the equilibrium in that market without knowing what we know as economists? ... And what astonished me was that they did.”
Neuroscience experiments show the brain encodes money in the same reward circuits used for food and other pleasures, with reward centers activated when subjects compare monetary payoffs, and the activation is weaker but still present even when the money is not real.
“it encodes it the way it encodes uh um items of pleasure like uh uh food”
Neuroscience shows the brain encodes money the way it encodes primary rewards such as food, using the same reward centers; imaging shows these areas activate when people compare monetary payoffs, and the activation is weaker for hypothetical money but still present.
“the same areas are activated when people are comparing situations that involve monetary payoff... it's just stronger if there's real money involved”
Smith built a laboratory market from the textbook supply and demand model, giving buyers private maximum willingness to pay and sellers private minimum acceptable prices, and found that untrained participants with no economics knowledge still converged on the predicted equilibrium price and volume, which astonished him in the 1950s.
“Will people be able to find the equilibrium in that market without knowing what we know as economists? ... And what astonished me was that they did.”
In two-person sequential game experiments, backward induction predicts that rational self-interested players defect, yet about half of subjects do not follow dominant strategies, and on average cooperators earn more than those playing the equilibrium strategy.
“a good half of our subjects don't follow dominant strategies... the people who follow cooperative strategies make more money than those who play the equilibrium”
After airline route deregulation in the 1970s, hub-and-spoke organization emerged unexpectedly, and attempts at nonstop service between secondary cities failed because passengers value departure frequency and will spend an extra hour routing through a hub to leave at a convenient time.
“people have a desire for certain for frequency of service which if it's not satisfied, they're willing to spend an extra hour going through a hub”
The hub-and-spoke equilibrium reflects a combination of traffic density, consumer preferences for service frequency, and the minimum profitable load factor on aircraft, a network problem so complex that formal models cannot easily set the parameters to match reality, though the industry found a stable equilibrium.
“there's a combination there of density of traffic consumer preferences the cost of kind of them the minimum profitable load factor on airplanes”
Fred Smith's hub insight was a constructivist model that he bet his own money on, and it was not copied by other airlines, which tried many alternatives before hub-and-spoke emerged, so competitors' experimentation discovered the structure rather than imitated a plan.
“They tried all these other different things and hubs and spokes is what came out.”
After airline deregulation in the 1970s, airlines were free to choose routes, and the industry spontaneously developed a hub-and-spoke system, which surprised transportation economists.
“how this hub and spoke uh form of organization emerged out of that deregulated uh uh airline industry”
Fred Smith's insight that FedEx should route every package through Memphis was a constructivist model that cut the total number of nightly flights by an enormous factor, and the airlines did not copy it; they tried other arrangements and hub-and-spoke emerged only from market trial.
“that insight wasn't copied by the airlines. They didn't all just say, Oh, then we should have hubs and spokes. They tried all these other different things”
Adam Smith's account of benevolence in The Theory of Moral Sentiments is essentially a theory of reciprocity and social exchange: people are benevolent toward those who have been benevolent to them, and human sympathy lets us read each other by imagining ourselves in others' situations.
“who are we likely to be benevolent toward? it's the people that have been benevolent toward us in the past... He's talking about reciprocity”
Constructivist rationality is the approach of building models through reason, such as the paper-and-pencil supply and demand model, that simplify reality so economists can reason about market equilibrium; economics took about a century after Adam Smith to develop this constructed model.
“the constructivist model which in of supply and demand took the economics profession oh uh about a century to find after you know, Adam Smith was writing”
Humans must live simultaneously in two orders with different rules, the small group and the extended order, and applying the rules of one to the other would destroy the wider civilization or crush intimate groups; Smith and Roberts agree people are biologically poorly equipped for this.
“so we must learn to live in two sorts of worlds at once... we're not very well equipped to live in those two sorts of worlds”
Federal Express routed every package through Memphis because the hub reduces the total number of nightly flights by an enormous factor, a counterintuitive cost saving that other airlines did not copy at first; they tried other arrangements before hub-and-spoke came out.
“his insight that it can be cheaper and therefore beneficial to have every package go through Memphis because it reduces the total number of flights by an enormous factor on any given night”
Adam Smith's propensity to truck, barter, and exchange is far broader than commercial shopping; it includes exchanges of favors and reciprocity, and these are real exchanges that generate gains.
