
Richard Epstein on Happiness, Inequality, and Envy 11/3/2008
What this covers
This EconTalk conversation pairs host Russ Roberts with Richard Epstein of the University of Chicago, and Epstein does nearly all the talking. It starts from the happiness literature and its finding that wealth and reported happiness are only weakly correlated. Epstein takes issue with how that finding is put to use. He argues it rests on the doubtful and unstated premise that redistribution would make the poor happier. He also challenges the behavioral economics experiments behind much of the research, because they put isolated subjects in artificial settings with no feedback and no chance to consult family, mentors, or religious communities. He grants one serious challenge to revealed preference: it cannot register regret, as when someone decades into 90-hour weeks finds the outcome to be ashes.
The middle of the discussion turns to evolution. Epstein draws on Charles Darwin and Bill Hamilton to argue that inclusive fitness explains why family behavior departs from narrow self-interest. He says it also explains a wider "halo" of empathy and why cooperation does not collapse into the prisoner's dilemma. On this view the happiness literature wrongly assumes hedonism, since raising children requires enduring worry and distress. He treats relative status comparisons as inevitable, and as a reason within-group rankings matter once wealth stops differentiating people.
The policy sections range more widely. Epstein presents the Superstar Market Effect benignly. He locates inequality in institutions such as weak early schooling, entry barriers, and union and minimum-wage rules, and he cites Jim Heckman on the returns to early education. He prefers a consistent pollution tax to a $4 gasoline target. The most contested stretch, and the widest, concerns the state itself. He says the basic problem of social organization is a state monopoly of force that stops private predators without becoming one, and he judges governments by the risk of rare catastrophes such as a tyrant taking over.
Epstein argues the happiness and behavioral economics literatures are mainly used to justify redistribution and anti-growth policy, and that people already trade off wealth against happiness through revealed choices, so the right response is to preserve free markets with a no-aggression rule and fix institutions that trap the poor.
- Happiness research undercuts the self-interest model to justify redistribution, but the weak wealth-happiness correlation does not show that taking wealth makes the poor happier
- People already trade pay against happiness, so information and individual choice beat coercion
- Inequality problems stem from bad institutions such as poor schooling, entry barriers, and union and minimum-wage rules, not from market outcomes
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Small everyday decisions are made effortlessly through repetition, but rare enormous decisions such as marriage or choosing cancer treatment are made under low familiarity, and people face them when their internal resources are most strained, so they must rely on others.
“if it turns out that repetition familiarity ease the pain of decision then we find ourselves in the position where where our resources are most strapped at the times that we need the most”
Policies like $4 gasoline to reduce driving sacrifice consumption benefits; the better approach is a consistent tax on pollution set at roughly the measured environmental damage, with the price of oil still varying with market conditions, so people consume more when the opportunity cost is low.
“the right way to do this in my judgment is to have a tax on pollution which roughly measures the environmental damage impose that consistently and then let the price vary with market conditions”
Early childhood education yields the highest returns: each dollar spent at age four or five has more positive impact than later spending, and a weak early education means a student will cost twice as much to catch up a year later, citing Heckman's argument that delaying education is a rounding error relative to the added cost of remediation.
“if you could get to a kid at age four or five every dollar you put in there is going to have more impact on a positive way”
Inclusive fitness shows individuals act to advance the welfare of genetic relatives in proportion to shared genes, so a parent will spend $1 to yield $2 of benefit to a child, because the child shares half the parent's genes and the trade is neutral in genetic terms.
“that individual in some sense or holders for their gene and that what there is a principle known as inclusive fitness”
The greatest social risk is not petty thuggery, which is limited to a few houses, but the centralized state's power to murder millions; the basic problem of social organization is securing a state monopoly of force that stops private predators without becoming a predator itself.
“the real risk of the thug because when the thug has the power of the state to murder millions of people”
Government should be assessed like a stock market investment with attention to low-probability catastrophic events, such as a tyrant taking over, rather than short-term modest risks; the U.S. Constitution's fragmentation of power makes heroic government functions harder but also makes tyranny harder.
