Conversations with Tyler - Luis Garicano
What this covers
Tyler Cowen interviews Luis Garicano, a Spanish economist who has advised on European policy. The conversation runs from Spain's housing bubble to how the EU makes decisions, and then to AI and work. The bubble came from a triangle of promoters, local politicians and savings banks. Spain built up to 800,000 houses a year before the crash and now builds under 100,000, despite hundreds of thousands of immigrants arriving annually.
The political section is the most contested. Garicano argues that parties practice Outside Option Selection, picking candidates who cannot threaten leadership, and uses this to explain why the Socialist Party has no internal critics during corruption scandals. He notes that Spain's big reforms came under outside pressure or crisis (1959, the mid-1980s, 2012), and cites Tano Santos and Jesús Fernández-Villaverde on reform fading once the euro eased the urgency. On the EU, he points to the unanimity rule and its result: incompatible cannon shells and several tank designs. He describes a shared euro bond as housemates sharing a credit card, and says the Hamiltonian compromise he proposed never got its revenue half. They also cover Flexicurity in Denmark, the cost of rigid labor markets when firms cannot reverse mistakes, and conditions under which industrial policy works.
The last stretch concerns AI. Garicano draws on the Knowledge Problem to argue that relational messiness survives automation. He is skeptical of retraining and attributes rising unemployment mainly to health and participation. Cowen adds that substitution effects may push people to work more. Garicano cites medical scribes and his own WHOOP data as evidence of a Jevons Paradox in work.
Garicano argues that Spain's housing, productivity, and reform gridlock trace to political economy, meaning who votes and who governments serve, and that AI will make jobs messier rather than eliminate them, so Europe should be a fast adopter rather than pursue AI sovereignty.
- Anti-corruption restrictions on municipal land decisions made Spanish housing supply rigid after the bubble
- Spanish policy serves retirees, with essentially all post-2008 GDP growth going to pensions
- Jobs that are clean and verifiable are the ones AI displaces, while relational, knowledge-intensive messiness persists
- Europe lacks hardware and frontier models, so bargaining power comes from being a large, switchable client
Substitution effects dominate in the short run, so AI gains may increase work rather than leisure.
- In the short run, substitution effects of tax changes usually overwhelm income effects, so AI productivity gains that raise the return to work may likewise push people to work more rather than deliver a leisure dividend.
“Say in the short run when taxes change, almost always the substitution effect overwhelms the income effect.”