What this covers

This is a 45-minute lecture by Michael Sugrue on Books II through V of the Republic. It begins with the challenge that sets the whole dialogue in motion. Glaucon and Adamantus, Plato's own brothers, press Socrates to show that justice is good in itself, even when it brings suffering and a bad reputation. Glaucon sharpens Thrasymachus's position into a social-contract account in which justice is a compromise among the weak, and he illustrates it with the Ring of Gyges. Adamantus adds that the best life is injustice paired with a reputation for justice. The lecture reads Socrates' own fate, a just man executed as unjust, as the living version of that problem. It also stresses the difference between being and seeming, which separates philosophers from sophists.

Socrates' answer is to read justice at the larger scale of the city, following The City as Magnified Soul. The lecture follows that construction through the Division of Labor, the problem of keeping armed guardians from turning tyrannical, and an education in music and gymnastics. It also covers the three metal classes sustained by the noble lie, and an Ascetic Elite barred from private property, families, and gold. Justice then appears as harmony among the parts of the tripartite soul), compared to health in the body.

The most contentious material comes in the discussion of the guardians' way of life. The "community of women" is read as equal education and function for women, since Plato cares about psyche rather than bodies. The lecture also treats lottery-managed eugenic marriage and Plato's hostility to innovation, and it notes that "innovator" was once an insult. It presents the philosopher-king as a deliberate displacement of Homer, the old educator of Greece, and of the warrior ideal, with knowledge replacing martial prowess as the heroic standard.

Sharpest takeaway

Plato argues that justice is the harmonious functioning of the soul's three parts (wisdom, courage, moderation) in the individual and city, and that this can only be achieved through radical educational and political reforms including communism of property for the elite, the abolition of family structures, and rule by philosopher-kings who have transcended desire for material wealth.

  • Justice emerges from each part of the soul and city performing its natural function without interference, creating harmony analogous to health in the body
  • The philosopher-king represents a revaluation of Greek values away from the Homeric warrior hero toward the hero of knowledge and wisdom
  • The gap between the ideal city and empirical reality reveals a fundamental problem with the physical world's resistance to platonic ideals

The claims · ranked38 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

The community of women proposal means that women and men will receive the same education and perform the same social functions, because minds compute mathematics the same way regardless of gender, and Plato cares about minds (psyche) not bodies.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“remember is primarily interested in minds not bodies and women when they do arithmetic or geometry they get the same answer that men do what that means is they have the divine logos in them”

0.80

Glaucon and Adamantus propose that justice has three kinds of goods: (1) goods intrinsically good (like health), (2) goods instrumentally good (like wealth), and (3) goods both intrinsically and instrumentally good; they demand Socrates prove justice belongs to the third kind by demonstrating it is good in itself even when it brings suffering and a bad reputation.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“gotham says there are three kinds of good there are things that are good in and of themselves like health for the body that's just a good thing for itself there are things that are good for what they get you like oh i don't know like wealth wealth if you have it you can exchange for other things and that's good for what it will get you and there are other things that are good both for themselves and for what they get you”

0.79

Plato is fundamentally opposed to innovation and historical change because once the ideal city is established, any alteration necessarily represents deterioration, requiring the creation of a warrior elite that is antagonistic to all novelty and external influence.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“plato throughout this book is going to be fighting a running battle against history he says stop the world stop historical development i want this to be frozen in time once plato gets a good city a good political order well then any change is deterioration”

0.79

Homer is the primary educator of Greece and has taught young men immoral behavior through his heroes, making him a pernicious influence on Athenian culture and morality, which is why Plato intends to replace Homer as the educator of Greece with a new ideal based on knowledge rather than martial prowess.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“plato knows that the most influential educational figure in greek life is homer and almost all young men because they're the only ones that get much in the way of an education are taught homer from their boyhood on and they know a quote from homer for just about every circumstance the difficulty is is that homer gives immoral advice and his heroes do immoral things”

