What this covers

This is a conversation between Peter Robinson and Bjorn Lomborg, recorded in April 2024 around Lomborg's book Best Things First. The method is benefit-cost analysis, which puts a dollar value on lives saved through revealed preference, such as the wage premium workers demand for dangerous jobs. Lomborg sets a bar of about $15 returned per dollar spent and ranks interventions against it. He contrasts the focused Millennium Development Goals with the UN's 169 Sustainable Development Goals. He also explains why the book recommends smart priorities instead of attacking wasteful spending: he thinks consensus is easier to build that way.

The range is wide. On health, he uses tuberculosis, which once killed one in four people in North America and Europe and still kills 1.4 million a year, with stigma keeping many cases undiagnosed. On food, he credits economic growth first and the Green Revolution of Norman Borlaug second for the fall in hunger. He argues for agricultural R&D on neglected crops such as sorghum and cassava. Robinson raises Paul Ehrlich's failed famine predictions, and Lomborg calls himself a "techno-realist" who sees Ehrlich's pessimism as a failure of imagination.

Trade is the most contested territory. Lomborg defends comparative advantage but admits economists neglected the losers in the Rust Belt. He cites a 7:1 benefit-cost ratio for rich countries and 95:1 for poor ones, and he assesses Donald Trump's tariff arguments. Robinson points to China's and India's tariff cuts alongside their growth.

On climate, Lomborg calls warming real but not existential, argues carbon taxes return only about $2 per dollar, and blames media appetite for doom narratives for its political salience. He adds that poor countries rationally put immediate threats ahead of it. The headline claims, including the $35 billion annual price tag for 4.2 million lives saved, are the ones most open to challenge.

Sharpest takeaway

Lomborg argues that benefit-cost analysis reveals 12 specific, high-ROI interventions that can save millions of lives and lift billions from poverty at modest cost ($35B/year), and these should be prioritized over unfocused global agendas and expensive climate mitigation that deliver poor returns.

  • The UN's 169 Sustainable Development Goals promise everything but deliver nothing; focused lists of high-ROI interventions work better
  • Interventions like TB treatment ($6.2B for 1M lives saved), agricultural R&D, and trade have benefit-cost ratios of 15:1 or higher, while climate mitigation delivers only $2 per dollar spent
  • Economic growth is the primary driver of poverty reduction and improved outcomes; R&D amplifies that growth more efficiently than direct provision of goods

The claims · ranked28 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

Free trade is fundamentally beneficial because it allows each actor to specialize in their comparative advantage, but economists historically failed to acknowledge that some people legitimately lose from trade, particularly workers in import-competing industries in rich countries (the 'Rust Belt' phenomenon), which explains recent political backlash against free trade agreements.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“Trade is fundamentally a good idea because if you and I trade, it means you can do what you're best at, and I can do what I'm best at, and we end up being better off. That's the fundamental point that we realized back in the late 1700s. This is a good idea, but there's often a lot of vested interests too who don't want this trade. Because if I do what you're better at, I'd like you to not be able to trade with me because then I get to just do my inefficient stuff. So there's a lot of reasons why this has been a hard, long slog. One of the things that economists forgot to talk about was the fact that when you do trade, some people legitimately lose out.”

0.69

Benefit-cost analysis uses revealed preference data (e.g., what people will pay for additional safety, how much wage premium workers demand for dangerous jobs) to calculate the implicit value of a human life; in the US this is approximately $10 million, while in low and lower-middle-income countries it is approximately $128,000 per life year, adjusted for age because younger lives have more years remaining.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“So take the biggest issue, which is how much is it worth to save a human life? Now, if we just sit here and casually talk about it, how much would you pay to save a human life? The polite answer is, 'Anything. Everything. I'll do—' But it's not a useful answer because we don't. We actually very specifically don't, and there's a lot of different ways that you can show this. If you look for instance at roundabouts, so traffic thus is a great example. Roundabouts save lives because it's hard to just rush into it. You'll pretty much only destroy your own car. It takes up time and it costs money to produce it, but it actually save lives.”