“the genius of our Constitution with its multiple structures has always been to fragment power to the point where it becomes harder for anyone to perform heroic functions”
The superstar economics effect, in which technology lets the best athletes, entertainers, and movie stars reach larger audiences, inflates their salaries relative to the mean, and Epstein views this benignly and finds it inspiring.
“the opportunity for the best athletes the best entertainers the best movie stars to reach larger and larger audiences has inflated their salaries”
Darwin argued emotions are subject to evolutionary pressure: behaviors that advance inclusive fitness become emotionally rewarding, because otherwise the psychological dissonance between what one does and what one would like to do would be too great, so parental love is an evolved emotion that binds people to their children.
“one of the great insights of Darwin early on when he started this is he said that emotions are not immune from evolutionary pressures”
People already understand that high pay compensates for unpleasant work: when high earners report unhappiness, they are accurately reflecting a trade-off in which they sacrificed some happiness to earn greater wealth, so reported unhappiness is not evidence of a policy failure.
“that the extra compensation is in fact compensation for being unhappy so when people report that they're not happy what they're doing is they're giving an accurate reflection”
The happiness literature falsely assumes hedonism, which is incompatible with species perpetuation, because evolution requires parents to endure distress for offspring; emotions such as dread and worry about children are adaptive, and the happiness measure misses them.
“the happiness literature falsely assumes the kind of hedonism which is incapable with evolutionary some perpetuation of the species”
Evolutionary psychology, founded on the observation that pure individual self-interest could not sustain reproduction or child-rearing, explains why family behavior departs from the self-interest model; W.D. Hamilton's inclusive fitness shows people act to advance the welfare of genetic relatives in proportion to shared genes.
“the key insight from that comes from a man named W D Hamilton now what he was able to show and to show quite persuasively was that individual in some sense or holders for their gene”
Littering shows private norm enforcement: a bystander who confronts a litterer bears a discrete cost to benefit the larger group, and when many people do this, norm enforcement becomes far more feasible than narrow egoism would predict.
“what they're doing in effect is having a private enforcement of a social norm for the benefit of a larger group at some discrete cost to themselves”
The behavioral literature's serious challenge to economics is that revealed preference ignores regret: people may choose high-paying jobs and later, after decades of 90-hour weeks, find the outcome to be ashes, a regret the choice-based framework does not register.
“the serious challenge of that behavioral literature to this conversation is that reveal preference ignores regret”
No economic system, socialist or capitalist, can insulate people from hard choices or remove uncertainty; guaranteeing a stable income to a group such as farmers shifts fluctuations onto those paying the subsidies, so uncertainty is reduced instead through stable legal rules rather than redistribution.
“the old Hayekian inside if you decide to certain people your farm is you're entitled to a stable income we're going to guarantee it to you it means that all the fluctuations in the economy are going to be borne by those people”
The happiness literature's finding of only a weak correlation between happiness and wealth is used to justify taking wealth from the rich, but that reasoning rests on the unspoken and doubtful premise that redistribution makes the poor happier.
“the implication I think that they tried to draw from this is it's ok to take away of the wealth because it doesn't make the people who had it less happy”
Social support networks such as family, religious communities, and mentors are critical for high-stakes decisions, because people deciding alone make more mistakes, while the behavioral experiments studied people in isolation without feedback or consultation.
“for these high risk high high stakes decision people try to make them alone always make mistakes and that's when you need a really strong family or religious support network”
Relative wealth matters in happiness studies because with little variance in absolute wealth within a peer group, people rank themselves through informal social status; status competition is inevitable, but the happiness literature wrongly claims that people become happy by making others miserable.
“what the happiness literature suggests and there's now it's the miseries of literature is that the way you become happy is to make the other fellow miserable”
Evolutionary inclusive fitness produces a halo of empathy extending beyond family, so people care about their children's friends and about unrelated people in danger, and this explains why social organizations and cooperation avoid the outcomes predicted by prisoner's dilemma games.