0.75

Adamantus argues that the truly successful unjust person is one who commits injustice while maintaining a reputation for justice, because they receive all the benefits of justice's reputation while enjoying the gratification of injustice, essentially having the best of both worlds.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“people make mistakes so if you're really smart at being unjust what you would do is seem just and seem good and seem virtuous and then be as bad as you possibly can this is the argument that machiavelli makes if you stop and think about it right i mean you should get away with whatever you can but you should look like you're a real good virtuous person”

0.75

The ideal ruling elite in Plato's system is intentionally ascetic, prohibited from owning private property, having families, or even touching gold and silver—extracting only subsistence wages and leaving the maximum possible surplus for the productive craftsman class.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“the elite for the first time or perhaps for the first time in the history of the world is going to be an ascetic elite it's not necessarily that they're going to fast or starve but the gold and silver that the small strata that actually runs society are not allowed to own any private property they're not allowed to have their own families they're not allowed to get married they're not allowed to uh to actually touch gold and silver”

0.75

Glaucon presents a radicalized version of Thrasymachus's argument by claiming that justice is actually the advantage of the weaker—weak people created a social contract to prevent others from doing injustice to them, not because justice is intrinsically good but because being wronged hurts them more than wronging others pleases them.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“what glaucon is essentially suggesting is that justice is the advantage of the weaker what he says is that lots of weak people that were incapable of becoming real tyrants got together and they said you know it's better for us to form something like a social contract so that we don't have to put up with having injustice done to us”

0.75

Plato's proposal for eugenic marriages arranged by lottery to ensure the best men and women reproduce will produce a gradual program of genetic improvement, with better people naturally incentivized to perform better, creating a reinforcing cycle of improvement.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“if we're going to have the really the best people in the society the guardians particularly the philosophy kings must create phony lots so that we have eugenic marriages so that we have the best men and the best women reproduce so the next generation will be even superior to the generation that we have now so we're gonna have a gradual program of eugenics”

0.74

Socrates defines words through establishing precise definitions that move from words or symbols to meanings and logical accounts (logos), unlike sophists who thrive on ambiguity.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“this being and seeming corresponds to the difference for example between words and definitions you'll notice that no sophists in any of the dialogues ever spend any time defining any terms sophists thrive on ambiguity socrates on the other hand is going to move from words to definitions from words or symbols to meanings because he thrives on the light he thrives on real articulate knowledge knowledge which is held together logically by a logos right an account or a reason”

0.74

The distinction between being and seeming is the foundation of philosophy itself, differentiating Socrates from the sophists who care only whether they appear to persuade rather than actually persuade.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“this difference between being and seeming is crucial to all the dialogues in some ways the source of philosophy is to be found in the distinction between the way things appear to be and the way they really are”

0.74

The guardian class requires education in music (understood as the muses and all the arts) to soften their hard nature and create harmonious souls, and gymnastics to make their bodies tough and vigorous, with the two forms of education corresponding to care of the soul and care of the body respectively.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“we'll have to give them a music education and here i don't mean just playing the piano what i mean is an education in the muses in all the arts poetry and literature and music and dance and things of that kind because that softens the hard nature of our guardians and that makes them harmonious and harmonious souls are one of the key things for plato”

0.73

Socrates was a just man with a reputation for being unjust who was executed by ignorant people, exemplifying in his own life the very problem he was trying to solve in the Republic—proving justice is good even when it brings suffering and bad reputation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“think about the fact that socrates is going to be an extremely just man who has a reputation that's the opposite of what it truly ought to be and the result is that he is killed by ignorant unjust men this is not just an intellectual exercise this is gesturing back at the trial and death of socrates right he's the unjust man reputed he's the just man reputed to be unjust that gets the consequences of the ignorance of the people around him”

