factual

Plato's Republic contradicts Socrates on the examined life

Plato's Republic, with its caste system where guardians are educated in philosophy and lower classes are kept in ignorance via a 'noble lie,' is prima facie incompatible with Socrates's claim in the Apology that the unexamined life is not worth living—since most citizens of the Republic would, by that standard, be living lives not worth living.

factualpending

Speaker

Donald Robertson

Evidence Quote

“in plato's republic though plato has this kind of caste system you know with the guardians are the ones educated in philosophy and the lower classes are kept in ignorance well that's that seems prima facie to be incompatible with what socrates had said during his trial about the unexamined life not being worth living”

Source

417 - Philosophy For Life— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:07:52 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...