
Mike Munger on Subsidies and Externalities 05/24/2008
What this covers
Russ Roberts interviews Mike Munger, who draws on his own experience as a farmer to ask what the economic case for subsidies is and how well it holds up. The conversation starts with farm payments and Japanese rice, moves through stadiums, roads and regional development, and ends on the theory of externalities, with bees and orchards as the main test case.
On subsidies, Munger takes the cultural justifications at face value and shows how they fail. If Japanese consumers truly valued domestic rice, they would pay for it, so protection reveals something other than quality. He describes Bootleggers and Baptists coalitions, and he argues that stadium consultants use multipliers while treating the public money as otherwise idle, ignoring opportunity cost. Wider roads, he says, mainly encourage people to move farther out and refill within about five years. The Research Triangle Park is set against the empty Global TransPark as a case of copying surface features. Film quotas in France and Canada appear as a tied good.
The second half turns to Ronald Coase. Munger says externalities are reciprocal and that the standard reading misses the high-transaction cost half of the argument. He recounts Steven Cheung's finding that Washington orchardists and beekeepers settled pollination through a custom of the orchard, where James Meade had assumed a subsidy was needed. He also says Coasian bargaining cannot be relied on for a global carbon agreement. Some of these claims, including his reading of Coase as partly tautological, are flagged as contested.
Munger argues that subsidies are usually captured by concentrated interests and wrapped in cultural rationales, and that the Coase theorem's real lesson is to compare alternative institutional responses, including private ones, before assuming externalities justify government intervention.
- Subsidies to farms, stadiums, and cultural industries are sustained by coalitions of beneficiaries and cultural appeals, not by measurable net benefits
- Studies that count benefits without opportunity costs overstate subsidy returns
- Private institutions like Cheung's 'custom of the orchard' often solve externality problems when transaction costs are low, and Coase's real insight concerns high transaction costs and property rights
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The Japanese rice justification is self-undermining: if Japanese rice were truly better, consumers would pay more for it and no subsidy or import restriction would be needed, so the protection reveals that the cultural claim is not about quality.
“if that's true they wouldn't need a subsidy if it's a different product and people will pay more for it then they don't need to worry about it”
Road subsidies do not relieve congestion; they subsidize location decisions. Widening a road to eight lanes encourages people to move farther out, and within about five years the expanded road is gridlocked again, so the public spent millions per mile and gained nothing lasting.
“what we've done is we've subsidized bad location choices”
The mainstream reading of Coase as proof that externalities need no policy attention misses the second half of the argument: when transaction costs are high, property-rights and liability assignment matter greatly, because parties with disparate advantages struggle to reach a solution on their own.
“the Coase theorem is really the second part of that which often gets forgotten”
Consultants hired by stadium proponents produce very large benefit estimates by using multipliers, and they implicitly assume that the public money used to build stadiums would otherwise have been unused or burned rather than spent or kept by taxpayers.
“they're assuming that these that the tax money that goes to build the stadium would otherwise have been burned”
Beekeeping and orchard pollination are linked by reciprocal payments that move in either direction depending on honey prices: when honey is scarce, beekeepers pay orchard owners for the nectar; when honey is cheap, orchard owners pay beekeepers for pollination, so the price fluctuates with the relative value of each service.
“sometimes if honey was pretty scarce we would have to pay the beekeeper to come in”
Urban and regional economic development is a selective use of evidence: boosters point to the successful district while ignoring what was lost when resources were diverted from other neighborhoods or places, so the visible success hides the forgone outcomes.
“you point to that and wave it around and say didn't we do a great job and you don't notice or point to the stuff that didn't do well”
A global agreement to allocate the costs of reducing carbon emissions is practically impossible, since the world cannot sit in one room and cheaply agree on the best allocation; this is why Coasian bargaining can't be relied on for climate and why alternative institutional designs matter.
