What this covers

This 21-minute video essay summarizes Steve Keen's book The New Economics, a manifesto-style critique of neoclassical economics paired with the beginnings of an alternative built on dynamical systems. A single unnamed narrator walks through the book roughly in its order: why a manifesto, what money is, how private banks create it, the aggregation problem behind supply and demand curves, and finally energy and the environment. The stakes are framed as practical, since economic ideas shape political incentives and society's relationship to the biosphere.

The money sections carry the most argument. The narrator contrasts the textbook "loanable funds" picture, in which banks merely lend out existing deposits, with the claim that a loan creates a deposit and a debt together, so money appears from nothing. Paul Krugman is cited as an example of the "less patient people borrowing from more patient people" view. The essay uses the eighth-century coinage of King Offa to argue that fiat currency draws its value from state authority, not metal content, and recommends modeling money through the double entry bookkeeping of banks. From there it makes a contested claim: rising private debt, not government debt, signals approaching crisis, and models that include it produce recessions that grow without equilibrium, resembling the Lorenz attractor.

The later sections turn to two further objections. One concerns aggregation: because incomes and tastes differ, individual demand curves cannot be summed into a macro curve, and textbooks reportedly get around this by assuming a benevolent central authority that redistributes wealth. The other is the omission of energy. The narrator invokes the second law of thermodynamics and the correlation between GDP and energy use, traces the labor-and-capital bias to Adam Smith and his contrast with the physiocrats, and argues that adding energy as a third input misses the point. The essay ends by saying a replacement is not trivial and that the book is an invitation to help build one.

Sharpest takeaway

Mainstream neoclassical economics fundamentally fails to model reality because it relies on linear mathematics and false assumptions about money, aggregation, and energy, making it incapable of predicting crises or addressing ecological limits to growth.

  • Neoclassical equilibrium models cannot explain the 2007 financial crisis or recurring recessions, which require nonlinear dynamics like the Lorenz attractor
  • Private bank debt creation is the true driver of instability, not government money printing, yet mainstream theory treats banks as mere intermediaries
  • Energy and thermodynamic limits are absent from production models, making growth predictions physically impossible at stated rates

The claims · ranked33 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.84

The failure of neoclassical economics to predict crises and its persistence despite empirical failure has real-world consequences because economic ideas underpin major political choices that shape incentives and society's relationship to the biosphere, affecting millions of people's lives.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“this isn't just some quaint academic dispute the ideas of Economics often underpin major political choices that have impacts on millions of people's lives and indeed our relation to the biosphere they shape many of the Dynamics and incentives of our society if we don't improve our understanding and thereby policy around our political economy we have no hope of changing the perverse incentives that are driving so many parts of the meta crisis we're facing”

0.80

To solve the aggregation problem, neoclassical textbooks assume a 'benevolent Central Authority' that redistributes wealth to maximize social welfare in order to make the math work for deriving supply and demand curves—an absurd, unrealistic assumption that directly contradicts free-market ideology.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“let us now hypothesize that there is a process a benevolent Central Authority perhaps that for any given prices P an aggregate wealth function W redistributes wealth in order to maximize social welfare yeah wealth redistribution is assumed in order to get the maths working for deriving the supply and demand curve of the neoc classical free market”

0.80

Historical example: King Offa's 8th-century coins derived their value not from the silver content but from the kingdom's authority and requirement that taxes be paid in coin, demonstrating that fiat currency can enable a thriving economy without commodity backing.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“Keen references the work by Professor Christine danan Who highlights the coinage of the 8th Century King offer as a good example of a fiat currency that enabled a thriving economy without being backed by the silver the coins were made from what gave the coin value is not the commodity it contained the coin was valued at more than the value of the silver from which it was made but the kingdom itself which was carved out by the force of the coin as much as by the force of the sword what enforced the use of the coin was both its creation by the kingdom and its requirement that taxes had to be paid in coin where these taxes replaced a previous practice of forced appropriation”

0.74

Any economic production necessarily creates waste; waste can be minimized but never completely eliminated; and waste must be dumped into the biosphere (at least while production occurs on Earth), meaning zero environmental impact from production is physically impossible.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“Keen also notes that to produce output we must create waste waste can be minimized but not completely eliminated and it must be dumped into the biosphere at least while production occurs only on planet Earth otherwise there can be no production”