0.64

Tuberculosis is a treatable infectious disease that killed one in four people in North America and Europe in the 1800s; the developed world essentially eliminated it around 1930, but 1.4 million people still die annually from TB in the poor world, and many cases go undiagnosed due to stigma (in Kenya, one in four TB patients face divorce; patients avoid diagnosis to protect their social status).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“Tuberculosis is an infectious disease. You typically get it in crowded conditions. It's been around forever. We also have references in the antique era, but it really was only when we started building up cities and people living close to each other, then we started to infect each other. In the 1800s, every fourth person that died in North America and in Europe died from tuberculosis.”

0.63

For approximately $35 billion per year in development spending, the world can save 4.2 million lives annually and make the poorer half of the world more than a trillion dollars better off each year.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“For about 35 billion per year, we can save 4.2 million lives annually and we can make the poorer half of the world more than a trillion dollars better off each and every year.”

0.63

Global warming is a real problem but not an existential threat; even worst-case climate scenarios leave 80-97% of future world wealth intact; by end of century, the UN projects we'll be 450% as rich per capita as today, and climate damage reduces that by only ~4% to 434%, which is still vastly better off than present, making it a solvable problem rather than civilization-ending.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“So it's a little of both. So fundamentally, global warming is a real problem. It's not an existential threat. Any kind of estimates, even the worst kind of estimates will still leave us with 80%, more likely with 97% of what we would otherwise have. So remember, by the end of the century, we're likely, according to the UN, to be 450% as rich per person as we are today. Because of global warming and because of the problems, there'll be more problems than benefits, we will feel like we're only 434% as rich. That's a problem, but it's not the end of the world. Actually, we'll be much, much better off—”

0.63

Paul Ehrlich predicted in his 1968 book The Population Bomb that the world would experience large-scale famines in the next decade, but this prediction proved false as agricultural productivity increased; Ehrlich later reaffirmed his pessimism in 2018, claiming civilization faces near-certain collapse unless perpetual growth ends, framing growth as equivalent to a cancer cell's expansion.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Peter Robinson

“Here's Paul Ehrlich in his 1968 book, The Population Bomb, 'The Battle to feed humanity is already lost, in the sense that we will not be able to prevent large-scale famines in the next decade or so.' Well, along came Norman Borlaug, this tremendous increase in productivity, agricultural productivity that you just mentioned. And in fact, as the population grew, people actually were better nourished, not less so.”

0.62

Donald Trump's tariff arguments—that tariffs bring manufacturing jobs back to the US and enhance national power—resonate with half the country; however, tariffs uniformly make goods more expensive for Americans and less efficient for the world, even though they may achieve the political goal of making trading partners 'sing' (comply through coercion).

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“So, this guy has half of the country supporting him. 47%, I think, in the latest poll. And of course, versions of this argument appear in democracy after democracy, after democracy.”

0.61

One hundred years ago, two-thirds of the world's population lived in a permanent state of hunger; today, hunger affects less than one in ten people. This transformation was driven primarily by economic growth, which allowed people to afford food, and secondarily by increased agricultural productivity through the Green Revolution.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“Two-thirds of everyone you knew back 100 years ago were starving, in a permanent state of starvation. And the way we fixed it is partly, when people get richer, they can actually afford to buy the food, whatever it costs, and they can also afford it to their kids. So this simply makes a lot of the poverty issue in hunger go away. But at the same time, we also managed to get many more of the great seeds that we used to for corn and rice and wheat and so on, to produce much more per acre.”

0.61

Norman Borlaug, architect of the Green Revolution in the 1960s, is credited by news sources with being one of the few people, possibly the only person, who saved a billion people, by developing higher-yielding crop varieties for rice, wheat, and corn.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“So if you make these seeds much more productive, that was basically what the first Green Revolution did back in the 1960s, ushered in by Norman Borlaug, who then went on to win a Nobel Prize for it. According to the news stories, he's one of the few people, possibly the only person in the world who can put on his CV that he saved a billion people all by himself.”

