Frank Rose on Storytelling and the Art of Immersion
What this covers
Frank Rose, author of The Art of Immersion, joins Russ Roberts to explore how the internet has fundamentally altered storytelling. Rose argues that every new medium—from the book to cinema to the web—requires roughly two to three decades to develop its grammar of a medium, a set of techniques and conventions audiences learn to interpret. Where cinema took from 1890 to around 1915 to consolidate tools like cuts and point-of-view shots into recognizable narrative forms, the internet is now undergoing its own apprenticeship. The critical difference, Rose contends, is structural: mass media for 150 years operated as one-way broadcast, while the internet enables multi-directional communication where audiences talk to each other, co-create around stories, and blur boundaries between author and audience, fiction and reality, advertising and entertainment.
The conversation unfolds across concrete examples of this shift in action. Rose traces how fan fiction and alternate reality games like the Dark Knight's NotSoSerious.com have invited millions to inhabit and reshape narratives. He examines Lost's deliberate opacity—a television show that broke from the medium's historical drive for simplicity—and how Lostpedia, a fan-built wiki, grew so authoritative that the show's own producers consulted it. The discussion also considers Will Wright's SimCity and the Sims as games that let players generate their own emergent stories through model-building, and probes the neuroscience behind immersion through Mirror Neurons. Roberts introduces Clay Shirky's theory that immersive participatory media represents the next evolution of leisure-time use beyond passive television. The conversation closes with brief remarks on Steve Jobs and the arc of technological acceptance.
Rose argues that every new medium requires decades to develop its storytelling grammar, and the internet's defining shift is from one-way broadcast to multi-way, participatory immersion that blurs the boundaries between author and audience, fiction and reality, advertising and entertainment.
- New media historically take 20-30 years to develop their storytelling grammar (cinema, ~1890-1915)
- The internet is multi-way rather than one-way, enabling audiences to co-create and share around stories
- Immersion via fan participation (Lost, Dark Knight ARG, fan fiction) reflects a deep human drive to inhabit and retell stories
Technology enables audiences to become active participants and co-creators within stories rather than passive consumers.
- What has changed is not just the audience's ability to influence a story but its ability to write the story—shaping how characters evolve, including by tweeting in the name of a character—an immersion that lets people get into a story in ways impossible before the technology existed.
“What has changed is not just the ability of the audience to influence the story, but...the ability of the audience to write the story...how the characters evolve in response to the audience's sometimes tweeting in the name of a character.”
- Storytelling is pervasive and fundamentally human: people like telling stories, listening to them, and retelling them with their own additions and subtractions—from retelling jokes to communal audience communication—and this retelling and participation is central to how stories live.
“it makes you realize how pervasive storytelling is and how fundamentally human an act it is. We like telling stories, we like listening to stories; and one thing your book made me think about is we like re-telling them.”
- In immersive participatory stories, the crowd exhibits emergent intelligence: any one fan struggles to solve all the clues, but as a group they solve them with surprising speed—sometimes cracking in a single day puzzles designers expected to last weeks or months, leaving the experience effectively out of the designers' control.
“the crowd-sourcing, the wisdom of crowds, the emergent smartness of the ecosystem of these fans. Any one of them has trouble solving all these things but as a group they solve them with lightning speed sometimes, to the surprise of the designers.”
People construct narratives to explain complex phenomena, then marshal evidence to support predetermined stories rather than discover truth.
- Whether explaining a sports team's collapse or the economy, people construct their own stories and then marshal data to support them—a Red Sox fan blames pitching and cites runs-scored stats to prove it, just as left and right tell different, more-or-less entertaining but not necessarily more accurate stories about why the economy struggles; in economics these things are very hard to pin down, so much of it is fake science.
“we all tell our story, Red Sox fans all tell their story, about why they lost...we also of course do it in economics and politics...if you are on the left you have one story...if you are on the right you tell a different story...It's not clear that the stories are more accurate.”
- Economists do a great deal of storytelling, much of it ex post—after-the-fact justification of philosophical views rather than science—so a lot of what economics does is closer to fake science than the real thing, and this storytelling is what people consume from economists.
“What we as economists do--we do a lot of storytelling, much of it ex post, after the fact justification of philosophical views rather than science.”
Emotional and biological responses to fictional narratives reflect profound truths about modern life, prosperity, and human nature.
- Many of the people behind the most creative storytelling and web successes—like college dropout Steve Jobs—did not take the standard American route to financial wellbeing (graduate from college, get a good job); they operated on the fringes of mainstream economic activity and then vaulted to wild success, and college billionaires are a dime a dozen.
“A lot of them were kind of on the edges of being on the fringes of mainstream economic activity and suddenly vaulted, not just to success, but to wild success...It's pretty well known, for example, that there are a lot of college billionaires, Steve Jobs was hardly unique.”
- Although Jobs is credited with creating Apple's products, he did not create most of them directly; he had an extraordinary team, and the hard part—his real achievement—was getting them to work together unified by a vision and a set of imposed principles of taste and usability.
“he didn't create many of them directly. He had an extraordinary team. But that's not enough. The hard part is getting them to work together, unified by a vision that he did clearly impose...principles of taste, usability, etc.”
- The enormous amount of leisure time people devote to immersing themselves in beloved (and unreal) characters and stories—hundreds of hours each, across millions of people—is an extraordinary statement about our standard of living; this could not have happened in 1500 not because of technology alone but because people would have starved to death, so the phenomenon reveals something deep and profound about modern life.
“the use of leisure to immerse yourself in these stories, is an extraordinary statement about our standard of living...it couldn't have happened in 1500...because you'd starve to death. The fact that people can devote hundreds of hundreds of hours personally, and millions can do this says something about modern life that is deep and profound.”
- Reward, competition, and score-keeping are central to what video games exploit—games without points, winning, or goals tend not to do well—and for whatever reason men on average seem to find these competitive, point-driven experiences more exhilarating than women.
“the power of reward, competition, score-keeping; that's what video games exploit...Video games that don't have points, winning, goals you achieve don't do very well...men seem to find those kinds of experiences more exhilarating. On average.”
- We cry when a fictional character dies even though we know it is unreal; the standard explanation that we 'fool ourselves' by pretending it is real is inadequate, because something clearly biological is going on—we cannot help reacting if the story is well-told, rather than choosing to pretend in order to have a good cry.
“the fact that we cry when a fictional character dies in a book...Something clearly biological is going on. It's not like: Let me pretend that this is unreal so I can have a good cry. I can't really help myself if the story is well-told.”
Storytelling permeates economics and advertising because both fields rely fundamentally on narrative and persuasion rather than rigorous science.
- Advertisers are some of the best storytellers, and advertising has become increasingly and almost entirely about storytelling.
“I have believed now for a while that advertisers are some of the best storytellers; and that's become increasingly obvious. It's almost all story-telling.”
- Despite how far web storytelling has come, it remains primitive and unintegrated: reading the book on a Kindle app required leaving the app to wander a YouTube app to find the Coca-Cola 'Happiness Factory' video rather than touching it to play inline, and much of the web is still just print put online (even academic textbooks are essentially PDFs); these trivial frictions, acceptable now, will become unacceptable within a year or five.
“I was struck that I had to get out of my Kindle app and go wander around on my YouTube app. It wasn't a very seamless experience...So much of what is on the web is just print put up on the web...we've got so much more to go.”