originalism
The interpretive method of construing the Constitution according to its original text and the understood meaning at the time of adoption.
As defined in Richard Epstein on the Constitution
Where it comes up · 7
- Living with the Constitution (with A.J. Jacobs)4 claims
- Richard Epstein on the Constitution3 claims
- Jill Lepore2 claims
- America At 2501 claim
- Michael Munger on Antitrust1 claim
- 133 - Globalism On The Brink1 claim
- 14 | Alta Charo on Bioethics and the Law1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 13Search all claims for “originalism” →
- The Supreme Court's role as the ultimate and final arbiter of constitutionality (judicial supremacy) was not in the original design; the Court was meant to be the least powerful branch, with the President and Congress also weighing in, and there was no expectation that people could file lawsuits to strike down major legislation—John Marshall later staked out this expanded power, which most Founders would find shocking, undemocratic, and unoriginalist.Living with the Constitution (with A.J. Jacobs)
- Jefferson had the most faith in future Americans among his generation and rejected originalism, arguing each generation should not be bound by its ancestors' views, as no adult should wear the coat of his boyhood.America At 250
- Because the Constitution is so hard to amend explicitly (de jure), the Supreme Court effectively amends it de facto by changing how it is interpreted—originalists focus on the original ratification meaning while living constitutionalists hold that the meaning must evolve with changed times and technology, as in applying the 14th Amendment to gay marriage.Living with the Constitution (with A.J. Jacobs)
- The Left has effectively adopted originalism—usually a conservative doctrine—by returning to the legislative debates around the Sherman Act's passage, which contained a 'dog's breakfast' of goals (protecting labor, reducing inequality, protecting competitors), and arguing this original intent should be restored, thereby correctly identifying the power problem but egregiously misidentifying the solution.Michael Munger on Antitrust
- Frederick Douglass reframed the Constitution—despite its slavery provisions—not as a pact with the devil to be burned (as Garrison argued) but as a promissory note: a flawed but aspirational document promising a more perfect, free, and equal nation that citizens must fight to fulfill, a framing later echoed by Martin Luther King and Obama.Living with the Constitution (with A.J. Jacobs)
- Some hardcore originalists argue the 14th Amendment's equal protection clause does not apply to gender because its 1860s writers and ratifiers were not thinking about women's equality, which historically supported state laws giving married women fewer rights than single women, such as the inability to sign a contract.Living with the Constitution (with A.J. Jacobs)
- Rather than handling novel challenges like automation and AI inside legacy agencies such as Commerce or USTR, government should create new institutions with different hiring practices, higher wage rates, and public-private blending so they can attract talent and adapt technologically—building on the stable bedrock of old institutions rather than being constrained by them, akin to rejecting originalism in both constitutional and institutional terms.133 - Globalism On The Brink
- Through the Tea Party's popular constitutionalism it became clear that liberals had failed to talk in constitutional terms when making political arguments, leaving room for conservatives to appear to have the Constitution on their side while liberals seem to think everything is made up—a structurally unequal fight—and it becomes problematic that liberals only invoke the Constitution when out of power.Jill Lepore
- Constitutional law has two tools to handle doctrines that began as incorrect but became entrenched: originalism (text and modes of construction) and what Epstein calls the 'prescriptive Constitution'—by analogy to property prescription, where a 20-year trespasser becomes the new owner, a gutsy and probably incorrect constitutional move that people acquiesce in over a long period becomes the new Constitution (e.g., Marbury), but only with selective judgment, since some long-standing decisions like Plessy (58 years) were never widely accepted as legitimate and were rightly overruled.Richard Epstein on the Constitution
- The Second Amendment is largely a structural provision intended to protect state militias from federal interference rather than a free-standing individual right; today the militia portion is dropped out and it is read as an individual right, which Epstein argues is not originalism—so Scalia (writing for the majority) was wrong on originalist grounds while Stevens's dissent was probably correct, even though it is a poorly drafted amendment.Richard Epstein on the Constitution