0.61

China reduced tariffs from 32% in 1992 to 2.5% in 2020, and India reduced tariffs from 56% in 1990 to 6% in 2020; both countries simultaneously lifted hundreds of millions of people out of poverty through trade liberalization, demonstrating empirically that declining trade barriers correlate with rapid growth.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Robinson

“You note that China cut its tariffs from an average of 32% in 1992 to 2.5% in 2020. At the same time, they're lifting hundreds of millions of people out of poverty. Actually, I think it would probably be better to say hundreds of millions of Chinese were then able to lift themselves out of poverty... India, similar story. Cuts tariffs from 56% in 1990 to 6% in 2020. It's opening itself to the world. It sees its incomes quadruple.”

0.56

Economic growth over the past four decades has been broadly shared: the bottom 20% and bottom 40% of income distribution have generally risen in proportion to mean economic growth, meaning 'a rising tide lifts all boats'—the poorest do not get left behind in growth, though one might argue they could grow even faster.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“One study shows that over the past four decades of economic growth, the bottom 20% and the bottom 40% generally rose in the same proportion as the mean economic growth in a country. As the whole economy grows, the poor become better off. Prosperity really is shared.”

0.52

The UN's 2000 Millennium Development Goals were successful because they focused on a small, clearly defined set of objectives: getting people out of poverty, hunger, getting kids into school, reducing maternal and child mortality, and providing clean water and sanitation. By contrast, the 2015 Sustainable Development Goals promise 169 things to everyone but deliver nothing because they try to address everything.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“So fundamentally, in 2000, the UN did the first successful array of goals for the world, which was a very small set of goals. They said, 'We want to get people out of poverty. We want to get people out of hunger. We want to get kids into school. We want to get moms and kids not dying. And we want clean water and sanitation.' This was a very simple list.”

0.52

The political salience of climate change among Western publics reflects human psychology that favors doom narratives ('doom is fantastically good TV'), similar to how acid rain was portrayed as an existential forest threat in the 1980s when impacts were actually localized; this media/political incentive structure distorts priorities away from tractable present problems toward speculative future catastrophes.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“Oh, absolutely. For the same reason that Paul Ehrlich could have got away with it more than 50 years ago, to say. Yeah, we've already lost the game. We're going to die in... Or many, many people, many billions are going to die in—... Doom is fantastically good TV. So obviously, you're just going to constantly argue this.”

0.52

Continued agricultural R&D should focus on neglected crops like sorghum and cassava used in Africa and Southeast Asia, which have low financial incentive for commercial development, because increasing their productivity would both increase food availability and reduce the percentage of the workforce needed in agriculture, freeing labor for other productive sectors—the same mechanism that enabled wealth creation in developed nations by reducing agricultural employment from 50-70% to 1-3%.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“What we also need to do is all the other stuff, all the food stuffs that is used for instance in Africa and Southeast Asia, so sorghum and cassava, these less sexy things that also Monsanto has very little financial incentive to try to make better, but we should help make better because both, if you can make them more productive, obviously you'll end up with more food, but you also have fewer people who need to work the land, which of course is how we got rich. We got rich by the fact that we don't anymore have 50 or 70% of the workforce working in agriculture, but maybe 1, 2 or 3%. And that means everybody else can do other productive... Or sit here and just talk in a studio.”

0.52

Lomborg describes himself as a 'techno-realist' rather than a techno-optimist; he argues that Ehrlich's pessimism represents a 'failure of imagination' because technology and innovation have consistently proven more powerful than anticipated constraints (e.g., agricultural yields doubled or tripled, enabling both increased food production and labor reallocation to more productive sectors).

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“I would say I'm a techno-realist and the obvious answer is, well, he was wrong 50 years ago. The simple point is, Paul Ehrlich is making some good points. We are making problems, so we should be aware of those problems, but fundamentally, it's a failure of imagination to believe, oh, there's only so much food, so when we can't really do anything about increasing the food, more and more people are just going to starve. Turned out to be wrong because technology is much, much stronger.”

