causal

Utilitarians and deontologists both rely on intuition

Utilitarianism (maximize aggregate utility) and deontology/Kantianism (follow hard-and-fast rules regardless of consequences) both claim to possess a formula that makes moral intuition unnecessary, yet each refutes the other only by appealing to moral intuition—the utilitarian invokes our gut sense that betraying Anne Frank is wrong, and the deontologist invokes our gut sense that harvesting one healthy visitor's organs to save five patients is wrong—proving moral intuition is inescapable.

causalpending

Speaker

Moshe Koppel

Evidence Quote

“What is the utilitarian appealing to at that moment when he says, 'Surely you don't think?'... He is surely appealing to our moral intuition.”

Source

Moshe Koppel on Norms, Tradition, and Resilient Societies— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:24 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...