
How to grow deeply happy | Jonny Thomson
What this covers
This eleven-minute Big Think talk features Jonny Thompson, who runs the "Mini Philosophy" account, surveying roughly 2,500 years of thinking about happiness. He starts from Aristotle's argument in the Nicomachean Ethics that everything we do serves some further purpose, so the chain of means and ends must finish at one ultimate end, happiness. From there he organizes Buddhist, Daoist, Greek, and Confucian material into three pillars of happiness, then closes by applying them to everyday unhappiness.
The first pillar separates hedonia, easily measured pleasure such as a night out or a cup of herbal tea, from eudaimonia, flourishing, which is often recognized only in retrospect and can include hard times. The Buddhist case against pleasure is that it is a desire satisfier, and with millions of desires a day, satisfying them is a game of whack-a-mole. The second pillar, moderation, draws on yin and yang and the Daoist middle way. The reasoning is that life is gray rather than black and white.
The third pillar is the most contested: happiness is an emergent state of goodness, so no one is meaningfully happy without being virtuous. Thompson anticipates the objection that virtue varies by culture and era. His answer is five recurring virtue-vice pairs: altruism against egoism, kindness against cruelty, justice against injustice, wisdom against ignorance, and humility against arrogance. He supports them with scattered thinkers and traditions, including Augustine's monastic code, Islamic zakat, Kant, Plato, Mencius, John Rawls, Socrates, and the Buddha. The Golden Rule is traced across Sanskrit, Tamil, Persian, and Greek sources. He also cites Robin Dunbar's work on gossip as social culling to argue that kind people gain friends and, with them, happiness.
Thompson argues that happiness across philosophical traditions rests on three universal pillars—distinguishing it from pleasure, practicing moderation, and cultivating virtue—which together serve as a diagnostic framework for understanding and addressing unhappiness.
- Happiness (eudaimonia) is not synonymous with pleasure (hedonia) and often emerges from difficult experiences when viewed retrospectively
- Moderation and balance across life domains, exemplified by concepts like lagom and the Daoist middle way, are essential to flourishing
- Virtue—specifically altruism, kindness, justice, wisdom, and humility—is an unavoidable requirement for meaningful happiness
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Evolutionary psychologist Robin Dunbar studied gossip and found that it is a kind of social culling mechanism by which people discuss and identify cheaters, liars, and thieves in order to shun them from society; conversely, those who are friendly and kind are welcomed into society, therefore those who are kind and friendly will have friends and those with friends are also happy.
“The evolutionary psychologist Robin Dunbar did a study into gossip, and he argued that gossip is a kind of social culling where we talk about the cheaters and the liars and the thieves in our lives so we can shun them from society. Inversely, those who are friendly and kind will be welcomed into society. So what we can conclude is those who are kind and those who are friendly will have friends and those who have friends are also happy.”
The ancient Greeks distinguished between hedonia (simple pleasure—easily measurable emotional affect like a night out with friends or drinking herbal tea) and eudaimonia (flourishing—a deeper state that often involves retrospectively viewing difficult experiences as moments of supreme happiness).
“So the ancient Greeks had a lot of different words for happiness, and one of them is hedonia. And hedonia is what we might want to call simple pleasure. It's the big night out with some friends, but it's also drinking a herbal tea on the sofa. It's quite easy to measure and it's quite easy to understand because it's an emotional affect. Eudaimonia though is a much harder word to understand. It's often translated as "flourishing." And the reason why it's difficult to understand is that it's often understood in reverse. So there are many moments in life where we look back on our experiences and think they were really hard at the time, but actually we were supremely happy. For example, raising young kids or even school can be quite hard at the time, but we look back and think, "Those were moments when I was deeply, supremely happy."”
In Daoism, yin represents the dark, mysterious, elusive, fluid, and watery aspects of existence, while yang represents the exciting, passionate, loud, sunny, and true aspects; happiness requires finding the middle path between yin and yang rather than privileging one over the other.
“So yin tends to represent the dark, the mysterious, the elusive, water, fluidity, and yang tends to represents the exciting, the passionate, the loud, the sunny, and truth. And so for Daoists, we have to find the middle path, which is walking between yin and yang.”
Kindness vs. cruelty is the second universal virtue-vice pair, represented most famously by the Golden Rule ('do unto others as you would have them do unto you'), which appears not only in the Gospels but also in Sanskrit, Tamil, Persian, ancient Greek texts, the Vedas, in Kant's categorical imperative, and in Aquinas's natural law.