0.52

Poor countries' governments and citizens prioritize immediate tangible problems (child mortality from infectious disease, food security, education, healthcare, infrastructure, corruption) over speculative long-term climate risks because their populations face immediate threats to survival; wealthy nations can afford to care about both but poor nations rationally focus on near-term existential challenges.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“This is not where most people in the poor half of the world is. If your kids are dying or have a risk of dying tonight, if they don't have enough food, or if you have bad education, there is not good jobs, corruption, all kinds of other problems, this is what you worry about, not what the temperatures was 100 years ago—”

0.52

The book's strategic approach focuses on identifying the 12 highest-ROI interventions rather than criticizing wasteful existing spending (e.g., the $1.2 trillion Inflation Reduction Act) because building consensus around 'smart things first' is more politically effective than framing current policies as 'dumb,' allowing diverse stakeholders to agree on some priorities even if they disagree on others.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“I find that one of the things I really appreciate about this book is it does not try to say, 'Here's what you shouldn't do. This is dumb, you're a idiot,' all that kind of stuff. This is about saying, 'Here are 12 amazing things. Whatever else it is that we're doing, shouldn't we do that first?' And then—... Well, but it's also... Look, it's a question of realizing there's much more power in getting everybody on board with saying, 'Oh yes, we should actually do this—' 'We will do lots of other things that everybody will disagree on. That's fine. But we should do this first.'”

0.51

Econometric analysis of free trade models shows that in rich countries, for every $7 in aggregate benefits from trade liberalization, there is a $1 loss concentrated on import-competing workers; this $7-in-benefits can theoretically compensate the $1 in costs with education and retraining, making smart trade policy a distributional choice rather than an aggregate welfare loss.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“Turns out in the rich world, this is a real issue. So for every $7 that the US would win by opening up its economy, you also lose $1. So that's a real dollar loss that somebody—”

0.51

For poor countries, the benefit-cost ratio of trade liberalization is 95:1 (compared to 7:1 for rich countries) because poor countries will capture new manufacturing and export opportunities, making trade an extraordinarily high-value intervention for development.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“But remember, most of the poor countries are going to be doing the jobs that will create more trade for them. So they're going to win, so we find that while in the rich world, the benefit-cost ratio is only 7:1. For the poor half of the world, it's 95:1.”

0.51

Carbon taxes, while economically justified, deliver only $2 back per dollar spent in climate mitigation, far below the $15+ threshold Lomborg uses to define 'best' interventions; in contrast, R&D into green energy is more effective (though still delivering only ~$11 per dollar) but costs $100B annually—three times the entire cost of the 12-intervention portfolio.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“Put in a carbon tax, which most economists would say is a good idea, is also very expensive. So what we find is typically, that carbon tax will deliver $2 back on the dollar, which is a nice thing to do. If you have enough money and if you have enough policy capital, you should also be doing this, but it's not the first thing you should be doing. So these are the 12 best things, and we've defined best by saying they deliver more than $15 back on the dollar. Climate change in any shape, form or way is far away from that.”

0.50

Many proposed agricultural interventions (fertilizer distribution, extension services, farm machinery like combines) deliver only $2-4 of return per dollar spent, whereas R&D on crop varieties delivers much higher returns because a single laboratory improvement can be distributed to all farmers at minimal additional cost, making it a uniquely scalable intervention.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“Well, those are all fairly expensive things. And yes, they're probably a good idea, but they only deliver say 2 or 3 or $4 back on the dollar. But if you make this little tiny grain, or in the cassava [inaudible 00:20:41] make the little lump a little more effective, you can just do that once in a laboratory and then you distribute it to everyone, and everyone grows more. This is why R&D is often an incredibly effective policy.”