0.74

The critical misconception in neoclassical economics is treating money as a commodity-backed promissory note (like a gold standard), but this has not been true for dollars or pounds for over 50 years and was often not true historically.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“the critical misconception at the heart of NE classical thinking about money is that we should think about it as a promiser note standing in place of a commodity typically gold now of course this can be a useful simple way to think about money as a first approximation and there have been times in history in many countries where the currency has indeed been backed by or simply made of gold or silver but it hasn't been true for dollars or pounds for over 50 years and was often not true for many currencies in the past”

0.74

Any economic model must be consistent with the second law of thermodynamics: energy is required to do useful work, all useful work is inefficient (producing waste), and the ultimate source of energy must be a free gift from nature; therefore energy and natural resources are fundamental inputs to production, not optional add-ons.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“Keen notes that any model of economics has to be consistent with the second law of Thermodynamics you need to use energy to do useful work and any such use of energy can never be perfectly efficient and so inevitably creates waste and the ultimate source of this energy is always as a free gift from nature”

0.74

Neoclassical economics completely failed to predict the 2007 Global Financial Crisis, and the dominant theory actually believed crisis could not occur, yet mainstream economists have not undergone a paradigm shift despite this empirical failure.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“one of the most damning recent charges against mainstream neoclassical thinking is that it completely failed to predict the 2007 Global financial crisis the crisis and the sluggish recovery from it surprised both the economists who advise governments on economic policy and the academics who develop the theories and write the textbooks that trained new economists not only had they expected a continuation of the boom conditions that had preceded the crisis they in fact believed that crisis could not occur”

0.73

With correct modeling of private debt, creation and destruction of money by private bank lending naturally leads to unstable dynamics; recessions initially shrink but eventually grow larger without external shocks, and no equilibrium is ever reached—behavior more like the strange attractor of the Lorenz equations.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“Keen notes that Rising private debt not Rising government debt is the main indicator of an approaching crisis private debt not government debt can depress economic activity because it is too high Kean goes on to show that with the correct modeling of private debt it becomes clear that the creation and destruction of money by private bank Lending naturally leads to unstable Dynamics”

0.71

Adam Smith introduced a bias into economic thinking by emphasizing labor (labor theory of value) as the core engine of wealth creation, whereas earlier physiocrats emphasized land and free gifts from nature as fundamental inputs, leading neoclassical successors to downplay energy and natural resources.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“Adam Smith is seen by many as the father of economics but Kean disagrees arguing that it was Smith who introduced an unhelpful bias into economic thinking right from these early days as Smith highlighted labor as the core engine of economic wealth creation in his labor theory of value whereas earlier pre-class iCal economists the physiocrats highlighted land and other free gifts from nature as the fundamental input to the economy”

0.70

Price changes have distributional effects: if apple prices rise due to increased demand, apple sellers' income increases and their consumption patterns change, while non-apple-sellers are unaffected; therefore heterogeneous incomes mean you cannot aggregate individual demand curves into a macro curve.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“if the price of apples goes up because the demand for apples goes up this will have a different impact on the income and purchasing preferences of someone whose business profits more when more apples are being sold compared to the impact on other people but then you can't simply aggregate all of the individual demand curves if their characteristics can vary so much”

0.69

The loanable funds perspective taught in mainstream neoclassical economics claims private banks only create money by loaning out existing deposits from other clients, suggesting banks merely multiply up money created by the central bank, rather than creating new money themselves.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“the standard narrative is that private Banks only create money by loaning out deposits from other clients the loanable funds perspective that suggests that private Banks only multiply up the money originally created by the Central Bank”

0.69

Paul Krugman, a prominent economist, exemplifies the widespread view that when private debt rises, it is merely 'less patient people borrowing from more patient people', not banks creating new money; this misconception is not unique to neoclassical economists.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“think of it this way when debt is rising it's not the economy as a whole borrowing more money it is rather a case of less patient people people who for whatever reason want to spend sooner than later borrowing from more patient people”

0.68

The dependable value of fiat currency is backed by the power and authority of the issuing state, and in today's world where physical cash is rare, money is best understood and modeled through the double-entry bookkeeping of banks that record how much money each person has.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“instead of thinking about money as a token standing in for gold keen and many others argue that the Dependable value of a fiat currency is actually backed by the the power and authority of the issuing State and especially in today's world where we so rarely handle actual notes or coins money is best understood and modeled in terms of the double entry bookkeeping of the banks who keep the records of how much money each of us actually have”

0.68

When a bank makes a loan (e.g., Jane borrows $1,000), the bank creates new money by simultaneously increasing its liability (Jane's loan account) and creating a new asset (Jane's debt obligation), so money is created ex nihilo, not recycled from depositors.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“imagine that Jane wants to expand her shop and so asks to borrow $1,000 from the bank this again is done through Double Entry updates to the bank's balance sheet this time there's an increase in the liability of what the bank now owes Jane of $1,000 but the bank also gains a new asset the $1,000 interest bearing debt that Jane now owes back to the Bank”