“it's not the case that all the people in the world can sit together in a big room and cheaply figure out the best way to allocate the costs”
Government activity is often a coalition of moral 'Baptists' who push a desirable cultural cause (preserving the hardscrabble farmer) and 'bootleggers' who profit economically and vote or contribute for the subsidy, so the subsidy is supported by both groups even though only one has a moral rationale.
“there is a kind of Baptist and bootlegger coalition here that explains this subsidy”
The fact that people receive consumer surplus from a good does not justify subsidizing it; the relevant question is how much it costs to produce, as with a bottle of water worth $10 to $12 to a thirsty shopper but costing $1.20 to supply.
“the fact that I get consumer surplus from it doesn't mean that we somehow have to subsidize this or maybe charge more for it”
North Carolina's Research Triangle Park succeeded because of its universities, low taxes, and an educated population, not because of subsidies alone; copying the surface features in Eastern North Carolina by building a huge airport ('Global TransPark') produced an empty facility, a case of post hoc ergo propter hoc reasoning.
“it's just a logical fallacy kind of post hoc ergo propter hoc that is a follows B therefore it caused B”
Ronald Coase showed that externalities are reciprocal, so the question is not who causes the harm but how to allocate the joint problem; when transaction costs are low, parties bargain to an efficient outcome regardless of how property rights are initially assigned, though the distribution of the payments depends on the assignment.
“the property rights assignment would matter but it doesn't matter at all to the decisions that the economic participants make”
A hidden cost of subsidies is the monitoring cost of verifying the subsidized activity, which can completely swamp any small benefit, as the revolving-door example shows: paying people to push on a revolving door would require measuring the effort, which costs more than the benefit.
“it reminds us of one of the hidden costs of subsidies which is monitoring the activity itself it might completely swamp whatever small benefit might exist”
Rice and dairy subsidies justified as protecting national culture are often unnecessary: if consumers valued domestic rice or milk enough, they would pay for it, so a subsidy signals that consumers would not pay the price.
“if that's true they wouldn't need a subsidy if it's a different product and people will pay more for it”
Steven Cheung's 1973 'Fable of the Bees' found that Washington State apple growers and beekeepers solved the pollination externality privately through the 'custom of the orchard': growers kept roughly the same number of hives per acre, and violators faced shunning, so no subsidy was needed.
“Jung analyzed the Apple growing industry in the state of Washington and found that there were these complex in some cases long term in some cases short term relationships”
Economists are good at explaining why things must have happened after the fact, but the claim that without subsidies there would be no lighthouses or bees is a 'predict the past' fallacy, since private actors often find a way to solve the problem.
“economists are really good at predicting the past and so it's absolutely true that if nobody did anything there wouldn't be enough lighthouses”
The 'externalities don't exist' reading of Coase is a misreading: a persistent market gap signals that someone can profit by solving it, and because such problems recur every year among a small set of parties, it would be remarkable if they were not solved, so the Coase argument is partly tautological but still informative.
“people criticize coast for having a tautology but like most tautologies it's true if there's this sort of deadweight loss”
Pigouvian taxes and subsidies are often presented as the standard fix for externalities, but in the bee case Meade's Pigouvian subsidy analysis missed that the private market already solved the problem, so the example actually illustrates Coase rather than Pigou.
“in fact he thought he had the perfect example of what the GU would have talked about if he had realized it when in fact it was a better example of what Coast talked about”
Economist James Meade's 1952 argument that beekeeping is the canonical positive externality, because orchards benefit from bees and beekeepers cannot capture that value, is mistaken for orange groves in Florida, where honey and pollination payments flow both ways.
“some time ago a famous economist named Mead claimed that he had discovered the canonical example of a positive externality and that was beekeeping”
Cheung found the orchard price for placing bees was almost exactly the competitive cost of production, so there was no pricing failure requiring subsidy, and the externality was resolved through local, repeated, small-number dealing.
