Vanessa Williamson on Taxes and Read My Lips
What this covers
Vanessa Williamson of the Brookings Institution joins Russ Roberts to discuss findings from her book Read My Lips, which surveys how Americans actually think about taxation and government spending. The conversation centers on a paradox: roughly 95% of Americans believe paying their fair share is a civic duty, and the country achieves high tax morale and compliance by international standards. Yet widespread misperceptions about who pays what prevent people from connecting these values to policy positions. Williamson argues these errors stem not from innumeracy but from how tax information is presented—the architecture of filing, the salience of certain taxes, and reasonable extrapolation from personal experience.
The discussion ranges across specific misunderstandings that shape political debate. People systematically underestimate taxes paid by lower-income earners because they focus on the progressive income tax while overlooking the payroll tax and sales taxes. Many wrongly believe moving into a higher bracket taxes all income at the higher rate. Misconceptions about "waste" and "foreign aid" reflect Definitional Mismatch—respondents fold in entire programs they dislike rather than using technical definitions. The conversation also covers loopholes, flat tax proposals, and why the gas tax provokes disproportionate anger despite funding popular roads. Williamson notes that politicians across the spectrum reinforce these misperceptions, and that Motivated Reasoning and Partisan Identity make people resistant to correction. The central claim is that making tax costs and spending visible through everyday experience offers the most plausible path to an informed electorate.
Williamson argues that Americans are proud to pay taxes and see taxpaying as evidence of being contributing citizens, but systematic misperceptions—largely produced by how tax information is presented rather than by innumeracy—prevent people from connecting their values to tax policy.
- 95% of Americans agree paying their fair share is a civic duty, and tax compliance is high by international standards
- Misperceptions about who pays what stem from the salience and hassle of certain taxes, not stupidity
- Making tax costs and spending more visible could produce a better-informed citizenry
Widespread misunderstandings about tax mechanics—brackets, loopholes, compliance rates—lead people to misperceive who bears the tax burden.
- A common and consequential error is the belief that moving into a higher tax bracket taxes one's entire income at the higher rate, which would be punitive and unfair; in reality only the income above the threshold is taxed at the higher rate, and this misperception reinforces the false idea that the income tax punishes work.
“there's a common error that people have in their mind, which is if you go from one tax bracket up to the next one, your whole income is going to get taxed.”
- Because people focus on the progressive income tax and forget about easy-to-pay taxes like the payroll tax and sales tax—which fall heavily on lower-income people who watch every penny—they systematically underestimate the taxes paid by the poor, a mistake compounded by rhetoric like the '47% pay no income taxes' claim.
“because people focus on the income tax--which does hit the rich more than the poor--and because they tend to forget about the taxes that are easier to pay but are actually very expensive for lower-income people--overall they underestimate taxes paid by low-income people.”
- People recognize the Social Security/Medicare tax when prompted (about 60% named it from their paystub versus 70% for income tax), but they hold almost no opinion about the tax component itself—when asked, they immediately talk about the programs rather than how the tax is collected, who pays, or the cap.
“it was something like 70% of people remembered the income tax when I asked them... And 60% of people remembered the Social Security or Medicare tax or both.”
- Because the income-tax filing process draws attention to deductions and credits ('loopholes') rather than rates, people extrapolate from their own filing experience and overestimate how much the rich escape taxes through loopholes, which misleads them about flat-tax proposals—many supporters of a flat tax wrongly believe it would raise taxes on the rich by eliminating loopholes, when most flat-tax plans would substantially lower taxes on the wealthy.
“because the income tax playing[?] process draws your attention to finding the ways that you can get quote-unquote "your loopholes", the people extrapolate outward to the very rich.”
- Tax misperceptions are reasonable mistakes rather than evidence of innumeracy—smart, educated, politically engaged people make them because they extrapolate from personal filing experience and from how tax information is presented to them—which is a source of hope, since the fix is better information rather than a fundamental overhaul of math education.