“the whole theory of inclusive fitness tends to create a halo effect weaker than family obviously but stronger than nothing”
Behavioral economics experiments are misleading because they place isolated subjects in artificial settings with no feedback or opportunity to consult others, whereas real decisions are made in groups with learning and feedback.
“the literature on behavioral ISM always has everybody acting in voids so if you look at all the experiments it's not how people get together and figure out how to come on words”
Competition creates variation, and variation creates excellence: a common standardized education in France and England routes people into fixed tracks with no hybridization, whereas American law school classes mixing bankers, paralegals, and mid-career students produce richer and stronger graduates.
“competition and effect creates variation variation creates excellent”
The Hobbesian world, in which everyone is relentlessly individualistic and cooperation depends on secure enforceable promises, does not describe reality, because most people, given a chance, cooperate in a first interaction rather than defect as in a prisoner's dilemma.
“the Hobbesian world where in effect what's going on is quite the opposite where everybody's relentlessly individualistic”
In medical decisions, people face diminished confidence in their own internal resources during serious illness and must rely on others, so support systems matter greatly, and no economic system, socialist or capitalist, can insulate people from hard choices or remove uncertainty.
“particularly in the medical area it's even worse because as you're faced with the decision of your life you're now dealing with your own diminished confidence in your own internal resources”
The rising U.S. inequality is worsened by a systematic decline in public education quality in states, correlated with family breakup and with strong unions and government oversight, so the appropriate remedy is deregulation rather than transfer taxation.
“we've seen a systematic decline in the level of public education in the you know states which correlates with the breakup of the family”
Some argue that extra consumption produces only illusory happiness and that people should stay closer to home with family, but this conflicts with revealed preference, since people visibly make sacrifices and work hard for raises and advancement, suggesting that the survey-based critics are assuming people operate under deep illusions about happiness.
“we have the theory of revealed preferences at the same time we are constantly told that wealth as a matter of complete indifference for the happiness”
Relative wealth does matter in some studies, but the happiness data's apparent contradiction with absolute wealth findings is resolved if people compare themselves within groups of similar wealth, where wealth stops differentiating and informal social ranking becomes the main means of self-assessment.
“since the wealth variation or the wealth component is relatively fixed the only way in which people can rank and understand themselves is in fact through these informal social ranking”
Since the 1970s, measured US income inequality has risen mainly because returns to education have grown at the high end and the economy has become more entrepreneurial, with superstar markets letting top athletes, entertainers, and movie stars reach larger audiences and earn much more relative to the mean.
“the economic part of it that's clearly the case is that returns to education have seemed to have risen especially at the high end and we have a more entrepreneurial”
The two-tier income structure reflects a two-tier education system: suburban schools and private schools serve the affluent well, while large urban public school monopolies trap most students, and resistance to vouchers and charter schools blocks escape.
“you're basically having a situation where the two-tier income you're seeing is in part from a two-tier educational system”
Human sentiments tilt the balance toward pro-social behavior, so the world is easier to organize socially than a Hobbesian world of relentless individualism, although some outliers remain who must be worried about, and most people, when given a chance, do not begin with a fatal prisoner's dilemma interaction.
“it's a much easiest world to organize socially than the Hobbesian world where in effect what's going on is quite the opposite”
In cities such as Los Angeles and New York, a third, a quarter, or half of a class cannot make it through high school, and social promotions hide this failure, so bad public institutions, including unionization, minimum wage laws, public school operation, and resistance to vouchers and charter schools, are a major cause of bottom-end inequality.
“you'll have a third or a quarter or a half of a class not being able to make it through you know call it high school”
Resistance to school vouchers and charter schools traps low-income families in large public school monopolies with no escape, and even capable leaders such as New York City's chancellor or Chicago's Arne Duncan cannot fix systems serving hundreds of thousands of students under such impediments.