“the price of having Apple having bees on my apple orchard property was almost exactly what you would expect the competitive price to be”
France and Canada require a share of films shown in theaters to be domestic or French-language, which functions as a tied good: to see an American film a viewer must also have access to a national film, protecting national culture from globalization in the form of cultural change rather than product competition.
“a certain number of movies shown in any Canadian theater have to be made in Canada”
Government subsidies to specific groups are better explained by the interests of politically important constituents, such as farmers, than by any collective desire of 'the state'. The state has no desires; the subsidy reflects self-interested lobbying dressed up as public purpose.
“there is no we the state doesn't have desires so an alternative explanation I hate to bring it up but an alternative explanation would be that farmers are politically important in the state of North Carolina”
Central planners attempting to create successful districts face two structural problems: they lack local information, and their incentives favor the tastes of politically powerful people over the wider public, so a top-down plan is unlikely to produce good outcomes even if it sometimes does.
“they don't have the information usually almost always and 2 they don't have the incentive the incentive is to favor things that politically powerful people want”
Opportunity cost is the key missing idea in subsidy analysis: stadium land and tax money have alternative uses that promoters and consultants assume are worthless, so any honest accounting must include the value those resources would otherwise produce.
“they're assuming that these that the tax money that goes to build the stadium would otherwise have been burned”
The cost of producing a team's benefits is partly endogenous to the subsidy: a publicly financed stadium and high ticket prices feed into player contract values and team profits, and because the sports market is not competitive, public funding inflates the cost of the benefit it is meant to deliver.
“that's partly endogenous meaning that it's partly determined by how much we subsidize”
Before imposing a carbon tax to correct the externality of emissions, policymakers should ask whether a cheaper alternative exists, such as sequestration or other low-cost ways of coping with climate impacts; the Coase lesson is to compare realistic alternatives rather than assume a single Pigouvian instrument is best.
“the question is is there a cheaper way to deal with global warming than preventing it I don't know the answer to that but we ought to think about it before we impose an expensive tax”
Subsidies that relocate economic activity do not create net gains, and Munger's view is that the subsidy is simply a transfer that changes where things happen rather than growing total output.
“what we've done is we've subsidized bad location choices”
James Meade's 1952 claim that beekeeping is the canonical positive externality, with too few bees because beekeepers cannot capture the pollination benefit to orchards, is the textbook case for subsidizing beekeeping.
“some time ago a famous economist named Mead claimed that he had discovered the canonical example of a positive externality and that was beekeeping”
Transaction costs, not the existence of externalities, are the fundamental issue: when transaction costs are low the externality is often ignored, and when they are high one should design property rights and liability carefully and consider cheaper coping strategies.
“the real insight of coasts ... is that oftentimes transactions cost are really high”
Dairy subsidies impose a double cost on ordinary consumers: they pay higher taxes to fund the program and higher prices for milk, cheese, and dairy products, without having any direct say in the policy, while the benefit mainly accrues to producers and to those who value the bucolic scene.
“we pay twice we pay higher taxes and we pay higher for we pay more for the milk and cheese and dairy products in the store”
Stadium subsidies impose costs on many residents: people who dislike baseball must pay, face game-day traffic, and the city devotes prime land to a facility used only about 81 days out of 365.
“they're also gonna take an enormous amount of city precious city land and devote a big edifice to that Enterprise called baseball that's used 81 days a year out of the 365”
U.S. farm policy persists despite farming's tiny economic footprint: in the 1930s about a quarter of the population lived on about six million small farms, but by the 2000 census roughly 150,000 large farms produced three-quarters of the food while only 2 percent of Americans lived on farms, yet subsidies for feed grains, cotton, sugar, wool, mohair, and oilseeds continue.
“by the 2000 census a hundred and fifty thousand large farms all over the United States gave us three-quarters of all our food only two percent of the US population resides on farms”
Coase's theorem is partly tautological, but it is still useful: if a deadweight-loss externality exists, someone can make money by solving it, so people are motivated to find solutions, especially in repeated dealings among small numbers of parties.