0.68

Mainstream neoclassical economics treats private banks and money as mere lubricants to trade between market participants—a 'veil over barter'—and therefore abstrats away the macroeconomic impacts of private bank money creation, which is why economists remained calm about the huge buildup of private debt before 2007.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“the traditional economics perspective wants to see money and private Banks as mere lubricants to the trade between participants in a market a mere Veil over barter they therefore think that the private Banks macr level impacts can mostly be abstracted away”

0.68

Rising private debt, not rising government debt, is the main indicator of an approaching economic crisis, because private debt directly depresses economic activity when it reaches unsustainable levels, while mainstream economists focused on government deficits and the false 'Great Moderation' theory.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“Keen notes that Rising private debt not Rising government debt is the main indicator of an approaching crisis private debt not government debt can depress economic activity because it is too high”

0.66

GDP and energy usage changes are closely correlated, which supports the view that energy is fundamental to economic production, not a separable input, and this relationship is consistent with second law of thermodynamics requirements.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“this approach sits well with the following graph from the book which shows how closely changes in GDP and changes in energy use are correlated and again with the second law of Thermodynamics in mind”

0.65

Mainstream economists recognize energy is missing from production models but attempt to fix this by adding energy as a separate input term alongside labor and capital, which misses the point that capital without energy is merely a sculpture and labor without energy is merely a corpse.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“many mainstream economists have realized that energy is missing from the inputs to the models that they use but some of the standard approaches to fix this do so by just adding energy as a separate new input term alongside labor and capital and Keen argues that this completely misses the point because as Keen puts it capital without energy is a sculpture and labor without energy is a corpse”

0.65

Neoclassical economists attempt to derive macroeconomic supply and demand curves from aggregating individual demand curves, but this is mathematically impossible because different people have different consumption preferences and income levels, so aggregation cannot be done properly.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“neoclassical theorists would like to derive the macr level supply and demand curves of a market from the aggregation of the micr level individual demand curve the way that increases in the price of a good usually leads to a decrease in the individual's demand for that good the difficulty with doing this kind of aggregation is that each individual has a different set of preferences on how to spend any extra income they receive if you give $10 to a homeless person they will spend it differently compared to giving the same $10 to a billionaire”

0.65

The excessive historical focus on labor and capital in economics led neoclassical models to misunderstand or downplay the importance of energy and other natural resources as inputs to production, a fundamental error that persists today.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“Kean suggests that this early excessive focus on labor and capital is what led on through the generations of economists to the neoclassical models that now downplay or misunderstand the importance of energy and other natural resources in their models of production”

0.65

Energy should be incorporated into economic production models by treating both labor and capital as means by which energy is harnessed to perform useful work, making them proportional to energy usage, rather than treating energy as a separate independent input variable.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“Keen suggests that to improve the standard models of production the labor and capital input terms should be made proportional to their respective usage of energy saying energy can therefore be incorporated into the models of production simply by treating both labor and capital as means by which energy is harnessed to perform useful work”

0.65

Neoclassical economics has dominated academia and led mainstream economists to be casually calm about significant climate change prospects in the coming decades, despite physical limits to growth being basic physics and ecology in the long run.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“Kean discusses this history and how neoc classical economic ideas have dominated the academic world too and how this has also LED on to so many mainstream economists being so casually calm about the prospects of sign ific climate change in the next few decades but while the limits to growth can be ignored in the short term it's basic physics and ecology in the long run”

0.63

Mainstream neoclassical economics has clearly failed to be a good theory of the real political economy; replacing it is not trivial, and Keen's book is a call for others to help find a better way of understanding and modeling political economy.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“mainstream neoclassical economics has clearly failed to be a good theory of the real political economy but it is not a trivial problem to replace it and Kean isn't claiming to have all the answers rather his book is a call to others to get involved in finding a better way of understanding and modeling our political economy”

0.62

Mainstream economics only introduces money when explaining inflation (blamed on currency issuers creating too much money too quickly), but this narrow focus misses money's central role in the dynamics of debt and financial instability.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“money is only introduced in mainstream economics when explaining inflation which is blamed on the currency issuer creating too much money too quickly relative to the real rate of growth of the economy now inflation is another whole monetary Dynamic that I will make more videos about someday but it's worth noting that kean's views have some significant overlap with modern monetary Theory”

