ex post
After the fact; in regulation, rules or penalties applied after an action has been taken rather than specified in advance.
As defined in John Cochrane on Economic Growth and Changing the Policy Debate
Where it comes up · 13
- Nassim Nicholas Taleb on Rationality, Risk, and Skin in the Game2 claims
- 85 | L.A. Paul on Transformative Experiences and Your Future Selves2 claims
- Larry Summers1 claim
- Stephen Jennings1 claim
- Frank Rose on Storytelling and the Art of Immersion1 claim
- Eugene Fama on Finance1 claim
- Don Boudreaux on Public Debt1 claim
- Campbell Harvey on Randomness, Skill, and Investment Strategies1 claim
and 5 more
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “ex post” →
- Whether a rapidly growing country's infrastructure investment (an airport built where few people are) is brilliant long-term planning or foolish waste depends entirely on subsequent growth, so such investments can only be judged in the very long run—and even then, an ex post good or bad outcome doesn't settle whether the decision was ex ante sensible (as with the Japanese building ahead of overestimated growth, or Dulles Airport derided for decades before vindicating Northern Virginia's tech economy).Larry Summers
- Big data is here to stay and findings from it must be evaluated differently to discard flukes, but the real danger is concocting a story or theory only after a finding emerges; sound practice works from first principles about what is reasonable rather than putting the cart before the horse with ex-post rationalizations.Campbell Harvey on Randomness, Skill, and Investment Strategies
- For most parenting choices, data will almost never give you the answer—it is only part of the picture—because there is too much heterogeneity across kids and choices and the data is too limited; the frustrating reality is parents must make choices without ever knowing if they were correct, neither before nor after the fact.Emily Oster on the Family Firm
- The right regulatory debate is not 'more versus less' but rule of law: good regulation is a knowable rule you can read and obey (like the FAA's 18,000-foot ceiling), whereas modern regulation in banking, health, and most business is vague, complex, applied after the fact, requires permission rather than rule-following, and lacks rights of appeal — making the regulator prosecutor, judge, jury, and executioner.John Cochrane on Economic Growth and Changing the Policy Debate
- Jewish dietary laws, which look irrational judged ex ante, plausibly aided survival because those who eat together stay together; without such laws Jews would have dispersed and become more vulnerable, so the laws should be judged by what their absence would have caused, not by surface rationality.Nassim Nicholas Taleb on Rationality, Risk, and Skin in the Game
- Economists do a great deal of storytelling, much of it ex post—after-the-fact justification of philosophical views rather than science—so a lot of what economics does is closer to fake science than the real thing, and this storytelling is what people consume from economists.Frank Rose on Storytelling and the Art of Immersion
- Development economics is a black box with almost no predictive power—most explanations (policy, location, culture) are ex post and some are tautologies; because development happens across an enormous range of settings from communist dictatorships to liberal systems, with many feedback loops we can't quantify, we cannot predict it, yet the descriptive record shows most of the world following a similar, merely time-shifted, development trajectory.Stephen Jennings
- Ex post narratives about crises are unreliable, and the Lehman and Bear Stearns episodes show that people revise their explanations after outcomes are known; creditors and policymakers can only be judged on what they expected ex ante.Russ Roberts on the Crisis 05/17/2010
- Religion should be judged by its track record (ex post) rather than by a priori rationality (ex ante), because it is not the religion that survives but the people holding it, so beliefs that enabled their survival cannot be dismissed by examining their cosmetic or literal expression.Nassim Nicholas Taleb on Rationality, Risk, and Skin in the Game
- Stories about the Great Depression's end are ex post narratives: after the fact, one can construct a story consistent with some of the data, but a once-in-a-century event cannot be reliably explained by a theory.Russ Roberts on Wealth, Growth, and Economics as a Science 04/20/2009