“like most tautologies it's true if there's this sort of deadweight loss if there's this problem with externalities it means somebody can make money by solving it”
Tradable emission credits (for example, EPA credit programs) reduce transaction costs by letting firms with cheap abatement options sell reductions to others, so some externality is ameliorated without dictating who reduces emissions, and this is the practical lesson of Coase for regulators.
“there's parts of the EPA and other kinds of regulatory bodies that have started to take that a little bit seriously with creating credits”
Economic development that copies success, such as St. Louis trying to become a biotech hub like Seattle, usually fails because it mimics surface features of a place that attracts high-income educated people without the underlying amenities or talent base.
“that mimicking a place where people of high income and education are desperate to live versus one where it's nice place to raise a family”
Subsidy advocates commit the post hoc fallacy by pointing to a successful place and assuming the subsidy caused the success, while ignoring the resources taken from other places, which are not visible.
“it's just a logical fallacy kind of post hoc ergo propter hoc”
Greensboro, North Carolina's downtown revival subsidizes art galleries and nearly tax-free storefronts, and the revival is celebrated while ignoring the opportunity cost of the forgone taxes and the alternative uses of the resources and land.
“they assume that these all have zero opportunity cost and that none of the taxes that are being given up”
Dennis Coates's analysis of stadium economics concludes that stadiums have no net economic effect or a large negative effect once the opportunity cost of the land and the tax money used to build them is counted, since the facility sits empty most of the year.
“his conclusion is that stadiums either have no net effect or in some cases a pretty large negative net effect if you account for the opportunity cost”
The standard case for subsidizing a city's sports team is a free-rider argument: fans like Munger's sons enjoy the Cardinals (reading box scores, rooting, feeling part of a major-league city) without paying, so the team cannot capture those benefits through ticket prices, and public subsidy is therefore 'moral and just'.
“they enjoyed the benefits of the Cardinals without having to contribute and what we're what were those benefits every morning”
Light-rail and mass transit subsidies should be questioned on the same grounds as free road building; the real policy choice is how much to subsidize location decisions by developers and officials, not transit versus roads.
“I don't think we need to subsidize mass transit I'm willing to say why don't we just stop subsidizing private transit”
Light rail subsidy debates are one-sided: the federal share is framed as short-sighted refusal, but the real question is whether the subsidy should exist at all, since every subsidy has hidden costs and benefits to particular groups.
“I don't think we need to subsidize mass transit I'm willing to say why don't we just stop subsidizing private transit”
Screen quotas that force viewers to consume domestic films only make sense if the public would not choose them voluntarily; if French or Canadian viewers preferred domestic films, no restriction would be needed. So the argument must rest on a claim that people will later regret losing their national film industry, an externality of their own choices.
“if French people wanted French films you wouldn't need these restrictions”
Sports stadium subsidies persist because a city cannot have a partial major-league team, so the franchise has strong leverage over city councils and the local interests built around the stadium resist its departure. Cities that refuse are exceptions.
“it's very hard to have three quarters of a baseball team if you want to be in the game”
Cultural arguments are persuasive and widely used to justify subsidies because they supply a higher-order moral appeal; raw self-interest rarely wins politically, so subsidy advocates must frame the benefit as a shared cultural value.
“it can't just be raw self-interest it has to be some kind of appeal to a higher value you usually have to get some other people to go along with your hijacking of the fiscal person”
Protecting Japanese rice production is best understood as keeping Japanese farmers working by hand in small plots as a 'human zoo' that preserves heritage for observers, a value most Americans and many Japanese do not share enough to pay for it.
“the answer is we want Japanese farmers working in a very artisanal way by hand in small plots as a kind of human zoo”
Munger's Pittsboro, North Carolina tree farm (35 acres) receives subsidies worth roughly $20,000 a year: a property tax near $600 a year despite high development value, half of fertilizer costs (about $6,000 last year), and three-quarters of the cost of prescribed undergrowth burning (about $12,000 total), even though he lives 50 miles away and is not impoverished.
