factual
Benthamite Utility Cannot Be Aggregated Across People
The economist's utilitarian framework monetizes pleasure and pain to create a common scale, but that scale depends on how much money each person has, so it is not a real scale of pleasure and pain but only a scale for one individual, making interpersonal comparison of costs and benefits effectively impossible—and the desire to aggregate net gains into a single policy verdict is therefore a fool's game.
factualpending
Speaker
Russ RobertsEvidence Quote
“as economists, we don't like that. We want to aggregate. We want to be able to say, 'This is a good policy because the net gains are positive'... Do you agree with that? I think it's horrible.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:11:06 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...