“I have come to appreciate that it's much more uh comprehensive than just commercial exchange.”
If we can never fully understand how market prices emerge because the required information is not available to any one mind, then evaluating policy by traditional economic methods yields agnostic results and requires other methods to assess.
“We can never fully understand how this process works in the world because the required information is not given or available to any one mind.”
Smith's book states that we can never fully understand how the process of market prices works in the world, because the information required is not given or available to any one mind, which makes evaluating policy require methods beyond traditional economics.
“We can never fully understand how this process works in the world because the required information is not given or available to any one mind.”
In two-person sequential game experiments, game theory predicts backward induction leads to defection, yet about half of subjects do not follow dominant strategies, and on average the cooperative players earn more money than those who play the equilibrium.
“a good half of our subjects don't follow dominant strategies... the people who follow cooperative strategies make more money than those who play the equilibrium of the game”
The experimental results from hundreds or thousands of replications show that participants using only their own private information, buyers' maximum willingness to pay and sellers' minimum acceptable price, reach competitive equilibrium and capture consumer surplus through profit-motivated trade.
“this has been replicated hundreds, probably thousands, of times. Uh is simply their own private information”
Oral outcry double auctions and bid-ask markets, used by currency, stock, and commodity markets worldwide, converge to competitive equilibrium in experiments, while posted take-it-or-leave-it prices like those in retail markets also converge but take a longer time.
“those converge, too, although they tended to take somewhat longer period of time”
Experiments paid subjects real cash tied to their profits, so each subject's incentive matched the profit-maximizing assumption of the supply and demand model, and when subjects behaved as profit maximizers the market maximized total surplus and produced the predicted price and quantity; the design has been replicated thousands of times.
“these have been replicated hundreds, probably thousands, of times”
Walras's auctioneer, who calls out prices until excess supply and excess demand cancel, is an imaginary construct that real markets do not use; the London gold fixing comes closest but still differs from how markets explore prices.
“Walras originally conceived the idea of of an auctioneer... Well, that was an imaginary construct which no one uses out there in the real world”
Policy interventions often assume people will not change their baseline behavior, but they do; bailouts create moral hazard because lenders become less cautious when they expect the government to rescue them if things go wrong, and this future cost is rarely considered when crisis relief is designed.
“why should you worry about being cautious in the loan market if you come to believe that if things go awry the government will uh bail you out”
Constructivist rationality means building an explicit model, such as the paper-and-pencil supply and demand model, and reasoning from it; Smith's lab experiment instantiated that model with private buyer and seller values and cash payoffs, and participants still converged to the predicted equilibrium price and volume without knowing the theory.
“I turned to was the idea of doing constructing a laboratory experiment using the constructivist model and then borrowing from the world out there one of the trading institutions.”
After airline deregulation in the 1970s, the hub-and-spoke network emerged unplanned; attempts at nonstop service between secondary cities failed because passengers value flight frequency and will accept an extra hour through a hub for a more convenient departure time.
“people have a desire for certain for frequency of service which if it's not satisfied, they're willing to spend an extra hour going through a hub”
The apparent tension between Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments and The Wealth of Nations can be reconciled by treating favor-trading and sharing within local social groups as a form of exchange that generates gains, which is consistent with the anthropological evidence on how trade originated.
“I see the kind of trading of favors and sharing and uh local social groups as really an exchange system in which and and I would argue there's gains from that exchange.”
Religious prohibitions such as 'thou shalt not steal' and 'do not covet' encoded property-right rules as moral behavior, and these moral rules were later captured in formal legal order.
“I think an important part of it is the probably is rooted in in religious traditions that emphasized the uh you know, the great shall nots.”
The apparent tension between Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments, which emphasizes love, pride, and empathy, and The Wealth of Nations, which emphasizes self-interest, is resolved by treating favor-trading and sharing within local social groups as a form of exchange that yields gains.
“I see the kind of trading of favors and sharing and uh local social groups as really an exchange system in which and and I would argue there's gains from that exchange”
Cooperative strategies can be more profitable on average than the game-theoretic equilibrium strategy, so the apparent irrationality of not following dominant strategies may reflect a broader social rationality.
“the people who follow cooperative strategies make more money than those who play the equilibrium of the game”
Experiment subjects who find the competitive equilibrium cannot explain how they did it, and even when shown that no one could do better given others' behavior, they cannot model their own decision process; humans are very good at functioning in rule-governed systems but very hard to model.
