labor theory of value
The Marxist economic doctrine that value derives only from labor, implying land itself has no value.
As defined in Alain Bertaud
Where it comes up · 14
- Democracy at Work: Curing Capitalism | Richard Wolff | Talks at Google2 claims
- Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Defoe, Robinson Crusoe1 claim
- Alain Bertaud1 claim
- Conversations with Tyler - Harvey Mansfield1 claim
- Sarah Paine — How Mao conquered China (lecture & interview)1 claim
- Sarah Paine — The war for India (lecture & interview)1 claim
- Why neoclassical economics has failed - Book summary of The New Economics by Steve Keen1 claim
- Sandra Faber on the Future of the Earth1 claim
and 6 more
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “labor theory of value” →
- The labor theory of value—that value comes from the amount of work put into something—was rejected because effort alone does not determine value: a gadget made in fewer hours can be more valuable than a giant knot tied over many hours, so value depends on implications for human flourishing, not solely on overcoming entropy.Sandra Faber on the Future of the Earth
- Classical economics, founded by Adam Smith, did not use much math, was close to political economy, concerned with the wealth of nations and distribution, and is defined from a distance by the labor theory of value—the idea that value comes from the labor a person puts into something, possibly derived from Locke's notion of property.Jennifer Burns
- The Great Leap Forward's idiocy is explicable once you recognize Mao's primary objective was to stay in power and keep the Communist Party in power and pursue revolution, not the welfare of people — and communist ideology fails because labor theories of value ignore that services are also valuable, so the basic theory he was implementing was simply incorrect.Sarah Paine — How Mao conquered China (lecture & interview)
- More emphasizes the labor theory of value—the idea that all valuable things come from work—which will later become important in the political economy of Locke and Hobbes, and has utopian and Christian roots.The Bible and Western Culture - Utopia: Between Heaven and Earth
- Smith's list of errors is much shorter than his list of correct ideas. One error, on which there is now consensus, is his labor theory of value: the idea that labor is universally quantifiable and determines value, which modern economics has completely discarded and which Marx took from Smith. Smith may have held a more subtle 'subjective labor theory of value', but the project was a wild goose chase.James Otteson on Adam Smith 06/27/2011
- The criticism that Marx's labor theory of value is flawed misses Marx's actual argument, which distinguishes between prices (market-determined) and values (socially-allocated labor), a distinction that predates Marx in Smith and Ricardo.Democracy at Work: Curing Capitalism | Richard Wolff | Talks at Google
- Adam Smith introduced a bias into economic thinking by emphasizing labor (labor theory of value) as the core engine of wealth creation, whereas earlier physiocrats emphasized land and free gifts from nature as fundamental inputs, leading neoclassical successors to downplay energy and natural resources.Why neoclassical economics has failed - Book summary of The New Economics by Steve Keen
- From English political economy, Marx borrowed the labor theory of value—the idea that a commodity's value is directly related to the amount of work required to acquire it—because this naturalistic approach avoids metaphysical formulations and represents a hard-headed, realistic, skeptical element characteristic of Adam Smith and the English intellectual tradition.Great Minds - Part 4 - Marx and the Problem of Alienation and Ideology
- Marxism appealed to colonized peoples scarred by World War I and the Depression because it framed capitalists as wasting lives, but the technicalities of Marx's labor theory of value are inaccurate since it is not just labor that produces value—intellectual contributions like those in Silicon Valley produce tremendous value—and pursuing equality through expropriation eliminates liberty.Sarah Paine — The war for India (lecture & interview)
- Neoclassical economics, which developed in the 1870s, explicitly rejected the labor theory of value as a reaction against Marx, not for scientific reasons, and substituted utility theory—which is equally difficult to measure empirically.Democracy at Work: Curing Capitalism | Richard Wolff | Talks at Google