“people are making mistakes; but they are reasonable mistakes. They are mistakes that come from--they are wrong, but they are not innumerate.”
Americans view taxpaying as evidence of contribution and derive identity from it, with high baseline tax morale.
- Americans have a very strong civic commitment to taxpaying, with roughly 95% agreeing it is their civic duty to pay their fair share—an exceptionally high level of agreement—and this tax morale translates into high tax compliance by international standards.
“if you ask people whether it's their civic duty to pay their fair share, then like 95% of Americans agree with that statement. That is an overwhelming majority.”
- People derive a sense of identity and pride from paying taxes because it is a very human need to feel useful and contributing; the most common source of tax anger is not the cost to oneself but the perception that others aren't chipping in their fair share.
“it's a very human feeling to want to feel that you contribute... 'I'm an adult. I'm a contributing person. I do my bit. I'm an upstanding citizen'--that's something that really appeals to people.”
- The book's central takeaway is that people see taxpaying as evidence of contributing and are most angered by the idea that others aren't paying their share, yet strong misinformation about that very question prevents them from connecting their values to policy—so we must do a better job giving people accurate information so their values can be reflected in the policies and politicians they support.
“people have real, strong misinformation about that particular question that makes it hard for people to connect their values with policy. And so we need to do a better job of getting them the information that they need so that smart, educated Americans who have misperceptions of the tax code can get their values to be reflected”
Hiding taxes in complexity and invisibility undermines informed citizenry and prevents people from accurately evaluating spending and policy.
- The gas tax illustrates why hiding taxes is bad: people dislike it despite liking the roads it funds, because they cannot see how much it is, it varies for reasons that make no sense to them, and being volume-based rather than price-based it behaves counterintuitively—so it has all the downsides of invisibility and none of the appeal of a visible user-fee-style tax.
“because they don't know how much it is--and because gas taxes vary so dramatically based on things that don't make a lot of sense to the average person--people tend to sort of ascribe a lot of that to taxes.”
- People overestimate how much the income tax costs them because they conflate the hassle of filing with the actual cost; the income tax is highly salient because of the annual filing burden even when the dollar amount is small.
“they sort of confuse hassle with cost. And over-estimate how much the income tax costs them.”
- A key takeaway is that policymaking is not just about creating invisible behind-the-scenes good or economic nudges; because citizens must perceive policy accurately to vote and hold government accountable, we should use the everyday experience of taxpaying to build a more informed citizenry.
“part of policy-making is making what government does visible. Because people out in the world are not just supposed to respond to little economic nudges, right? They are supposed to make decisions about who to elect to implement policy.”
- Much of the spending people like is local (roads, sanitation, fire, police) or feels earned (Social Security), and people barely notice the taxes funding it; but when people think about 'their taxes' they think about the federal income tax, which is both complex and pays for controversial things, so the federal focus makes taxation seem far more controversial than it need be.
“the focus at the Federal level does, to some extent, make taxation seem more controversial than it otherwise could.”
Taxes fund shared collective goods that cannot be provided privately and require pooled resources for societal functioning.
- Taxes pay for common goods—clean air, good streets, decent schools—that cannot be provided privately for just oneself and one's family; you can't have good streets only for you, and if only your own children are educated the economy would collapse, so these shared needs require collective funding.
“we want clean air, good streets, decent schools... I can't just have good streets for me. That doesn't make any sense. If only my children are educated--then obviously the economy would collapse... there are things that are common goods.”
- Historical evidence shows that education is poor when not publicly funded—literacy rates in the U.S. South before robust public education funding were exceptionally low—and a child born to poor parents should not have to rely on charity to get an education.
“if you look at the literacy rates in the United States' South for a long time before there was robust funding for education, you'll find that they were exceptionally high.”
Contrary to common stereotypes, immigrants integrate at historical rates and pay substantial taxes including those benefiting systems they cannot access.
