What this covers

A.J. Jacobs describes a year-long experiment in living by the Constitution's original 18th-century meaning—a project that ranged from quill pens and candlelight to election cakes and close study of forgotten constitutional powers—in conversation with Russ Roberts. Rather than treating the document as frozen doctrine, Jacobs argues that the Founders themselves were experimental thinkers: Benjamin Franklin practiced epistemic humility, Thomas Jefferson wanted a new constitution every 19 years, and James Madison envisioned amendments constantly rewritten into the text, not appended as footnotes. The experiment yields both restorative insights and sharp critiques of how American government has drifted from its original design.

Jacobs moves across several distinct domains. On forgotten constitutional powers, he details letters of marque and reprisal—government-sanctioned privateering that helped win the Revolution—and notes that many assumed constitutional features, like the winner-take-all Electoral College, were never mandated. On institutional structure, he challenges judicial supremacy and the Imperial Presidency, arguing both represent departures the Founders would reject. He examines how originalism and living constitutionalism each claim fidelity to the text, and explores the practical gap between them—whether the 14th Amendment's equal protection clause covers gender, for instance. On democratic renewal, he proposes reviving 18th-century civic practices: festive Election Days with 70-pound cakes, the deliberate pace of writing with quills, and Framing the Constitution, as Frederick Douglass did, as a Constitution as Promissory Note rather than a finished code. Throughout, Jacobs argues that citizen engagement, not deference to courts or presidents, determines whether democracy rises or sets.

Sharpest takeaway

Jacobs argues that immersively living by the Constitution's 18th-century original meaning reveals both virtues worth reviving (epistemic humility, civic virtue, deliberate communication, festive democracy) and structural distortions worth correcting (an overpowered Supreme Court and Presidency), ultimately leaving him more optimistic that the future of American democracy depends on citizen engagement.

  • The Founders were flexible, experimental thinkers who treated the Constitution as a process, not a frozen artifact
  • Judicial supremacy and the imperial presidency are departures from the original constitutional design
  • Reviving 18th-century civic practices (election cakes, deliberate writing, epistemic humility) renews democratic engagement

The argument · threads6 threads · 25 claims
0.76

The Constitution's meaning has always been interpreted and reinterpreted, not frozen; the Supreme Court and living constitutionalism reshape it de facto as times change.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Because the Constitution is so hard to amend explicitly (de jure), the Supreme Court effectively amends it de facto by changing how it is interpreted—originalists focus on the original ratification meaning while living constitutionalists hold that the meaning must evolve with changed times and technology, as in applying the 14th Amendment to gay marriage.

    “if you can't amend it, then you can change the way you interpret it.”

  • The Supreme Court's role as the ultimate and final arbiter of constitutionality (judicial supremacy) was not in the original design; the Court was meant to be the least powerful branch, with the President and Congress also weighing in, and there was no expectation that people could file lawsuits to strike down major legislation—John Marshall later staked out this expanded power, which most Founders would find shocking, undemocratic, and unoriginalist.

    “the Supreme Court was really third of three. It was the least powerful of the Branches. And, it was supposed to weigh in on what is Constitutional and what is not. But, it was not supposed to be the final and only say, which is what it is now.”

  • Displaying the Constitution as a sacred, frozen artifact in a titanium case at the National Archives inadvertently turns it into something static, contradicting the Founders' view of it as a living process about people rather than just a piece of parchment.

    “it sort of turns it into this sacred, static piece of parchment that is frozen in time, as opposed to the way the Founding Fathers viewed the Constitution as something--a process. And, it was about people; it wasn't just about the parchment.”

  • Many features Americans assume are constitutionally mandated are not actually in the Constitution—including the winner-take-all Electoral College (states could split votes like Maine and Nebraska) and judicial review by the Supreme Court—revealing the document is far more open than commonly believed.

    “a lot of what we assume is in the Constitution is not. Including the Electoral College. You could split the votes, like Maine and Nebraska do now. It wasn't a winner-take-all for each state.”

  • The Constitution should have moderate elasticity—like a pair of pants that is neither so loose it lacks structure nor so rigid (like skinny jeans) that gaining two pounds splits it open—preserving core basics like free speech and equal protection while remaining flexible enough that laws stay predictable and the document can continue to function.