“the resistance to vouchers into charter schools are yet the others so you're basically having a situation”
The problem of rising inequality lies at the bottom, where minimum wage laws, unionization, and protective employment legislation raise barriers to entry, so low-ability workers cannot get the first job step; the remedy is deregulation rather than transfer taxation.
“the barriers at the bottom to entry are much more difficult because it's not just minimum wage laws it's a whole variety of situations”
High marginal tax rates forcing people to lead more virtuous lives are a bad policy, since high earners who want to accumulate wealth put it into investment from which the rest of society benefits.
“the last thing I think you want to do in effect is to say that we want to have government policies like very high marginal tax rates on income”
Harlem Success Academy shows that high expectations and back-to-basics instruction (standing in line, learning letters and multiplication) allow children from poor communities to make rapid progress, with kindergartners who could barely write letters advancing to visibly strong third-grade work.
“the expectations there are really very different from what they are in the public school system day one they walk into class”
Human traits such as self-interest and generosity are distributed with variability, most people cluster in the middle with modest concern for others, a few are selfish outliers, and a few are professional do-gooders; the legal system should suppress the bad actors and encourage the do-gooders rather than tax them.
“if you look at most of the distribution people be custard about the middle with a modest appreciation of the welfare of others and then there'll be some people at the top who professional do-gooders”
The two literatures can be reconciled by recognizing that every trait, including self-interest and generosity, is distributed with variability across people, so the outcome depends on the tails and the middle of the distribution rather than on a single typical person.
“the most natural characteristic for every particular trait that you can mention is variability on a self-interest measure”
In experiments where people can invest 10 to produce 12 for themselves or 20 for a group of four, a surprising number choose the group option, expanding the total pie even at a net personal loss of 7 units, so people will share in expanding rather than shrinking the pot.
“it turns out they're a surprising number of people when it comes to making their choices and these artificial settings are willing to kind of expand and to share the wealth simultaneously”
Regret is symmetric: people regret both risky choices that failed to happen and cautious choices they made, so life will always generate regret, and no institution can remove it.
“the point about this and the wish I would insist upon is it goes both ways”
Behavioral economics shows people make computational errors and act under systemic uncertainty and ignorance, but behavioral research has no brief for using force against other individuals, so the negative side of the utilitarian calculus against aggression remains intact.
“other behavioral list as best I can tell have no particular brief for the use of force against other individuals so the negative side of the utilitarian calculus remains pretty much intact”
Envy is a terrible emotion that a small minority feels; most people are cheerful about others' success, and the envy that does arise in businesses stems mainly from perceived unfairness when peers in the same position work at unequal effort but receive unequal rewards.
“what you do see all the time is a very different phenomenon which is if you have two people in roughly same position and one person is slacking and the other one has to take the work”
Envy-driven resentment in workplaces is mostly not directed at colleagues who earn more for more training; it arises when two people in similar positions contribute unequally, with the slacker's lower effort and similar pay generating resentment, and a manager who fails to address this will lose good workers and retain bad ones.
“if you have two people in roughly same position and one person is slacking and the other one has to take the work then the resentments are really great”
Inequality that generates resentment is not born of natural ability differences but of circumstances created by social institutions, many of them championed by the advocates of modern social programs, and therefore is indefensible and improvable.
“it's unfortunately it's the champions of many of our modern social programs who are the source of the kinds of indefensible inequalities”
If people care about relative status and can't raise their rank through market success, they may try to knock others down, producing a suicide contest in which everyone tries to subvert neighbors; the Russian proverb about the genie and the neighbor's cow illustrates this.
“you're prepared to knock somebody else down at which point we have a suicide contest everybody is trying to figure out how to subvert neighbor”
A market arranges jobs along a spectrum from high-pay, low-happiness to low-pay, high-happiness, and people with different utility functions choose different points based on family commitments and tolerance for sacrifice, so the market accommodates heterogeneous preferences without outside decision-making.
