normative
Treat Moral Foundations as Critiques Not Foundations
We should take the same attitude toward moral theories as Popper does toward scientific theories: regard all theories claiming to give morality a foundation—Kant's categorical imperative, utilitarianism, Rawlsian fairness, the will of God, human flourishing—as mistaken qua foundations, but all of them have value when regarded instead as critiques; utilitarianism as a fundamental theory is rubbish but as a critique of other theories it is very powerful.
normativepending
Speaker
David DeutschEvidence Quote
“regard all the series about morality which claim to give it a foundation as being mistaken but all of them have more or less value some of them much less and some of them much more regarded not as ideas about morality but as critiques”
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:51:39 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...