categorical imperative
Kant's moral principle that one should act only according to a maxim one could will to become a universal law for everyone.
As defined in et_857
Other definitions
Kant's moral principle of acting as if your action set a universal rule; Weyl invokes it as the logic behind matching small contributors as though each controlled everyone's behavior.
Glen Weyl on Antitrust, Capitalism, and Radical Reform
Where it comes up · 27
- Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals: Bibliotheca Webinar12 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 55 Kant's Ethics6 claims
- Kant's Moral Philosophy3 claims
- 53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality3 claims
- A Theory of Justice: Bibliotheca Webinar3 claims
- Hegel's Philosophy of History2 claims
- How to grow deeply happy | Jonny Thomson2 claims
- Great Minds - Part 4 - Hegel: The Phenomenology of Geist1 claim
and 19 more
Most important claims · 10 of 51Search all claims for “categorical imperative” →
- Moral agency and moral personhood adhere not just to individual persons but also to nations as collective rational agents, obligating all nations to eliminate the state of nature between them by creating international law, just as individuals must create civil law.Kant's Moral Philosophy
- We should take the same attitude toward moral theories as Popper does toward scientific theories: regard all theories claiming to give morality a foundation—Kant's categorical imperative, utilitarianism, Rawlsian fairness, the will of God, human flourishing—as mistaken qua foundations, but all of them have value when regarded instead as critiques; utilitarianism as a fundamental theory is rubbish but as a critique of other theories it is very powerful.52 - Finding Our Way In The Cosmos
- On Kant's view you need God as a practical postulate that agents must assume in order to insist on a connection between virtue and happiness—that the virtuous will be rewarded in an afterlife—so that even though you can't prove God exists, belief in God is a presupposition of your moral agency, with the order God represents underwriting one's moral commitments.Agnes Callard on Philosophy, Progress, and Wisdom
- When returning a lost wallet to a person you dislike, Kant says the action is even more morally important than returning it to a friend, because you are genuinely overcome an immoral impulse driven by heteronomy (your dislike) and forcing yourself to do the right thing through the categorical imperative.Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals: Bibliotheca Webinar
- Utilitarianism (maximize aggregate utility) and deontology/Kantianism (follow hard-and-fast rules regardless of consequences) both claim to possess a formula that makes moral intuition unnecessary, yet each refutes the other only by appealing to moral intuition—the utilitarian invokes our gut sense that betraying Anne Frank is wrong, and the deontologist invokes our gut sense that harvesting one healthy visitor's organs to save five patients is wrong—proving moral intuition is inescapable.Moshe Koppel on Norms, Tradition, and Resilient Societies
- Deontological principles and virtues are only ever nominated as good because we believe they have good consequences on balance; no one would endorse a categorical imperative known to uniformly produce terrible consequences, and a virtue like courage in service of an awful end (e.g., a more courageous Hitler) ceases to be praiseworthy—so non-consequentialist theories covertly smuggle consequentialist assumptions everywhere.305 - Moral Knowledge
- Deontologists and virtue ethicists smuggle good consequences into their theories from the start—no one would defend the categorical imperative if it reliably made everyone miserable, and no sane person would call virtues like generosity good if they caused nothing but pain and chaos—so consequences, whether real or imagined, are ultimately always the point of any ethics.364 - Facts Values
- Criticism that utilitarianism or consequentialism is bad amounts to a claim that it has bad consequences, which can simply be folded into a fuller consequentialism; everyone is in fact some form of consequentialist, since if you listen to people long enough—even deontologists or virtue ethicists—they reveal the consequences they really care about.303 - The Fall Of Sam Bankman-fried
- People who talk about justice in the anti-racist movement really mean revenge—the two can feel the same when one is in the grip of a lust for vengeance—and this abandonment of any commitment to universal values means the movement does not care about fairness or a categorical imperative, only about advancing one's own group, which cannot scale because the next skirmish leaves no neutral standard to appeal to.281 - Western Culture And Its Discontents
- Socrates believed in the Republic that no one is fit to govern other people until they learn to govern themselves; Kant provides a rule for self-governance through the categorical imperative, which is a kind of stoic rule that is very rigid but gives very clear answers about what you must do and must not do.Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals: Bibliotheca Webinar