noble lie
A Platonic concept of a belief that is not literally true but is propagated because believing it produces a better society
As defined in ms_209
Where it comes up · 12
- Marco Ramos on Misunderstanding Mental Illness2 claims
- 135 | Shadi Bartsch on Plato, Vergil, Confucius, and Modernity2 claims
- Gary Greenberg on Depression, Addiction, and the Brain 09/27/20102 claims
- Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)1 claim
- The Bible and Western Culture - Utopia: Between Heaven and Earth1 claim
- 270 - What Have We Learned From The Pandemic1 claim
- 417 - Philosophy For Life1 claim
- 334 - The Low-trust Society1 claim
and 4 more
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “noble lie” →
- Plato's noble lie—the founding myth in the Republic that citizens were born from the earth as gold, silver, or bronze humans to keep them loyal to their social classes—has disturbed Western thinkers as a blueprint for eugenics and totalitarianism, whereas Chinese articles under Xi Jinping treat it as obvious common sense: of course society is hierarchical and of course rulers must lie to keep people happy, possibly even as a way to expose the Chinese government's own noble lie.135 | Shadi Bartsch on Plato, Vergil, Confucius, and Modernity
- People self-suppress the truth not through conspiracy but by convincing themselves that for good reasons they must say something untrue—a noble lie; this mirrors the bootlegger-and-Baptist dynamic at the individual level, where we have both self-interested and noble reasons for our views and convince ourselves the noble reasons drive us when the self-interested ones do.Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)
- Plato's noble lie is paradoxically self-exposing—it is the stupidest way to tell a lie, like announcing 'the following is propaganda' and then saying it and expecting belief—and this same self-exposing quality recurs in Chinese articles that openly say 'of course we need a noble lie, noble lies are good,' even though the whole point of a noble lie is that you are not supposed to know it is a lie.135 | Shadi Bartsch on Plato, Vergil, Confucius, and Modernity
- We know some of what antidepressants do in the brain, but those effects have never been linked to improvement in a patient's mood; prescribing is largely trial and error, yet the myth that the drugs target an underlying biological reality of mental illness persists because it makes pharmaceutical companies money and builds academic careers.Marco Ramos on Misunderstanding Mental Illness
- Public health officials' temptation to shade or outright lie about COVID has backfired, energizing vaccine-safety doubt, so ends-justify-means lying should be rejected; we must treat people like adults, align means with ends, and build a society capable of honest conversation about probability and risk rather than one guided by paternalistic misinformation.Ask Me Anything 17
- The myth of the metals teaches that souls are inherently unequal in capacity—some are gold (rational), some silver (spirited), some bronze (appetitive)—and this inequality is presented as a 'noble lie': not literally true, but necessary for social stability and justified because people do in fact have different aptitudes for different social roles.Great Authors - Literature of Ancient Greece and Jerusalem - Plato and Poetry
- The noble lie is dangerous because it begins with the assumption that people cannot handle the truth, which both enables manipulation and the accumulation of power and is fundamentally inauthentic about the human enterprise.Gary Greenberg on Depression, Addiction, and the Brain 09/27/2010
- The noble lie is necessary to maintain the three-tiered social structure (gold philosophers, silver warriors, bronze craftsmen) by telling the people they are all brothers born from the earth with different metals infused in them, preventing social mobility and keeping each class satisfied with its lot.Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City
- Saying we don't know how a drug works biologically does not mean we should throw out the drugs; there is middle ground, and the honest position is to tell patients we don't know the mechanism but have good evidence the drugs help a certain percentage of people.Marco Ramos on Misunderstanding Mental Illness
- Plato's Republic, with its caste system where guardians are educated in philosophy and lower classes are kept in ignorance via a 'noble lie,' is prima facie incompatible with Socrates's claim in the Apology that the unexamined life is not worth living—since most citizens of the Republic would, by that standard, be living lives not worth living.417 - Philosophy For Life