“you could kind of rank jobs out there and at one side there are high pay low happiness jobs and at the other side there were low pay high happiness jobs”
Adding the variability of human nature back into the cooperation-yes, aggression-no maxim shows that a self-interested person cannot take a neighbor's cow by force, but a prosocial person can cooperate to get ahead, so the system works fairly well and the variation intensifies pressure on prosocial people.
“if you say cooperation yes then the guy with empty can go out and cooperate with somebody else and instead of having no cows can leapfrog the first guy”
Regret and uncertainty cannot be eliminated, so people need better training and stronger family or religious support networks, since people who make high-stakes decisions alone tend to make mistakes.
“for these high risk high high stakes decision people try to make them alone always make mistakes and that's when you need a really strong family or religious support network”
Rather than coercing career choices, society should adopt an information strategy by publishing what jobs involve, so people can project the trade-offs onto their own lives; lawyers who earn $250,000 at three years out often move to public interest work at a third of the pay because they value the work more.
“my own attitude about this is that well we should adopt an information strategy rather than a coercion strategy publish anything you want”
The United States' dynamic labor and marriage markets lower the cost of errors relative to stratified societies because people can change jobs and partners, whereas in more rigid systems a single early choice can lock in a person's lot for life.
“we have a pretty dynamic marriage market in the United States people move among jobs and marital partners and as a result the cost of errors are lower”
Behavioral and neoclassical models are solipsistic, treating individuals as isolated actors, and they miss the natural human tendency to cooperate with friends and trusted partners, which generates gains from trade through informal team production and knowledge sharing.
“they are almost always solipsistic everybody sort of out there doing things themselves and the natural tendency on the part of people to cooperate not with everybody but with those whom they like”
Forcing workers to keep a constant ratio of happiness to income at every life stage would be an unjustified restriction on freedom, and it would also eliminate the gains from trade in international mega-deals that require people to travel on short notice.
“if we want to say that nobody should be doing these kinds of things because everybody will be miserable all the gains from trade that come from some of these international transactions will be left to go by the wayside”
Children from poor communities who attend strong charter schools will do well, but if placed in inferior public institutions with no escape they will do much worse, so inequality should be addressed by fixing institutions rather than by equalizing outcomes.
“those kids will do alright because the education is much better but if you drop them in inferior public institutions”
New parents are stunned by how strong biological impulses are, beginning in pregnancy, and emotional change after childbirth cannot be explained by prior academic reasoning, because evolution does not rely on cognition for its most important functions and instead uses emotions that run continuously.
“mother nature does not involve does not rely on to your cognition to handle its most important functions brains with high intelligence are too unreliable”
Michael Jordan's peak salary of roughly $30 million a year is small relative to consumer surplus: if each of many viewers paid about a penny per game across 80 to 100 games a year, the total would dwarf the salary, so the top earner's pay understates the value he created.
“Michael Jordan's salary the peak of his basketball game must have been you know say thirty million dollars a year”
The happiness and behavioral literatures are designed to justify government redistribution and guaranteed minimum rights, and sound policy should first expand the economic pond through growth and only then add minimum support, rather than starting from egalitarian distribution and treating production as an afterthought.
“first figure out how you expand the pond and then if you find that there's some shortfalls figure out what forms of minimum support you can use to overcome those defects”
Many people accept a deal of being miserable for a period, such as five years, in exchange for accumulating wealth early, then switch to lower-paying jobs with greater social rewards, and this sequencing is a rational life strategy rather than a sign of irrational behavior.
“I'll be miserable for five years so long as you make me rich”
The happiness literature is designed to undercut the standard market model based on narrow self-interest, and it attacks that model through two lines: behavioral economics, which says people are not as rational as assumed, and empirical findings on happiness and relative status.
“a lot of it is designed in its ulterior fashion to undercut the standard form of market which is based upon this narrow self-interest model”
Populism's core danger is stoking envy, which leads to policies that kill the goose that lays the golden eggs: when no one can earn a billion dollars, new companies that create major social wealth, such as venture-backed firms, will not emerge, risking long-term social stagnation.