“Can you model yourself? Well, they can't do it.”
Property rules and norms against theft and coveting, such as the commandments about possessions, were expressed as moral duties through religious traditions, and this moral framing later became encoded in formal legal systems, which helped enable market exchange with strangers.
“an important part of it that ... is probably rooted in in religious traditions that emphasized the great shall nots”
Federal Express initially sent every package through Memphis, Tennessee, which looked wasteful but reduced the total number of flights by an enormous factor each night and saved money relative to direct service, with some waste that was well spent.
“that hub system saves an enormous amount of money relative potentially relative to uh direct service route”
Hayek's point that people must live in two kinds of orders, the small-group microcosmos and the extended order, is important because applying small-group rules to the wider civilization would destroy it, and humans are biologically poorly equipped to live in both at once.
“biologically we're not very well equipped for that. No, we're not”
Markets do not destroy virtue; commercial enterprise has been as important and valuable as art and poetry, because commerce generates the wealth surplus that funds art, music, and the other activities that intellectuals often regard as superior.
“the commercial enterprise in the human career has been just as important and valuable as as the art enterprise”
Commerce is as valuable as art and poetry in human life: it creates wealth, and the surplus it generates funds art, music, and other activities intellectuals often rank above commerce, so markets do not destroy virtue.
“I think that's a wrong-headed view. I think uh the commercial enterprise in the human career has been just as important and valuable as as the art enterprise”
Double auction markets, the oral outcry bid-ask format used in currency, stock, and commodity markets worldwide, converge to equilibrium in experiments; posted-price retail-style markets also converge but take noticeably longer.
“And those converge, too, although they tended to take somewhat longer period of time.”
Government bailouts of mortgage lenders create moral hazard: if lenders expect the government to rescue them, they will be less cautious in lending, so the intervention makes future problems worse even as it relieves present distress.
“why should you worry about being cautious in the loan market if you come to believe that if things go awry the government will uh bail you out”
Trade evolved from exchange systems in families, extended families, and tribes into exchange with strangers, money, and global trade, but the historical path from kin exchange to trade with strangers is largely lost and poorly understood.
“What we don't know is how that may have evolved into trade with strangers.”
Economic policy is built on models with policy variables that ask how to set them optimally, but this is an abstract exercise that leaves open whether the policies will work in the world, and because any policy affects people differently, choosing among them is a problem economics has not solved satisfactorily.
“but the best policy, any policies usually going to affect us all differently. And so how we choose between those is a problem that economics has struggled with.”
The mainstream textbook model of economic man, a utility maximizer subject to an income constraint with perhaps some altruism added, should be tempered with Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments and with multidisciplinary perspectives that treat humans as connected through non-market processes.
“I guess I would temper it with uh a healthy dose of reading from Adam Smith and The Theory of Moral Sentiments.”
Hub-and-spoke airline organization is a case where Smith's experiments and FedEx show that a profit-and-loss system with free passengers and free firms gives robust outcomes that no single planner designed.
“a profit and loss system which with passengers free to choose uh airline companies free to choose and making adjustments over time gave you uh an equilibrium that is very robust”
Economic policy is typically designed as an abstract optimization over policy variables, which leaves open how the policy will actually work in the world; any policy affects people differently, so choosing among policies is a problem economics has not solved satisfactorily.
“but the best policy, any policies usually going to affect us all differently. And so how we choose between those is a problem that economics has struggled with.”
The hub-and-spoke airline equilibrium resulted from a combination of traffic density, consumer preferences, and the minimum profitable load factor, a problem so complex and network-based that the formal models could not capture it without knowing the right parameters.
“even if you formally model it, you don't know what where to set the parameters”
The hub-and-spoke airline equilibrium is robust and is an example of an ecological equilibrium that formal models have not dissipated, partly because even formal models do not reliably specify the parameters needed to match real-world conditions.
“even if you formally model it, you don't know what where to set the parameters”
Trade originally grew out of exchange systems within families, extended families, and tribes; how these evolved into trade with strangers and then money and global trade is poorly understood because that history has been lost.
“What we don't know is how that may have evolved into trade with strangers.”
The textbook model of economic man as a utility maximizer subject to income is a good model that economists were right to pursue, but it should be tempered by Adam Smith's account of sympathy and non-market connections, and economics education and research should be more multidisciplinary.