    “it's like a pair of pants. You want an elastic pair. You don't want it so loose that there's no structure. You do want the basics, like freedom of speech and equal protection. But at the same time, you don't want it like a pair of skinny jeans that it's so rigid that you gain two pounds and it splits open.”

0.64

Presidential and judicial power have grown far beyond what the Founders intended, concentrating authority in ways they would reject.

2 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The Presidency has become far too powerful—what Arthur Schlesinger called the 'Imperial Presidency'—with excessive power over war and trade, a development that accelerated even under admired presidents like Lincoln and FDR; the Founders, who made Congress first among equals, would be shocked and would want Congress to have more power.

    “right now, the Presidency, it's what Arthur Schlesinger called The Imperial Presidency in the 1970s. The President has way too much power over war, over trade”

  • George Washington, despite his moral flaws, displayed remarkable restraint by rejecting royal titles like 'His Highness' (and even a proposal that 'Washington' become the generic title of the office, like 'Czar' from Caesar), insisting he simply be called 'President' and refusing to become a dictator or king.

    “it was Washington himself who really struck down people like John Adams and said, 'No, just call me President.'”

0.58

The Founders modeled epistemic humility, flexibility, and openness to revision, expecting citizens and leaders to rethink and amend the document repeatedly.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The structure of American government was highly fluid at the Constitutional Convention; delegate James Wilson proposed a single president, but others feared the 'fetus of monarchy' and wanted a poly-presidency of three presidents, with Franklin even suggesting twelve, and the single-president outcome won only 7-3.

    “He said, 'Let's have one president.' Other delegates said, 'What? Are you crazy? We just fought a bloody war to get rid of a king. Why do we want what they called the fetus of monarchy?'”

  • The Founding Fathers practiced epistemic humility and flexible thinking—Franklin noted that the older he got the less certain he was of his own opinions, Jefferson wanted a new constitution every 19 years, and Madison reportedly changed his mind on his deathbed—modeling that no single person can be right on every occasion (Franklin's parable of the French lady).

    “Ben Franklin said, in the Convention he said, 'The older I get, the less certain I am of my own opinions.'”

  • James Madison wanted the Constitution to be rewritten each time it was amended—more like a Google Doc than the current practice of appending amendments at the end—which would make it a more fluid document, though keeping the original ugly passages about enslaved people reminds us how far the nation has come.

    “the way he wanted it to be was every time you amend the Constitution, you rewrite it. So, it was more like a Google Doc than what we have now.”

  • Amending the Constitution is one of the hardest processes in the world—harder than the Founders anticipated because they didn't foresee the entrenched two-party system—requiring three quarters of states; of thousands of proposals only 27 have passed, with the last in 1992, and growing political division makes future amendments unlikely.

    “it's very hard to pass an amendment to the Constitution. Harder than the Founding Fathers thought because they didn't foresee this two-party system quite as entrenched as it is.”

0.54

Citizens must actively engage with and fight for democracy; one person can change history, and small rituals and practices keep the democratic spirit alive.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Like the carved sun on Washington's Convention chair that Franklin could not tell was rising or setting, the future of American democracy is not governed by natural law but is up to citizens—who must engage, fix problems like gerrymandering, and act to make the sun of democracy rise rather than set.

    “it's not like the sun. The sun, natural law is it's going to set. But we are the ones who can make the sun of democracy rise or set. We are the ones who have to get in there and roll up our sleeves and change gerrymandering and all sorts of other things”

  • Texas college student Gregory Watson single-handedly revived and ratified the 27th Amendment (barring Congress from giving itself a same-session raise)—a 'zombie' amendment from Madison's original 12 that had never been rejected but lacked states—through a letter-writing campaign after getting a bad grade, demonstrating that one person can change history.

    “It was a Texas college student named Gregory Watson, and he was doing his paper for his government course, and he discovered James Madison had written 12 amendments, and two of them did not pass.”

  • In the 18th century, Election Day was a festive celebration—complete with farmer's markets, music, rum punch, and election cakes (some weighing 70 pounds)—because voting was an amazing new right worth celebrating; reviving this tradition of baking election cakes can re-motivate disenfranchised, depressed citizens to value and fight for democracy.