“one of the great dangers of populism of course is that what it is designed to do is to stoke the envy”
Neoclassical logic implies every voluntary transaction yields mutual gain, but not in equal proportions, and because natural endowments and luck differ, the standard model generates high dispersion in income.
“every voluntary transaction will yield mutual gain but it doesn't tell you that the mutual gains will be of equal proportion”
Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments is the other half of economics, and Smith did not treat self-interest as the essence of economics; the moral sentiments explain how people react to others' misfortune, so they are not indifferent to others.
“people think Adam Smith was a proponent of grasping self-interest that that's the essence of economics”
Historical examples of state failure include Nazi Germany, Soviet Russia, and African kleptocracies under Pol Pot and Idi Amin, so government is an enterprise from which catastrophic failure is possible and must be guarded against with a low-probability, high-consequence view.
“you've had noticeable failures in that domain you know start with Nazi Germany and think of Soviet Russia”
Survey data show momentary happiness is not especially hard to attain for parents, but long-term life satisfaction from raising children is much deeper, and parents who say they are glad they raised children mean that it was worth the cost.
“momentary happiness is not all that hard but long-term life satisfaction is much deeper and some people will say I'm glad I raised my children”
Standard economic models become tractable by assuming people have well-ordered utility functions, are self-interested, and care mainly about themselves, so that voluntary trade is mutually beneficial and the sensible legal rule is cooperation yes, aggression no.
“they assume that people have perfectly well ordered utility functions they're self-interested they care about themselves”
Recent US policies on venture capital, corporate taxation, and capital gains have made few new companies go public and become fortunes, and those firms have sustained large portions of social well-being.
“one of the things that so worrisome about our current policies with respect to venture capital corporations tax gain and so forth is that there very few new companies that come out and go public”
A three-thousand-year Western religious and moral literature reminds people that accumulating stuff does not reliably lead to happiness, and the secular and religious traditions both urge adjustment of trade-offs away from bigger houses and fancier titles.
“there is a oh I don't know three thousand-year-old literature in Western civilization that that reminds us that the accumulation of stuff is not always the road to happiness”
Insisting that people consume less to control externalities is equivalent to wanting to make people miserable, because more precise tools such as pollution taxes or congestion pricing address externalities without sacrificing consumption.
“the idea that you want to impose a tax to restrict the consumption perfectly is a way of saying that we really like making people miserable”
The happiness literature suggests material well-being raises satisfaction for very poor people but yields diminishing returns after a certain point, so beyond subsistence additional consumption adds little.
“after a certain point yes in the beginning if you're very poor in your subsistence increases in material well-being do lead to greater levels of satisfaction”
The resentment that will arise in American society comes from people who paid taxes for inferior public education, so the policy concern should be the institutions that hold back the least fortunate, not inequality as such.
“the resentment will come from people who realize that in their critical phases they were paying on put tax dollars to get a vastly inferior education”
Hedonism yields momentary happiness, not a lasting path to well-being, and an economic framework that weighs present against future satisfaction, as Adam Smith's moral philosophy did, is the sounder guide to a coherent life.
“both the evolutionary literature and the spiritual viewpoint point out that Hedden ism is not the road to happiness it's the road to momentary happiness”
People in helping professions such as ministers, social workers, and teachers score highly on happiness surveys, which is what one would expect if people trade pay for non-monetary satisfaction.
“people in the helping professions tend to score very very hard so ministers and social workers and so forth teachers”
Demographic changes, including a large increase in immigration over the last 20 years and a rise in the divorce rate beginning in the 1970s that changed household structure, contribute to measured inequality for reasons unrelated to economic outcomes.
“we have a large increase in immigration in the last 20 years we had a huge demographic change beginning in the 70s due to an increase in the divorce rate”
The variability of human nature is even more important than it first appears because the pressure of norms falls hardest on people with antisocial tendencies while protecting those with prosocial instincts.