“And the second is kindness and cruelty. So this is best represented by the golden mean, which most people are familiar with this from the gospels, which is "do unto others as you'd have them do unto you," but it's not just in the gospels. It's seen in Sanskrit, in Tamil, in Persian, in ancient Greece, and in the Vedas. But it's also seen in modern times in Kant's first categorical imperative and in Aquinas's natural law: be good and kind to other people.”
The ancient Greeks had multiple words for happiness: hedonia (simple pleasure, easily measured and understood) and eudaimonia (flourishing, harder to understand because it is often understood in reverse—experienced retrospectively even during hard times).
“the ancient Greeks had a lot of different words for happiness, and one of them is hedonia. And hedonia is what we might want to call simple pleasure. It's the big night out with some friends, but it's also drinking a herbal tea on the sofa. It's quite easy to measure and it's quite easy to understand because it's an emotional affect. Eudaimonia though is a much harder word to understand. It's often translated as 'flourishing.' And the reason why it's difficult to understand is that it's often understood in reverse.”
The first universal virtue is altruism (vice: egoism), which is the virtue of other-regardedness, charity, and caring for other people; it is found in Augustine's monastic code, Islam's zakat (almsgiving), and in the work of Peter Singer, Immanuel Kant, and Thomas Aquinas.
“The first is altruism and the vice egoism. So this is seen in Augustine's code for monks, and it's seen in Islam's zakat. It's there in Peter Singer and Immanuel Kant and Thomas Aquinas. And the idea is a sense of other-regardedness, charity and caring for other people.”
Across philosophical and theological traditions, certain universal 'lights' or beacons recur as guides to right living: Confucius's idea of right virtue, Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics, and Al-Ghazali's idea that the right way is in accordance with Allah.
“It's found in Confucius's idea of right virtue, it's found in Aristotle's Nicomachean ethics, and it's found in Al-Ghazali's idea that the right way is in accordance with Allah.”
The second universal virtue is kindness (vice: cruelty), exemplified by the golden mean ('do unto others as you'd have them do unto you'), which appears in the gospels, Sanskrit, Tamil, Persian, ancient Greece, the Vedas, Kant's categorical imperative, and Aquinas's natural law.
“the second is kindness and cruelty. So this is best represented by the golden mean, which most people are familiar with this from the gospels, which is 'do unto others as you'd have them do unto you,' but it's not just in the gospels. It's seen in Sanskrit, in Tamil, in Persian, in ancient Greece, and in the Vedas. But it's also seen in modern times in Kant's first categorical imperative and in Aquinas's natural law: be good and kind to other people.”
The third universal virtue is justice (vice: injustice), understood as retribution for wrongdoing; philosophers as diverse as Plato, Mencius, and John Rawls would agree on the necessity of justice.
“The third virtue/vice is justice and injustice. I think if you put Plato and Mencius and John Rawls in the same room, they would agree about the need for justice, which is the idea of some kind of retribution for wrongdoers.”
The fourth universal virtue is wisdom (vice: ignorance), grounded in Socrates' dictum that 'the unexamined life is not worth living' and the Buddha's encouragement of disciples to meditate on the universe; no major philosopher treated seriously for long advocates for ignorance.
“The fourth virtue/vice is wisdom and ignorance. Socrates famously wrote that, 'The unexamined life is not worth living.' And the Buddha encouraged his disciples to meditate at great length on the universe. I can't think of any major philosopher who's been treated seriously for long who advocates for ignorance.”
In Buddhism, pleasure is defined as a desire satisfier (satisfying a want), but this creates an impossible game because humans have millions of desires daily and there is no way to satisfy them all—like 'whack-a-mole'—so if people are to be happy at all, it must be found outside the notion of pleasure.
“So Buddhists tend to define pleasure as being a desire satisfier. So I want a drink of water, and so I reach for the water and I drink it, and that gives me a pleasure. But the problem of course is that this is an unwinning game. Every day we have millions and millions of desires, and there's no way we can satisfy them all. It's like a game of whack-a-mole. If we're to be happy at all, it has to be found outside of this notion of pleasure. We have to step beyond hedonia.”
The second pillar emerging across all philosophical traditions is moderation—finding a middle way, because life is not black and white but rather a 'confused and confusing cocktail of things,' and everything is gray.
