proportional representation
A system where parties receive Knesset seats in proportion to their share of the national vote, provided they clear the electoral threshold.
As defined in et_987
Other definitions
Electoral system where parties receive seats proportional to their vote share, creating multiple parties and coalition governments; contrasted with first-past-the-post winner-take-all systems
And here we are... at the end of the world. With Peter Zeihan Author & Geopolitical Strategist
Where it comes up · 19
- Jonathan Rodden on the Geography of Voting4 claims
- 151 | Jordan Ellenberg on the Mathematics of Political Boundaries3 claims
- And here we are... at the end of the world. With Peter Zeihan Author & Geopolitical Strategist2 claims
- Garett Jones2 claims
- Conversations with Tyler - Luis Garicano2 claims
- 287 | Jean-Paul Faguet on Institutions and the Legacy of History2 claims
- 305 | Lilliana Mason on Polarization and Political Psychology2 claims
- Viktor Shvets The Twilight before the storm2 claims
and 11 more
Most important claims · 10 of 30Search all claims for “proportional representation” →
- Parties select for candidates whose outside option is zero, meaning people who owe their position to the party and cannot threaten it, rather than the most competent people, which weakens the link between voters and politicians.Conversations with Tyler - Luis Garicano
- Single-member first-past-the-post elections can produce less democratic results than even the US system when more than two parties compete, because a large share of votes (40-45% or more) become 'dead votes' that elect no one, letting a party win a parliamentary majority with well under 50% of the vote (as in Canada), whereas proportional party-list systems route nearly all votes to seats and reliably produce competitive multi-party systems.344 | Adam Gurri on Liberal Democracy and How to Fight For It
- Starting a third party does not work in a first-past-the-post system because a party that gets less than half the votes wins nothing and cannot incrementally claw into power as it could under proportional representation; building a new party identity is also psychologically very hard since people retain strong loyalties to existing party brands.305 | Lilliana Mason on Polarization and Political Psychology
- The US first-past-the-post system, where winning 51% of the vote yields 100% of the power, makes it very difficult or impossible for third parties to emerge because people vote strategically to get their group in power, leaving no compromise group and entrenching zero-sum two-party competition.305 | Lilliana Mason on Polarization and Political Psychology
- Parties choose candidates whose outside option is zero, selecting the most subordinate people rather than the most competent, because this keeps party leaders in control; this explains why the Socialist Party has no internal voices against corruption scandals.Conversations with Tyler - Luis Garicano
- Per Duverger's Law, a first-past-the-post, majority-wins electoral system always produces two parties, so the only way to make a viable third party possible is to move to a proportional-representation system where a party winning 15% of the vote gets 15% of seats, which would create coalitions and reduce the zero-sum aspect of current politics.Lilliana Mason on Uncivil Agreement
- In proportional representation systems like Germany's, coalition partners negotiate detailed coalition contracts specifying legislation in advance, creating formal accountability for contradicting agreed positions—a structural difference from US government that makes bad-faith coalition behavior (like the FDP's) more visible and damaging.Germany’s Political Collapse | Ones and Tooze Ep. 166 | An FP Podcast
- First-past-the-post in its purest British form is the most error-correcting electoral system because proportional representation causes coalitions, which are bad: in coalitions political energy goes into form (what to offer parties to join), smaller parties become more powerful than the leading two, and parties proliferate — though the electoral system is only a tiny facet of the institutions of criticism and consent.David Deutsch
- The Weimar Republic was not inevitably doomed by constitutional flaws like proportional representation and Article 48's emergency presidential powers; close study reveals many forks in the road where things could have gone differently. Rather, a rushed 1919 process produced an ultra-liberal democracy without guardrails that allowed extremists to hijack it, while crisis-born economic instability—propped up by American money even in the stable mid-1920s—made the system brittle and never gave people a sense of lasting stability.Conversations with Tyler - Katja Hoyer
- Electoral cycles in first-past-the-post systems allow rapid shifts (2-3% vote change can swing an election dramatically), making them vulnerable to demagogue capture and populist movements; proportional representation systems have more friction and stabilize politics more but are slower to respond.Viktor Shvets The Twilight before the storm