“it puts the hard pressure on the people with the a social instincts and it tends to give much more protection with people who have pro-social”
Redistributive income taxation shrinks the pot, whereas voluntary sharing that expands total value is preferable; people's willingness to accept less from an expanding pie reduces the serious social problem of public goods provision.
“unlike the usual form of share the wealth which is income rate acts in come taxation and redistribution which shrinks the pot”
The standard advice for trouble is to think longer and seek the view of a trusted, somewhat detached person such as a mentor, friend, family member, or clergy, and this advice applies equally to parents helping children choose colleges and careers.
“the first piece of advice that you give to anybody just about any time is when you are in trouble in college you want to think a little longer”
The Harlem Success Academy shows that low-income minority kindergartners can be prepared for college when expectations are high and basics are taught, so inequality can be addressed through institutional design that changes expectations.
“his class is virtually all minority students but the expectations there are really very different from what they are in the public school system”
Judicial interpretation has weakened the constitutional safeguards against state power, and the gains from private rent-seeking activity may be larger than ever before in today's societies.
“these safeguards are weaker today than they've been because of judicial interpretation”
When a friend gets engaged or makes the team, people who have not are usually disappointed and wish they had done better, not that the friend's success be undone, so a status structure that rewards self-improvement is better than one that rewards bringing others down.
“I don't think you resent the fact that he made it if he got it fair”
Critics such as William Bernstein, who appeared previously on EconTalk, argue that rising income inequality correlates with higher crime and worse health and that envy from it is a social catastrophe, but Epstein is skeptical of those correlations.
“William Bernstein talked about literature that suggests this is correlated with higher crime rates lower health rates I'm sceptical”
Epstein fears that the happiness and behavioral literatures will produce perfect equality with everyone poor, which he regards as an undesirable social state compared with a world where people are prosperous and some are more prosperous than others.
“the thing that I've always feared about the happiness literature and the behavioral literature is it will produce perfect equality everybody being very poor”
Environmentalists use the happiness literature as a pure anti-growth argument: after a certain level of subsistence, further material gains are a fool's game that only degrades the environment without adding well-being.
“this literature is also I think used by environmentalists as a pure anti-growth argument”
Happiness research and behavioral economics together are designed to justify government redistribution and guaranteed minimum rights, undercutting the traditional principle that cooperation comes first and aggression is prohibited.
“both of these fields are designed to explain why it is that government action in the field of redistribution and guaranteed minimum rights is useful”
Epstein's view is that envy is a terrible emotion, that successful and productive people should be celebrated rather than resented, and that most people respond to others' success with good cheer, so the envy literature describes only a small minority.
“my attitude is envies a terrible emotion in this world don't want to have it if somebody's highly successful highly productive more power to it”
Envy-stoking politics combined with regulation-induced economic uncertainty will produce a climate of long-term social stagnation.
“I fear that the efforts to stoke the fire envy take advantage of the economic uncertainty that's created by regulation will lead to a kind of a climate”
Higher returns to education combined with inferior schooling for the neediest produce growing inequality, and a large urban school system such as Chicago's, serving around 500,000 students with many impediments, cannot be reformed by even smart administrators like Arne Duncan.
“by god you're trying to educate 500,000 people there with all sorts of impediments on the opposite side”
Epstein advises students not to take the highest-paying job by default, nor the lowest-paying job assuming it is the most noble, since career choice is a trade-off between what one accomplishes with one's skills and the time left for personal or social life.
“there is a trade-off between what you accomplish in the world with your skills and how much time you leave for for other things whether they're personal or social”
Epstein's own choice to remain an academic rather than join a major law firm reflects a trade-off: he would earn about five times as much, but he says he is happier, and he observes that people who drop out of successful academic careers for money are vanishingly rare while leaving hard business careers for less arduous work is very common.
“the number of people who drop out of a successful academic career in order to make money is vanishingly small”