0.73

Justice is only valued instrumentally by ordinary people: fathers tell sons to be just for the reputation and advancement it brings (political office, military command, neighbors' esteem), not because justice is intrinsically good—making people praise justice for external rewards rather than inherent virtue.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lecture Instructor

“men when they tell their sons that they must be just they always tell them look you should be just because of what it gets you if you have a reputation for being a just man you can get elected to office you can get made you can be made general of an army you can rise high in the estimation of your neighbors but they always praise justice not because it's good intrinsically but rather because it's good for what it gets you it's good because of the reputation you get”

0.70

Justice is properly understood as harmony between the three parts of the soul (wisdom, courage, moderation) performing their respective functions, not as individual happiness or satisfaction but as the good of the whole organism, analogous to health in the body.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“socrates says no the point of this regime is not the good of some subset it's the good of the whole he thinks of of his ideal city as being a sort of organic unity so we're not trying to make your uh the hand happy or the head happy or the foot happy we want the happiness of the entire body”

0.69

The invisibility element of the ring of Gyges means that what is being examined is the soul stripped of the body—the claim is essentially about what the soul would do without bodily constraints or social accountability.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lecture Instructor

“so this invisibility element means that what we're doing is essentially subtracting the body and looking just at the soul”

0.69

Socrates employs the technique of examining justice at a larger scale—in the city rather than the individual—because virtue of the soul will be magnified and easier to see in a city, allowing the examiners to determine whether justice is intrinsically good.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“suppose we don't look in an individual man because it'll be hard to see justice or virtue of the soul if we look at an individual let's look at the city let's construct a city in speech and this city in speech will show us the virtues of the individual man magnified manifold”

0.69

In ancient times, calling someone an innovator was a put-down and accusation, whereas in modern society innovation is praised—a fundamental shift in cultural values that shapes what societies will accept.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“in the ancient world to call someone an innovator is generally speaking a put down you know it's an accusation nowadays in a kind of much more modern society that we have today to call someone an innovator is praise 25 centuries ago it was not praised it was an accusation”

0.69

The noble lie is necessary to maintain the three-tiered social structure (gold philosophers, silver warriors, bronze craftsmen) by telling the people they are all brothers born from the earth with different metals infused in them, preventing social mobility and keeping each class satisfied with its lot.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“we're supposed to tell the people that we have given the various kinds of training uh we train some people to be bronze and craftsmen we train other people to be silver and defenders of the society we're eventually also going to train one or a small group of people to be philosopher kings to be professional knowers who are also going to run the society how are we going to keep this three parts of the city separate”

0.69

Glaucon and Adamantus are Plato's own brothers and represent the upcoming talented and potentially virtuous youth of Athens, which is why Plato immortalizes them in the Republic as examples of good education.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“glaucon and adamantis are brothers and they're both plato's brothers so he's writing his own family members and his talented capable brothers into the dialogue the most famous of the platonic dialogues so he immortalizes his own family which has a considerable status within athens”

0.69

Socrates says he is 'overwhelmed by the magnitude of the task' imposed by Glaucon and Adamantus, though it is proper that he should be, because he has been waiting for this argument and these talented youth to give him the hardest possible case against justice.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lecture Instructor

“socrates is stuck i mean he says well i mean i'm just overwhelmed by the magnitude of your task now in some ways it's quite proper that he should be it's a very difficult argument second on the second hand though it's also true that socrates has been waiting for this argument he's been stepping back a little bit waiting for these boys to come on to give him an argument and make the hardest possible play in defense of justice”

0.69

The bronze in the myth (the hollow bronze horse and the man) represents emotion and appetite; Socrates uses the symbolism to connect physical materials to psychological parts, showing how the sensible world maps onto the tripartite soul.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lecture Instructor

“it's a hollow horse and it's bronze and in a little while we'll find out what bronze means too right it means emotion or appetite”