“And the second pillar, the second light which emerges across all these traditions is moderation, that we have to find a middle way. It's essential to Daoism. And the idea is that life is not black or white, but rather it's a confused and confusing cocktail of things. Everything is gray.”
Justice vs. injustice is the third universal virtue-vice pair—Plato, Mencius, and John Rawls would all agree on the need for justice, understood as some kind of retribution or accountability for wrongdoers, despite philosophical differences in other areas.
“And the third virtue/vice is justice and injustice. I think if you put Plato and Mencius and John Rawls in the same room, they would agree about the need for justice, which is the idea of some kind of retribution for wrongdoers.”
Wisdom vs. ignorance is the fourth universal virtue-vice pair—Socrates declared that 'the unexamined life is not worth living,' and the Buddha encouraged lengthy meditation on the universe; Thompson notes that no major philosopher treated seriously for a long time has advocated for ignorance.
“The fourth virtue/vice is wisdom and ignorance. Socrates famously wrote that, "The unexamined life is not worth living." And the Buddha encouraged his disciples to meditate at great length on the universe. I can't think of any major philosopher who's been treated seriously for long who advocates for ignorance.”
The third pillar of happiness is that happiness is an unavoidable emergent state of goodness: one cannot be truly and meaningfully happy unless one is also virtuous.
“the third thing that I notice appearing is the idea that happiness is an unavoidable, emergent state of goodness, that you cannot be truly and meaningfully happy unless you are also virtuous.”
To apply the third pillar (happiness requires goodness), evolutionary psychologist Robin Dunbar's research on gossip supports the claim: gossip functions as social culling where people discuss cheaters, liars, and thieves to shun them from society; conversely, friendly and kind people are welcomed into society and have friends, and those with friends are happy.
“Pillar number three is that happiness requires goodness, which might seem ridiculous to lots of people, because we can point to people who seem to be pretty cruel or immoral and yet they seem to be also very happy. But the evolutionary psychologist Robin Dunbar did a study into gossip, and he argued that gossip is a kind of social culling where we talk about the cheaters and the liars and the thieves in our lives so we can shun them from society. Inversely, those who are friendly and kind will be welcomed into society. So what we can conclude is those who are kind and those who are friendly will have friends and those who have friends are also happy.”
Aristotle argues that everything we do in life is for some further purpose, forming a chain of means to ends that culminates in the ultimate end: happiness.
“Aristotle argues that everything we do in life is for some further purpose. So I go to school to get an education, I get an education to get a job, and I get a job so that I get money to buy nice things, and so on and so on. But the question Aristotle asks is what is the end point of all this? What lies at the top of the ladder? And for Aristotle, the point of all human life is to reach happiness.”
The third pillar is that happiness is an unavoidable emergent state of virtue: one cannot be truly and meaningfully happy unless one is also virtuous—because definitions of virtue vary across cultures and time, this raises the question of what 'virtuous' means.
“But the third thing that I notice appearing is the idea that happiness is an unavoidable, emergent state of goodness, that you cannot be truly and meaningfully happy unless you are also virtuous. But of course, this raises a problem, and the problem is, what does "virtuous" mean? Because if we zoom in on any different culture and any different time, what people define as right and wrong and good and bad will change from person to person, from philosopher to philosopher.”
Aristotle argues in the Nicomachean Ethics that everything humans do in life is for some further purpose, and the ultimate end point or summum bonum of all human life is happiness (eudaimonia).
“So in his "Nicomachean Ethics," Aristotle argues that everything we do in life is for some further purpose. So I go to school to get an education, I get an education to get a job, and I get a job so that I get money to buy nice things, and so on and so on. But the question Aristotle asks is what is the end point of all this? What lies at the top of the ladder? And for Aristotle, the point of all human life is to reach happiness.”
Despite the apparent relativism of virtue across cultures and times, certain virtues have consistently been called virtues and certain vices have consistently been called vices throughout history—Thompson identifies five universal virtue-vice pairs: altruism vs. egoism, kindness vs. cruelty, justice vs. injustice, wisdom vs. ignorance, and humility vs. arrogance.
“So if you look at the history of philosophy, what you find is that certain virtues have always been called virtues and certain vices have always been called vices. I think we can identify five.”
The first pillar of happiness is that happiness is not measured by pleasure; this principle appears across many philosophical schools.