“I guess I would temper it with a healthy dose of reading from Adam Smith and The Theory of Moral Sentiments”
Economic policymakers often assume they can intervene to improve outcomes while people leave their baseline behavior unchanged, and this assumption is a recurring error in policy design.
“people assume they can intervene in some way and and make the world better but people will not change their fundamental base baseline behavior”
The puzzle is that individual transactors use their reason quite limitedly when they trade, yet the entire market system is surprisingly rational, whereas the theorists who built the supply and demand model used reason intensively to reach it.
“why the individual transactors in those interactions either in the experiments that you've conducted or out in the real world uh have much less limited use of their reason”
People carry into markets the intuition that good is deliberately produced by good acts, such as returning a favor, and this leads them to try to improve markets by intervening in arrangements that already work well and should be left alone.
“we carry that type of of thinking and reasoning over when we look at markets. And we say, Well, surely we can we can improve on these markets”
The benefits of markets are not directly experienced by individuals, so people perceive markets as biased toward sellers when they are buyers, and they overlook the discipline each side imposes on the other, which is as hidden as the equilibrium outcome of a classroom experiment.
“the good that markets do is not something we experience directly as individuals”
In double auction markets, participants respond to the bids and offers of others and dynamically adjust their behavior, and this response yields the predicted equilibrium that maximizes their surplus, even though they are not consciously computing it.
“they're taking into account the information in bids and offers that are being provided others by others”
The interior world of the human mind is the last frontier of exploration, and it may be impossible for the mind to fully understand itself, because the brain and social interaction produce capacities that resist constructivist modeling.
“can the mind understand itself? And you know, it's not clear that it can”
It is puzzling that individual traders use limited reason in actual markets, yet the overall system behaves with surprising rationality; the theory of equilibrium rests on theorists' reasoning, not on what participants consciously calculate.
“why the individual transactors in those interactions... have much less limited use of their reason... and yet it turns out that the entire system is surprisingly rational”
Ecological equilibrium arises when people, through repeated trade over time using their own devices and whatever trading institution exists, reach outcomes that match the supply and demand model's prices and volumes, even though they never model the process themselves.
“people find these equilibria if they have a chance to engage in repeat and repeat trade over time”
Adam Smith's notion of the human propensity to truck, barter, and exchange is broader than commercial exchange and reaches into everyday reciprocal dealings among people.
“Well, I have come to appreciate that it's much more uh comprehensive than just commercial exchange.”
People carry their intuition that good is deliberately produced, from social exchange, into markets, leading them to try to improve markets through intervention when those markets are already working effectively and should be left alone.
“we carry that type of thinking and reasoning over when we look at markets... we can improve on these markets out there by intervening”
The good that markets do is not experienced directly by individuals, so people interpret markets as biased in favor of whichever side they are on; buyers do not see the discipline sellers face and vice versa, just as students in a supply and demand experiment do not see their collective gain.
“the good that markets do is not something we experience directly as individuals”
Ecological rationality is the process in which people using their own devices in repeated trade over time reach the price and volume predicted by the supply and demand model, and the outcome can be called rational because the model explains why it is rational, even though real markets are a moving target.
“that is an example of a what I mean by an ecological equilibrium, in which people using their own devices”
Economists are boundedly rational too: the problem of modeling how people solve the problems they cannot explain is so hard that theorists cannot solve it, which is a more apt use of bounded rationality than applying it only to people.
“I like to talk about the bounded rationality of theorists. Uh this is such a challenging problem that we can't solve it.”
A central theme of the book is that people solve many life problems, such as how to behave in a marketplace, in ways they do not understand themselves, yet produce outcomes with attractive properties.
“we solve a lot of problems in life, like how to behave in a marketplace... in ways that we don't understand ourselves, and yet manage to produce solutions or outcomes that have attractive properties”
Adam Smith's The Theory of Moral Sentiments describes social exchange through reciprocity: people are more benevolent toward those who were benevolent to them, and human sympathy lets people read each other by imagining their situation.
“who are we likely to be benevolent toward? It's the people that have been benevolent toward us in the past. He's talking about reciprocity”
Humans solve market problems that they do not understand because participants respond to others' bids and offers using social cognition, not only self-interest, and this responsive behavior dynamically converges on the surplus-maximizing equilibrium.
“they're taking into account the information in bids and offers that are being provided others by others... responding to that in a way that turns out to be dynamically the right way”
Entrepreneurs with real stakes have stronger incentives than outside critics to figure out whether an unusual business design is sound, so a student's first reaction that the Memphis hub is stupid should give way to the presumption that the founder has thought it through.