0.68

The division of labor is the foundational principle of the city, as each person pursuing a single craft becomes more proficient than those attempting many trades, making 'the jack of all trades master of none' a key constraint on social organization.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“one man one job is established as the ideal because the division of labor so that each man takes one job means that each will be able to pursue one craft and pursue it well you find that the jack of all trades is master of none”

0.66

The central political problem is how to prevent warriors who control the means of coercion from becoming tyrannical and using state power for their own benefit rather than the city's good.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“how are we going to get these people not to be tyrannical in other words once they have control of the means of coercion how is it that they're not just going to run the city for their own good you don't want thrasymachus and people like thrasymachus given all the weapons in the city and allowed to dominate”

0.63

Although rare, small amounts of upward and downward social mobility are permitted in Plato's system—a talented child of bronze or silver parents can be promoted, and a gold child can be demoted—but the system is otherwise completely rigid with no substantial social mobility.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“it's a completely hierarchical society with just about nothing in the way of social mobility if a child born of bronze or silver parents shows great promise it can be moved up a notch or a child of gold parents can be moved or silver parents can move down a notch but for the most part it's a completely fixed rigid hierarchical society”

0.63

The three waves of the argument Socrates faces are feminism, communism (abolition of family and private property), and the practical realizability of the philosopher-king, with each wave presenting successively greater difficulties.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“he says there are three waves to the argument and if you thought my argument was strange to begin with and hard to believe to begin with it's going to get even harder to believe and even more peculiar the first wave that socrates has to face is feminism”

0.61

Plato's political proposals are framed as a response to post-Peloponnesian War Athens, which lost that war largely because it overextended itself through imperial hubris and failed to control its own internal disorder—making the goal self-control rather than domination of others.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“plato is not trying to write legislation for the modern world he's trying to write legislation for post peloponnesian war athens that lost the philippine asian war largely because they overextended themselves because they were full of hubris and pride and foolish stuff like that one of the things that plato most objects to in the in contemporary athenian politics is the fact that we went and developed an empire which caused us to lose that war”

0.61

Plato borrows extensively from Spartan institutions—common housing, common training tables, community of property and activity—because Sparta defeated Athens in the Peloponnesian War, suggesting that Spartan virtue and better institutions enabled their victory.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“remember that sparta won the peloponnesian war and for plato to write so many spartan customs into his ideal city is a real slap in the face to his contemporaries saying look the reason we that sparta overcame athens in the peloponnesian war at least partially is because they are more virtuous than we are their institutions are better conceived”

0.61

Bodies are relatively accidental things; at the end of the Republic (myth of Er), people will be reincarnated, so Plato does not care what genitalia a person has attached to them—he cares about the mind, the psyche, the soul, because the entire book is about the perfectability of souls.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lecture Instructor

“bodies are relatively accidental things and god knows at the end of the book at the myth of earth we're going to find out that people are going to get reincarnated anyway right so naturally he doesn't care what sort of genitalia a person is attached to he cares about their mind their psyche their soul this is a book about souls the perfectability of souls bodies don't interest him very much”

0.61

Plato rejects the democratic assumption that universal education will enable all citizens to make wise political decisions, based on his observation that early Athenian democracy killed Socrates and made disastrous decisions like the Peloponnesian War overextension.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“plato doesn't think that he saw these you know this early democracy kill socrates he saw this early democracy do all kinds of evil he saw this early democracy make bad decisions and lose the peloponnesian war and get themselves all killed and conquered so he thinks that democracy is an intrinsically unstable polity”

0.56

The gap between the ideal city Plato envisions and the empirical world's resistance to realizing it shows that something is fundamentally wrong with the world of space and time—it is not capable of instantiating perfect justice.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“and it seems that there's a sort of resistance by the empirical physical world of tables and chairs towards all of platonic ideals and towards the perfect city that plato suggests and the philosopher king suggests to us that there's some sort of disjunction between theory and practice that we can't quite realize in the world of space and time the world of nature the ideals that we would hope or that we would aspire towards”