0.61

There is an extraordinary gap between the political rhetoric of neoclassical free-market ideology underpinning Thatcher-Reagan neoliberal politics and its mathematical foundations, which assume benevolent central wealth redistribution despite decades of massive rises in income and wealth inequality under neoliberalism.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“wealth redistribution is assumed in order to get the maths working for deriving the supply and demand curve of the neoc classical free market the very economics that underpins the Thatcher Reagan neoliberal Politics the world has been living under for decades and that is actually seen massive rises in income and wealth inequalities since the 1970s it's an extraordinary gap between the political rhetoric and the underlying mathematics”

0.60

The 1972 'Limits to Growth' report by the Club of Rome challenged neoclassical orthodoxy by highlighting ecological limits and market externalities that were ignored by mainstream growth ideology, but neoclassical economics and neoliberal politics dominated for 50+ years regardless.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“the idea that there are limits to growth has been known about and argued about for many decades and Keen of course references the famous 1972 limits to growth report by the club of Rome which earlier challenged the mainstream neoclassical Orthodoxy of continual growth ignoring ecological limits and Market externalities but since then we've had over 50 years of neoclassical business as usual with neoliberal politics dominating much of the world's economy”

0.57

Today in 2024, we are 50 years past the 1974 deadline implied by the Limits to Growth report; we are now in the long run where physical limits matter, dangerously close to or beyond those limits; an urgent theoretical revolution in economics is necessary.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“today 2024 was in the long run 50 years ago so we're getting dangerously close to or even Beyond those limits now which is why I totally agree with Kean that there is an urgent need for a theoretical revolution in the field of Economics”

0.55

Physicist Tom Murphy calculates that after 400 years of 2.3% annual economic growth, the heat waste generated from human economic activity would cause Earth's surface to reach boiling point, independent of greenhouse effects or climate change—purely from waste heat dissipation physics.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“Keen also notes that to produce output we must create waste waste can be minimized but not completely eliminated and it must be dumped into the biosphere at least while production occurs only on planet Earth otherwise there can be no production this leads on to Keen referring to an interesting calculation by physicist Tom Murphy who calculates that after 400 years of 2.3% economic growth the amount of heat waste generated would mean that the surface of the Earth reaches boiling point and Mar's calculation has nothing to do with the greenhouse effect in climate change it's purely about the growth at which human economic activity is generating waste heat compared to the rate at which the Earth can radiate heat out into space”

0.51

Similar physical limit calculations exist: even space-faring civilizations face hard physical limits to growth due to finite atoms in the universe, as discussed in William MacAskill's 'What We Owe the Future'; there really are hard limits to long-term continuous economic growth.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“I read a similar kind of calculation about the physical limits to the growth of resource usage even for space fairing civilizations in the book what we owe the future by William mccal in a few thousand years there just aren't enough atoms they really are hard physical limits to long-term continuous economic growth”

0.34

In Godley table accounting, for each entity their assets are their total holdings, liabilities are things they owe to others, equity is their net worth (assets minus liabilities), and the balance sheet constraint requires assets minus liabilities minus equity always equals zero.

definitionestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“for each entity in the economy their stocks are their total assets the value of things that belong to them their liabilities the things that they owe to other people and then the difference between these two is known as their Equity or net worth which is the value of what they own outright after taking account of what they owe to others and to remain con consistent assets minus liabilities minus Equity must always equal zero”

0.34

When a bank accepts a deposit (e.g., Bill deposits $100), this increases the bank's assets but simultaneously creates an equal liability on the bank's balance sheet (the liability being the deposit account), so total money remains unchanged in a simple deposit transaction.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“imagine a client called Bill comes along and deposits $100 into his account this adds to the assets of the bank but also creates an equal and opposite liability for the bank in Bill's client account it's a liability for the bank as someday Bill may come and ask for his money back”

0.30

Keen developed the open-source Minsky program with a colleague to construct dynamic economic models using Godley tables for double-entry bookkeeping to track stocks, flows, assets, liabilities, and equity of all entities in an economy.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“another thread of the book is kean's Introduction to and use of an open source program called Minsky after the economist Hyman Minsky Kean developed the program with his colleague in order to construct Dynamic models of the economy using Godly tables to do the double entry bookkeeping of the entities in the economy”

0.17

A better economic system should aim to be fairer and more sustainable, probably circular in design, which is a project the narrator wants to be involved with and will continue to follow on their channel.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (video essay narrator)

“we can learn to live in a fairer more sustainable probably circular economy and that is certainly a project that I want to be involved with where I can and will continue to follow on this channel”