causal
Deontology and virtue ethics smuggle in consequences
Deontological principles and virtues are only ever nominated as good because we believe they have good consequences on balance; no one would endorse a categorical imperative known to uniformly produce terrible consequences, and a virtue like courage in service of an awful end (e.g., a more courageous Hitler) ceases to be praiseworthy—so non-consequentialist theories covertly smuggle consequentialist assumptions everywhere.
causalpending
Speaker
Sam HarrisEvidence Quote
“it would actually be better for the world if hitler were less courageous you know less self-confident less charismatic... so there's a kind of a paradox there but again it consequentialism runs through it from all sides”
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:53:51 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...