- Each new wave of immigrants has been met with inaccurate assumptions (as with Germans and Italians historically), and such distrust undermines the social solidarity—the shared sense of a common project and faith that everyone will chip in—that makes Americans good taxpayers.
“each new wave of immigrants gets--assumptions are made about them that are not accurate, not factually accurate. Which undercut our sense of social solidarity. Which is one of the things that makes us good taxpayers.”
- Sociological evidence shows current immigrants are integrating at the same rate they always have—learning English and opening businesses at the same rates as previous generations—so there has been no fundamental shift in the most recent generation's assimilation.
“sociologists would say that immigrants are integrating at the same rate they always have. They learn English at the same rates; they are opening businesses at the same rate.”
- Contrary to the common belief that immigrants don't pay their fair share, immigrants pay a great deal of taxes—unauthorized immigrants in particular often pay into Social Security and Medicare without being able to receive the benefits, propping up an aging system, and they pay sales, income, and (directly or indirectly) property taxes like everyone else.
“immigrants, particularly unauthorized immigrants, are often paying into Social Security and Medicare without the capacity to receive those benefits, because they're not here with the right paperwork... They are propping up our Social Security system because we have an aging population.”
- Contrary to expectation, most Americans do possess the numeracy to distinguish flat from progressive taxes and understand that the income tax has graduated brackets; they support progressive taxes and continue to do so even when asked to do the math, even if they struggle to articulate the distinction aloud.
“they actually do understand, for instance, that there are graduated brackets in the income tax. It's a general rule. It's relatively well understood.”
- Williamson's findings come from a survey of 1000 U.S. adults plus 49 in-depth interviews designed to capture not just what people think about taxes but how their train of thought works when reasoning about parts of the complex tax code.
“I also conducted my own survey of 1000 U.S. adults. And I did interviews with an additional 49 people to fill in--to understand really how they think in addition to what they think”
- Survey data show a spectrum of public support for spending: local services like education and roads are both extremely popular (90%+ support) and frequently mentioned; programs like the sewer system are equally approved when mentioned but less remembered; foreign aid and corporate aid (bank bailouts) are the least popular; and welfare-state programs in the middle (health care, military, welfare) attract mixed and partisan views, while Social Security is nearly as popular as local services.
“the programs that did best... tended to be local services. Right? Education, roads were both extremely popular: 90-plus percent support for these programs”
People reasonably confuse technical and colloquial definitions of spending categories, and politicians reinforce misleading anti-waste rhetoric.
- When Americans estimate that ~50% of the federal budget is 'waste,' they are not using the technical sense of fraud and overinflated contracts; they are folding in entire programs they dislike (defense on the Left, welfare on the Right) and systemic grievances about corrupt, elite, unrepresentative government—so anti-waste rhetoric misleads, because rooting out technical waste cannot balance the budget.
“when you get estimates of waste that are approaching the 50% mark... People are not actually thinking that 50% of the Federal budget goes to crooks who are over-inflating their contracts”
- Politicians across the spectrum reinforce misinformation—even unwittingly—because railing against loopholes is popular but reinforces the public's fundamental misunderstanding about the impact of rates; the incentives to speak this way are unlikely to change, so the better hope is making taxes and spending visible through everyday experience.
“Every politician I've ever heard, on any part of the political spectrum, rails against loopholes... But, what you are doing is reinforcing a fundamental misunderstanding about the impact of rates.”
- When ordinary people say 'foreign aid' they often mean total foreign spending including overseas military operations, not the technical ~1-1.5% humanitarian budget; survey research confirms that respondents who included military items gave substantially higher foreign-aid estimates, meaning their high estimates reflect a colloquial definition rather than simple ignorance.
“people who were asked to estimate foreign aid and then were asked what they meant by foreign aid, those who said things that were military had substantially higher estimates of the foreign aid budget.”