0.48

Economic poverty makes populations vulnerable to 'pretty much everything' (disease, violence, natural disasters, political instability); conversely, wealth creates resilience; therefore, the primary purpose of the 12-intervention portfolio is to give the poorest 4 billion people a 'fighting chance to actually live the life that you and I and many others in the rich world live' by ensuring they have basic health, education, nutrition, and opportunity.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“We have learned very clearly if you're poor, you're vulnerable to pretty much everything. If you're not poor, you're much more resilient to pretty much everything. This is an argument of how we can make a very large portion of the world have much better starting positions.”

0.47

Poor countries, not wealthy philanthropists or governments, have been most responsive to Best Things First because the portfolio addresses their actual priorities (healthcare, education, infrastructure) rather than wealthy countries' priorities (climate mitigation), validating the claim that development objectives are clearer and more tractable than global environmental goals.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“But that's fascinating that it's not rich philanthropists or even rich countries that seem to be responding. It's poor countries—... Yes. This is about poor country problems. Obviously, if you're trying to sell the Inflation Reduction Act, this is not your main thing—... Tonga cares less about that and more about the fact that they want better healthcare, they want better infrastructure, they want better education, these very, very simple things, and that's where you really have a big chance to influence.”

0.47

The core goal of the book is 'getting things slightly less wrong' and 'moving in the right direction' rather than solving all problems perfectly; this incremental, pragmatic approach reflects a theory of change where change happens when individuals and institutions adopt one or two high-ROI interventions, not when they adopt entire systems at once.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“The main point here is to say that a lot of people within USAID, a lot of people in the administration and everywhere else, a lot of people that do philanthropy realize that this is some of the things that they should do. Now I'm marking for all 12 point, but the reality is that most people will pick up on one or two and say, 'Oh, I want to do that. I want to help doing that.' And that's exactly what this is about. This is not about getting everything right. It's about getting things slightly less wrong. Moving in the right direction.”

0.44

Increased agricultural productivity through R&D creates a distributional win because while farmers may initially worry that increased output will depress prices, they ultimately benefit from volume increases, and urban consumers benefit from cheaper food, making it one of the rare interventions where 'everybody wins.'

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“Because there's also a distributional issue here, obviously farmers love to produce more, but they're also a little worried about, well, when I produce more, prices are going to down... Yeah. But this actually turns out that both farmers will make more overall because they'll make up for it in volume, so they'll actually make more, but it'll also be great for people who live in the cities who typically buy the food because they can buy cheaper food for each of their kids. So overall, everybody wins with us.”

0.43

Scandinavian countries, often portrayed as socialist, are actually 'unabashedly capitalist' and wealthy because of capitalism; they then redistribute wealth through taxation into public goods like schools, making them models of market economies with strong welfare states—not socialist systems.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“I think if you look at most of the Scandinavian countries, they're unabashedly capitalist. This is why they're rich. They're also just very aware that they want to recycle some of that revenue into good schools and other kinds of good things.”

0.39

TB treatment and diagnosis in poor countries would cost $6.2 billion annually but would save approximately one million lives per year, making it one of the highest-return interventions available.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“So it's about getting people treated and getting people diagnosed. This is fairly cheap, simple. We estimate it'll cost about $6 billion at least... And you can save in the long run about a million lives each and every year.”

0.39

USAID and international development organizations have not significantly shifted strategy in response to Lomborg's recommendations; however, individual governments, philanthropists, and administrators recognize the value of the portfolio, and Lomborg is working with specific poor countries (Tonga, Namibia, Uzbekistan) to help them prioritize investments based on economic research rather than external pressure.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Bjorn Lomborg

“The UN not surprisingly decided to say, 'Oh my God, we're failing on all these tasks, so give us much more money,' which is the standard approach of any bureaucracy. I understand why they'd say it. I also understand why they wouldn't embrace this book. It's essentially saying you should have done it differently. But the main point here is to say that a lot of people within USAID, a lot of people in the administration and everywhere else, a lot of people that do philanthropy realize that this is some of the things that they should do.”