0.55

The Ring of Gyges myth represents a bad education that moves the shepherd from a state of naivete or knowledge down to moral ignorance, and this moral deterioration in the individual necessarily produces disorder in the political state, because the city is like the man.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“by having the ring of go well first of all i mean hollow horses play a very very big role in greek poetry right so it's a clear implied dig at homer right so he moves from a state of at least naivete if not knowledge down to a morally inferior state to a state of moral ignorance and comes back up not improved but made worse this bad education because i think that the myth of guy jesus is a parable about a bad education comes back up and then subverts the political and moral order”

0.54

The persistent problem in modern liberal society is the unresolved conflict between private good and public good that Plato identified, though his solution of abolishing the family may not be successful or plausible.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“i don't know that it is successful this attempt to abolish the family in the interest of creating a kind of general cohesion within society on the other hand one of the persistent problems that we get in modern liberal society is this conflict between the private good and the public good right we haven't really resolved this so i would be inclined to think this isn't an especially plausible way of resolving it by abolishing the family although people have tried that the point is though that it remains a problem”

0.52

Socrates is being compared to Achilles in the Apology, presenting himself as the new hero of knowledge in shabby clothes living an austere life, rather than the homeric warrior hero, representing Plato's revaluation of values that subordinates warrior prowess to wisdom.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“socrates in the apology directly compares himself to achilles why well first of all because the only person only poet that the audience is likely to know is homer and he's trying to get right in the audience's face by saying well look i'm dressed in shabby stuff and i'm an old man and i haven't done very much in war lately on the other hand i'm a tremendously heroic individual”

0.52

The abolition of the family for the guardian class aims to unify public and private good by making all members of the guardian class view the whole city as their family, replacing particular family loyalty with universal civic loyalty.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“plato wants to break down the distinction between public good and private good that's why he's abolishing the family in the interest of creating family ties of family relationships across the city as a whole in other words all the members of the guardian class all the silver and all the gold should view the whole city as being their own their family their particular private thing so private and public good will be unified”

0.52

Socrates intentionally gives weak arguments against Thrasymachus in Book 1 to lure and provoke Glaucon and Adamantus into articulating a much stronger, radicalized version of the immoralist argument, setting them up for a more serious engagement.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“socrates of course rises to the challenge a challenge which he set up by beating thrasymachus badly by offering bad arguments by making the defense of justice look kind of wishy-washy he has lured thrasymachus or lured adamantis and glaucon into this argument so that's why he gives i think fairly weak arguments against thrasymachus”

0.52

Philosophical dogs are beings that love and recognize those they know while being antagonistic to strangers and the foreign, making them ideal guardians because they will defend their own city while resisting external change and innovation.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“here's a great thing about philosophical dogs and clearly this is meant as broad humor they like what they know in other words if a dog knows you doesn't matter if you're a good man or a bad man as long as the dog knows you'll come up and lick your hand and it won't be a problem but even if a virtuous stranger comes up the dog barks he doesn't like strangers”

0.47

Luxury causes both physical illness (requiring more doctors) and moral illness in the soul, and the attempt to satisfy unlimited desires inevitably leads to territorial expansion and war as cities extend their borders to acquire goods they do not need.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“luxury will lead to various kinds of physical maladies in the individuals but the implication is always that anytime that the physical individual is sick or that the soul of the individuals that make up a society are sick you will have a soul sick political order as well”

0.43

The city of utmost necessity—a simple city with no luxuries, poetry, or public buildings—will be tolerably just but cannot support the development of civilization, culture, or the activities that make life distinctly human.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Great Minds - Part 1 - Plato's Republic II-V: Soul and City [rVxSoiHtovM]

“this city of utmost necessity will be tolerably just but will not have any luxuries will not have anything in the way of cultivation in other words there won't be any leisure left over for these people to develop things like civilization like greek culture there won't be much in the way of poetry or statues or large public buildings they'll live a sort of arcadian simplicity”