    “Election Day was festive, at least for those who could vote. There was farmer's markets, there was music, and there was rum punch, and there were cakes. Election cakes were a tradition.”

0.44

Eighteenth-century thinking valued virtue, community responsibility, and restraint; reviving certain practices and mindsets offers value despite that era's moral failures.

7 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Some pomp and ritual is valuable and not to be opposed, because rituals provide continuity and a measure of respect for institutions that society needs—so long as we do not deify the politicians themselves.

    “rituals are important. As long as we don't deify the politicians, I think that it is fine to have rituals because they provide continuity and a little bit of respect--which, we do need some respect for institutions.”

  • Letters of marque and reprisal—a constitutional power in Article I, Section 8—amounted to government-sanctioned piracy that outsourced naval warfare to private merchant and fishing boats; these privateers captured roughly 2,000 British ships and were unsung heroes without whom America would not have won the Revolution.

    “This is basically legalized piracy, government-sanctioned piracy. Because we, at the start, had very little--our navy was very meager, so we outsourced it. It was very libertarian, in a way.”

  • Writing with a quill pen profoundly changes how one thinks by slowing down thoughts, creating a waiting period for ideas, and removing digital distractions, making thoughts more nuanced and deeper; cutting off from the internet while writing has a similar beneficial effect.

    “writing with a quill--the experience itself--I felt was profound because it made me think differently. It slowed down my thoughts. I couldn't just type some acronym and press Send. I had to take out the pen, and it was like a waiting period for my thoughts.”

  • The 18th-century conception of free speech was far more constrained than the modern view, with state laws against blasphemy and cursing considered constitutional because rights were seen as needing to be balanced against the common good rather than treated as absolute trump cards; modern expansive free speech largely emerged from 1940s-50s lawsuits brought by Jehovah's Witnesses.

    “these were seen as Constitutional because their idea was that rights, like the freedom of speech, must be balanced with the common good. They had a much more balanced view of rights as not absolute or trump cards.”

  • Some hardcore originalists argue the 14th Amendment's equal protection clause does not apply to gender because its 1860s writers and ratifiers were not thinking about women's equality, which historically supported state laws giving married women fewer rights than single women, such as the inability to sign a contract.

    “some hardcore originalists say that sections like the 14th Amendment about equal protection under the law, that they do not apply to gender. Because when that amendment was written in the 1860s, those writers and ratifiers were not thinking about women--women's equality.”

  • The do-it-yourself ethic of the 18th century—making your own ink, sharpening your own quill—is a virtue worth reviving because it connected people to the physical world in a meaningful way, even though much of that era (sexist, racist, dangerous) should not be returned to.

    “there is some virtues that I think we should revive. And, one of them was this DIY: just being able to make your own ink and make your own quill. It just connected you to the physical world in a lovely way.”

  • The 18th-century mindset emphasized virtue, responsibilities, and sacrificing for the community rather than just individual rights—a bill of responsibilities was unwritten because it was simply assumed (e.g., all adult males served in the militia)—though that community was narrowly defined as white men.

    “the mindset in the 18th century was very much about virtue, responsibilities, sacrificing for others, being a part of the community. And, they didn't have a bill of responsibilities written because it was just assumed.”

0.36

The Constitution's slavery and injustice are real but the document itself is an aspirational promissory note citizens must work to fulfill.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Frederick Douglass reframed the Constitution—despite its slavery provisions—not as a pact with the devil to be burned (as Garrison argued) but as a promissory note: a flawed but aspirational document promising a more perfect, free, and equal nation that citizens must fight to fulfill, a framing later echoed by Martin Luther King and Obama.

    “Let's view the Constitution as a promissory note--that it's a promissory note that we are trying to achieve a more perfect nation where everyone is free and everyone is equal; but we're not there yet, and we have to fight to try to make it more like the Constitution says.”

  • Many educated Americans, including the host and the author before his project, have never read the Constitution from start to finish despite its enormous daily impact on their lives.

    “I was shockingly ignorant of it. I had never read the Constitution from start to finish.”