definition

The Prescriptive Constitution Doctrine

Constitutional law has two tools to handle doctrines that began as incorrect but became entrenched: originalism (text and modes of construction) and what Epstein calls the 'prescriptive Constitution'—by analogy to property prescription, where a 20-year trespasser becomes the new owner, a gutsy and probably incorrect constitutional move that people acquiesce in over a long period becomes the new Constitution (e.g., Marbury), but only with selective judgment, since some long-standing decisions like Plessy (58 years) were never widely accepted as legitimate and were rightly overruled.

definitionpending

Speaker

Richard Epstein

Evidence Quote

“if you start with a Constitution, somebody does something which is rather gutsy and probably incorrect, and then people acquiesce in it over a long period of time, that becomes the new Constitution. Not in every case, but in many cases.”

Source

Richard Epstein on the Constitution— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:11:58 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...