“Fred Smith probably has a slightly bigger incentive than you do to figure out whether it's a good idea or not”
Modeling how people solve market problems is so difficult that it reflects the bounded rationality of theorists, not merely of the people being modeled, since theorists cannot yet solve the problem of formally describing this process.
“I like to talk about the bounded rationality of theorists. Uh this is such a challenging problem that we can't solve it.”
Entrepreneurs like Fred Smith often bet other people's money: Fred Smith put his own money and his sister's money into FedEx without their agreement, and was later sued by his family over the trust fund.
“He put his sister's money in, too, without their uh agreeing. He was sued by them for taking money out of the family trust fund.”
Walras's auctioneer model of price adjustment, in which prices are tried until excess supply and excess demand vanish, is an imaginary construct that no real market uses, though the London gold fixing comes closest.
“Walras originally uh conceived the idea of of an auctioneer who would try out different prices”
Humans walked out of Africa roughly 50,000 years ago with tools and eventually settled the entire planet, with the migration largely completed by about a thousand years ago, when Polynesians settled New Zealand roughly 500 years before square-rigged sailing ships were invented.
“that's when New Zealand was was settled by uh by humans, the Polynesians. And that's 500 years before they before they square-rigger sailing ship had been invented.”
Freedom is essential because it lets people discover new ways of connecting and new institutions, and technologies such as the internet and blogs are expanding the means for people to link up through markets and other forms of communication.
“it's through freedom that people are able to discover new ways of connecting uh creating of new institutions”
Freedom is essential because it lets people discover new ways of connecting and new institutions, and new communication technologies such as blogs and markets expand the possibilities for people to link up.
“this points to really the important role of of freedom and our society because it's through freedom that people are able to discover new ways of connecting”
Supply and demand is an intellectual construct that simplifies an extraordinarily complex set of buying and selling interactions, and it took economists about a century after Adam Smith to find a clear model of how preferences show up as demand and production costs as supply.
“the constructivist model which in of supply and demand took the economics profession oh uh about a century to find after you know, Adam Smith was writing”
Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments is a major work in its own right, first published in 1759 and substantially rewritten shortly before his death, which shows it was central to his thinking.
“it's tragedy that people think he wrote one great book. He wrote two great books.”
Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments and The Wealth of Nations are often presented as contradictory: one says people are motivated by love, pride, and approval, the other by self-interest.
“some claim that those two views of the human being are contradictory”
Adam Smith's Moral Sentiments and Wealth of Nations are two great books, and Adam Smith's reputation suffers because people think he wrote only one.
“It's tragedy that people think he wrote one great book. He wrote two great books.”
Smith's experiments were designed by building a laboratory market from supply and demand theory, borrowing real trading institutions such as the double auction, and asking whether people without economists' knowledge could find equilibrium.
“Will people be able to find the equilibrium in that market uh without knowing what we know as economists?”
The constructivist supply and demand model predicts that profit-maximizing participants will maximize total surplus and produce the textbook equilibrium price and quantity, and experiments confirm this prediction.
“if people behave rationally as profit maximizers they will maximize the surplus generated in the market and they'll produce an equilibrium in price and quantity”
Technology has always been central to human achievement; early humans left Africa about 50,000 years ago with their tools, and Polynesians settled New Zealand about 1,000 years ago, roughly 500 years before the square-rigger sailing ship was invented.
“they uh they ultimately settled the entire uh planet. Uh And this and and that migration was pretty well completed by a thousand years ago.”
The brain's valuation of money as a reward is an open question for currency debasement: after governments inflate the money supply, the brain must eventually register that money has lost value, but how the brain makes this adjustment is unknown and neuroeconomics might answer it.
“Clearly, at some point the brain must make a switch and realize that this is not the same as commodity”
The interior world of the human mind, and the role of information, knowledge, and creativity within it, is the last frontier, one that will never be closed, and it is unclear whether the mind can understand itself.
“can the mind understand itself? And you know, it's not clear that it can”
In a classroom supply-and-demand experiment, the group-optimal result is transparent to the instructor but not to the students, who do not connect their own successful bidding to the market's welfare outcome, so the same non-transparency appears in the real world.
“it's not part of their experience. It's part of of our attempt to get them to understand what that exercise is about in the you know, in our follow-up.”
Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments was first published in 1759 and substantially rewritten, finished about six weeks before his death, making it his first and last love.
“the first edition was in 1759 if I am remember correctly. He made did a major rewrite of that book and finished it about 6 weeks before his death”
Psychology did not build on Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments because people were not ready for it, and psychology only became a defined field about a century later, even though Smith anticipated much of social psychology.
“that book didn't become the foundation of psychology... people just weren't ready for it”
Critics see hub-and-spoke routing as inefficient, but passengers do not account for the cost of direct service, so their complaints ignore the savings from consolidating flights.
“They don't think about what it would cost to service that direct route. And so they just complain.”
It is unclear whether the mind can understand itself, since the brain and social interaction produce capacities that are very hard to capture with constructivist modeling.
“can the mind understand itself? And you know, it's not clear that it can”
The frontier of human exploration is now the interior world of the human mind, involving information, knowledge, and creativity, which will never be closed.
“we've turned to the interior world of the human mind, the role of of information and knowledge and creativity as as it's the last frontier”
Many people view the hub-and-spoke system negatively and complain about having to connect, but they do not consider what it would cost to serve a direct route.
“They don't think about what it would cost to service that direct route. And so they just complain.”
Policymakers who think about moral hazard deeply tend to keep that concern to themselves when addressing current distress, because pointing it out is unpopular.
“If they do think about it deeply, they keep it to themselves, I think.”
Human exploration has been driven by an entrepreneurial and inventive spirit combined with social connections within tribes, and this drive is now being hugely leveraged by rapid technological growth.
“I think that was very much driven uh by uh by entrepreneurial spirit in humans an inventive spirit”
Human exploration and settlement was driven by entrepreneurial and inventive spirit, and social connections inside tribes made them powerful explorers, a capacity now hugely leveraged by technology.
“I think that was very much driven uh by uh by entrepreneurial spirit in humans an inventive spirit”
Psychology could have been founded on Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments, which anticipated social psychology, but people were not ready for it, and psychology only became a defined field about a century later.
“in a way the great tragedy is that that book didn't become the foundation of psychology”
An open question for neuroeconomics is how the brain adapts when governments debase the money supply and inflation erodes currency value, since the brain must at some point stop treating money as a commodity like food, and nobody yet knows how that switch happens.
“What happens when uh the state debauches the money supply?”
The ability of people who solve problems to explain how they did it is limited, and this gap gives market rationality a mystical character; neuroscience so far confirms only the limits of our understanding of reason.
“that people who solve problems can't explain how they do it. Um which um leads to a certain respect, I think, for the um the mystical nature”
Constructivist rationality means reasoning through simplified models that economists build, such as the paper-and-pencil supply and demand model, and then trying to give those models life through stories about how people actually behave.
“we tend to think in terms of models that we construct. And, you know, the good example is the paper and pencil model of supply and demand.”
Entrepreneurs often do not risk their own money but find others willing to bet on them, and Fred Smith's hub idea had earlier roots in an undergraduate paper he wrote at Yale.
“it goes back to a paper he wrote as an undergraduate, I believe, at Yale.”
Fred Smith, who founded Federal Express, bet his own money and his sister's money, which he took from a family trust fund without their agreement and was later sued for, on a constructivist hub model he had outlined in an undergraduate paper.
“He put his sister's money in, too, without their uh agreeing. He was sued by them for taking money out of the family trust fund.”
Smith's motivation for experimental economics was that he could not see how the textbook supply and demand story connected to what buyers and sellers actually do in markets, so he built a laboratory market to test it.
“I found it difficult to understand the connection between the way we tell the supply and demand story and what it is that people do actually do in markets”
Economics education and basic research should expose the economic model to broader considerations such as non-market connections among humans, though not all economists need to become multidisciplinary.
“not that all economists should now become multi-disciplinary”
Roberts summarizes the book's main theme: people solve many life problems, such as how to behave in a market, in ways they do not understand themselves, yet produce outcomes with attractive properties.
“your claim, and I think a theme that runs through the book, is that we solve a lot of problems in life... in ways that we don't understand ourselves”
Economics education and research should be more multidisciplinary, but not every economist must become multidisciplinary; the key is to expose the standard economic model to broader considerations such as moral and non-market connections.
“not that all economists should now become multi-disciplinary. My point is simply that... it's important to expose that economic model to broader”