payroll tax
A tax levied on wages, which combined with mandated employer health insurance Kling argues makes low-wage employment among the most heavily taxed activities.
As defined in Arnold Kling on Specialization and Trade
Other definitions
Taxes withheld from employee paychecks and paid by employers for Social Security and Medicare; fundamental funding source for these entitlements.
Something's Going to Break, We Don't Know What
Where it comes up · 13
- Vanessa Williamson on Taxes and Read My Lips5 claims
- Tammy Frisby on Tax Reform2 claims
- Kimberly Clausing on Open and the Progressive Case for Free Trade2 claims
- Update on Small Business and Private Equity1 claim
- Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Dylan Patel – Anthropic & OpenAI will have most of the world’s compute by 20281 claim
- David Autor on Disability1 claim
- Mulligan on Redistribution, Unemployment, and the Labor Market1 claim
- Alberto Alesina on Fiscal Policy and Austerity1 claim
and 5 more
Most important claims · 10 of 19Search all claims for “payroll tax” →
- Because people focus on the progressive income tax and forget about easy-to-pay taxes like the payroll tax and sales tax—which fall heavily on lower-income people who watch every penny—they systematically underestimate the taxes paid by the poor, a mistake compounded by rhetoric like the '47% pay no income taxes' claim.Vanessa Williamson on Taxes and Read My Lips
- Contrary to the common belief that immigrants don't pay their fair share, immigrants pay a great deal of taxes—unauthorized immigrants in particular often pay into Social Security and Medicare without being able to receive the benefits, propping up an aging system, and they pay sales, income, and (directly or indirectly) property taxes like everyone else.Vanessa Williamson on Taxes and Read My Lips
- People recognize the Social Security/Medicare tax when prompted (about 60% named it from their paystub versus 70% for income tax), but they hold almost no opinion about the tax component itself—when asked, they immediately talk about the programs rather than how the tax is collected, who pays, or the cap.Vanessa Williamson on Taxes and Read My Lips
- Because people wrongly treat the payroll tax as a separate retirement-funding mechanism rather than part of the tax system, income-tax cuts appear to benefit only the rich while nearly half of Americans pay zero income tax; this creates an unhealthy dynamic where government spending seems cheap, and rolling the payroll tax into the income tax would force people to see they actually pay a roughly 15% near-flat tax, enabling honest, universal tax reform.John Cogan on Entitlements and the High Cost of Good Intentions
- Before the recession, the safety net was not ungenerous: a typical worker earning $600/week received about $300 in UI, but because payroll taxes and much of income tax are not paid when unemployed, the effective earnings replacement rate was about 70% even before counting food stamps or Medicaid.Mulligan on Redistribution, Unemployment, and the Labor Market
- Workers pay significant payroll taxes that they may falsely perceive as going into a personal Social Security retirement account, but the money goes out the door to fund current government spending—war, agricultural payments, anything—so the dedicated-account framing is an illusion; and because employees don't file on it, it barely registers in their consciousness.Tammy Frisby on Tax Reform
- The US payroll tax of roughly 15% (split nominally between worker and employer) is effectively borne by the worker through lower wages, so the true middle-class tax burden is obscured when people look only at income taxes; the payroll tax merely carries a Social Security label but goes into the same pot.Alberto Alesina on Fiscal Policy and Austerity
- The New Deal created the myth—commingling ideas—that the Social Security payroll tax funds your personal account, and this myth, started by Roosevelt, hampers reform of the tax system and dealing with the Baby Boom to this day.Amity Shlaes on the Great Depression
- The payroll tax for Social Security and Medicare has been marketed dishonestly as a 'contribution' that is saved or invested for the individual, when in fact the money goes out the door immediately and historically funded all government activity; this obscurity is bad for democracy.Vanessa Williamson on Taxes and Read My Lips
- Linking health insurance to employment locks people into jobs and acts as a large tax on employment, so that low-wage employment is now taxed higher than almost any other activity because of the high payroll tax plus the requirement that employers provide health insurance, creating a major barrier to experimenting with hiring; reducing payroll taxes (offset by lower government spending) would be Kling's single highest-priority reform.Arnold Kling on Specialization and Trade