“so I probably benefits something close to $20,000 a year from these subsidies”
A farmers market in a struggling neighborhood is a small-scale example of the same mistake: its appeal rests on nostalgia for local produce, and the 'local' advantage ignores that efficient trucking of food from far away is often much cheaper and lower in carbon than local production.
“they didn't waste all that carbon being trucked efficiently from a far away place that raises them at one-quarter the cost”
Competitive retail succeeds by offering more products, higher quality, and lower prices, so letting Home Depot beat the mom-and-pop hardware store is the proper market outcome; subsidizing failing stores to stay open overrides consumer choice on grounds that consumers themselves generally value.
“if you're able to offer more products higher quality variety of products and lower prices that means you get to win in a market”
Pushing a revolving door is a joke example of free riding: people fake the effort because the person on the other side of the door does the work, which is why subsidies would be hard to target.
“people don't push fast enough because they can wrote freeride on the pushing by the person on the other side”
U.S. sugar policy combines import quotas with domestic production subsidies, justified by a 'national defense' argument about dependence on foreign sugar.
“what would we do if we couldn't get American sugar so we have we have big quotas on sugar to prevent that nasty foreign sugar from coming in”
An externality is an effect of something a person consumes or produces that is not fully captured in price, so individuals underprovide activities with positive external benefits and government must subsidize the difference to correct the mismatch.
“the effect of something that I do something I consume something that I produce is not fully captured in price and government has to make up the difference”
Free riding on public goods explains why people who enjoy a benefit without paying (like a team's fans or a shared hobby) produce too little of it unless some mechanism captures payment.
“they enjoyed the benefits of the Cardinals without having to contribute”
A.C. Pigou argued that one of the main functions of the state is to get prices right, because removing pricing distortions generally improves the allocation of resources.
“one of the main things that the state meaning the nation the government should do is get prices right”
Pigou's 1920s concept of externality was the foundation of subsidy and tax policy, and it is still invoked today as a justification for correcting price distortions.
“the pigouvian tax of the Pogo vien subsidy is was invoked in in the 20s and still is invoked today”
Downtown real estate is often empty because it is expensive and prices adjust slowly, so the apparent 'failure' of Main Street may reflect a lag in price adjustment rather than a lasting market problem, and cities should not react by subsidizing storefronts.
“paradoxically it's empty because it's expensive we may not get price adjustment very quickly”
Directed subsidies for growth, such as building a facility and hoping businesses come, are very difficult to make work; they sometimes produce good results, but predicting which ones will succeed is hard and the belief that subsidy alone will produce growth is wrong.
“it's very difficult to subsidize growth that way by building a facility and hoping that they will come”
Consumers who choose Home Depot over a local hardware store are rationally trading cheaper, wider-selection goods against the nostalgic appeal of Main Street, and most people do not regret the change; the decline of hardware stores is not clearly a loss.
“I think most of them don't regret it I think they like the Home Depot and they like the Walmart”
Subsidies to reduce the cost of a revolving-door push or to keep people home are facetious, but they show that a negative externality from staying inside could justify taxation rather than subsidy.
“that's a negative externality so if I could if I would stay in one should be taxed”
An Alabama highway near Huntsville, about 12 lanes wide and nearly empty, is a gift of concrete to road builders, likely arranged by an influential federal official, showing that subsidy benefits go mainly to the builders rather than to drivers.
“that subsidy did benefit somebody well I think mainly the person who built the road the road builders”
Light-rail and mass-transit subsidies should be questioned: Roberts argues that the federal share of a light-rail project shows that funding requests are about who pays rather than whether the project creates net benefit.
“federal government would pony up 15 million but we need we need the word need is underlined we need 35 million”
Attractive people staying indoors would be a negative externality, and Munger jokes he would accept payments from listeners to stay in his office, because Coase says the property rights assignment should not matter to efficiency if transaction costs are zero.
“coast would say it shouldn't matter and says I have the property right”