revealed preference
The economics principle that people's actual choices reveal their true preferences better than their stated ones.
As defined in cwt_bryan-caplan
Other definitions
The principle that consumer behavior reveals preferences more accurately than stated preferences; what people actually choose reveals what they truly want
The Fertility Crisis: Capitalism's Next Challenge, with Sir Niall FergusonEconomic concept that true preferences are inferred from actual choices and behavior rather than stated intentions.
Finding Your Favorite Thing
Where it comes up · 24
- Richard Epstein on Happiness, Inequality, and Envy 11/3/20083 claims
- Jennifer Frey on Education, Philosophy, and the University3 claims
- Will MacAskill on Longtermism and What We Owe the Future3 claims
- Mike Munger on Subsidies and Externalities 05/24/20083 claims
- Tyler Cowen and Russ Roberts on Nation, Immigration, and Israel2 claims
- Anupam Bapu Jena on Random Acts of Medicine2 claims
- Doing “The Best Things First,” with Bjorn Lomborg | Uncommon Knowledge1 claim
- How Great Founders Tell Their Story1 claim
and 16 more
Most important claims · 10 of 34Search all claims for “revealed preference” →
- A successful division of labor requires large numbers of people: even 100 maximally talented, diverse people on a resource-rich island would remain poor because they cannot exploit Smithian gains from specialization; the prosperity of eight billion people specializing is an underappreciated miracle, and 80 million survivors might need huge fractions devoted to subsistence farming, making recovery to modern living standards very slow.Will MacAskill on Longtermism and What We Owe the Future
- Varian's 1982 paper on the nonparametric approach to demand analysis directly inspired his model of Google's ad auction, because the auction equilibrium conditions are revealed-preference inequalities—'I'd rather be in my position paying my price than in another position'—that you manipulate to derive a formula for the price, just as in the demand paper.Hal Varian
- Big choices like marriage or career cannot be reduced to revealed preference for whichever option maximizes day-to-day enjoyment, because such choices involve pride, sense of purpose, and meaning that cannot be honestly traded off into a single scalar; with choices like having kids, you are choosing what kind of person you want to be, which is precisely what utilitarian calculus cannot adjudicate.Tyler Cowen and Russ Roberts on Nation, Immigration, and Israel
- Rice and dairy subsidies justified as protecting national culture are often unnecessary: if consumers valued domestic rice or milk enough, they would pay for it, so a subsidy signals that consumers would not pay the price.Mike Munger on Subsidies and Externalities 05/24/2008
- Economists assume a preference-satisfaction theory of wellbeing (what's good is getting what you want), but MacAskill prefers a theory where wellbeing is a matter of positive versus negative conscious experiences; on the latter view, people's preferences (e.g., against dying) only imperfectly track their wellbeing because evolution would bias us toward survival regardless of experiential quality.Will MacAskill on Longtermism and What We Owe the Future
- People already understand that high pay compensates for unpleasant work: when high earners report unhappiness, they are accurately reflecting a trade-off in which they sacrificed some happiness to earn greater wealth, so reported unhappiness is not evidence of a policy failure.Richard Epstein on Happiness, Inequality, and Envy 11/3/2008
- The economist's utilitarian framework monetizes pleasure and pain to create a common scale, but that scale depends on how much money each person has, so it is not a real scale of pleasure and pain but only a scale for one individual, making interpersonal comparison of costs and benefits effectively impossible—and the desire to aggregate net gains into a single policy verdict is therefore a fool's game.Tyler Cowen and Russ Roberts on Nation, Immigration, and Israel
- The behavioral literature's serious challenge to economics is that revealed preference ignores regret: people may choose high-paying jobs and later, after decades of 90-hour weeks, find the outcome to be ashes, a regret the choice-based framework does not register.Richard Epstein on Happiness, Inequality, and Envy 11/3/2008
- When Apple gave Facebook users the power to opt out of spying via a checkbox, 96% of Apple users ticked the box, demonstrating that revealed preference for spying is overridden when users have actual choice and countervailing power.We Didn’t Ask for This Internet | The Ezra Klein Show
- Economists' hope of inferring preferences purely from observed choices fails because the same observed action (e.g., eating a glob of wasabi) is ambiguous between very different underlying mental states, so you cannot interpret choices without letting at least some psychology back in.337 | Kevin Zollman on Game Theory, Signals, and Meaning