“The first pillar or like number one is the idea that happiness is not measured by pleasure.”
Buddhism defines pleasure as a desire satisfier (the process of wanting something and then satisfying that want), which creates an unwinnable game because humans have millions of desires each day and cannot satisfy them all.
“Buddhists tend to define pleasure as being a desire satisfier. So I want a drink of water, and so I reach for the water and I drink it, and that gives me a pleasure. But the problem of course is that this is an unwinnable game. Every day we have millions and millions of desires, and there's no way we can satisfy them all.”
The second pillar of happiness is moderation: finding a middle way, which is essential to Daoism and the concept that life is not black-or-white but a confused and confusing cocktail of things, where everything is gray.
“the second pillar, the second light which emerges across all these traditions is moderation, that we have to find a middle way. It's essential to Daoism. And the idea is that life is not black or white, but rather it's a confused and confusing cocktail of things. Everything is gray.”
Humility vs. arrogance is the fifth universal virtue-vice pair, with two strands: (1) intellectual humility, best represented by John Stuart Mill, and (2) existential humility found in religions like Christianity (Karl Barth), Judaism (Maimonides), and Islam (which literally means 'surrender to Allah')—the recognition that one is not the center of the universe and that there are forces beyond one's understanding to which one must occasionally bow.
“And the fifth virtue/vice is humility and arrogance. And I think this has two strands really. The first is a kind of intellectual humility, which is represented best by John Stuart Mill, and the second is a kind of existential humility, which is represented by the religions. It's in Karl Barth, it's in Maimonides, and the word "Islam" literally translates as "surrender to Allah." This is the idea that you are not the center of the universe. There are things outside of your understanding which are far more powerful and which we occasionally have to bow to.”
Altruism (other-regardedness) vs. egoism is the first universal virtue-vice pair, found in Augustine's monastic code, Islam's zakat principle, and in the ethics of Peter Singer, Immanuel Kant, and Thomas Aquinas—all emphasizing caring for and benefiting other people.
“The first is altruism and the vice egoism. So this is seen in Augustine's code for monks, and it's seen in Islam's zakat. It's there in Peter Singer and Immanuel Kant and Thomas Aquinas. And the idea is a sense of other-regardedness, charity and caring for other people.”
Despite cultural and historical variation in moral definitions, certain virtues have always been called virtues and certain vices have always been called vices across philosophical traditions; five universal virtues can be identified.
“if you look at the history of philosophy, what you find is that certain virtues have always been called virtues and certain vices have always been called vices. I think we can identify five.”
Moderation is exemplified in the Swedish lifestyle concept of lagom, which means 'just the right amount,' and has two elements: a fair usage policy (not taking all resources) and a recognition that sometimes less is more (diminishing returns to excess).
“it's in the Swedish lifestyle concept of lagom, which means 'just the right amount.' And there's two elements to it, really. The first element is a kind of fair usage policy where if I take all of the cookies in the cookie jar, then it leaves none for anybody else. And so what I do will affect other people. The second element of lagom is a kind of recognition that sometimes less really is more.”
The fifth universal virtue is humility (vice: arrogance), which has two strands: intellectual humility (exemplified by John Stuart Mill) and existential humility (the recognition that one is not the center of the universe and must sometimes bow to more powerful forces; found in Karl Barth, Maimonides, and the Islamic concept of surrender to Allah).
“the fifth virtue/vice is humility and arrogance. And I think this has two strands really. The first is a kind of intellectual humility, which is represented best by John Stuart Mill, and the second is a kind of existential humility, which is represented by the religions. It's in Karl Barth, it's in Maimonides, and the word 'Islam' literally translates as 'surrender to Allah.' This is the idea that you are not the center of the universe. There are things outside of your understanding which are far more powerful and which we occasionally have to bow to.”
In Daoism, yin represents the dark, mysterious, elusive, watery, and fluid aspects of existence, while yang represents the exciting, passionate, loud, sunny, and true aspects; harmony is achieved by finding the middle path between yin and yang.
“yin tends to represent the dark, the mysterious, the elusive, water, fluidity, and yang tends to represents the exciting, the passionate, the loud, the sunny, and truth. And so for Daoists, we have to find the middle path, which is walking between yin and yang.”
The concept of virtue is culturally and historically variable—what people define as right, wrong, good, and bad changes from person to person and from philosopher to philosopher across cultures and time periods.
“this raises a problem, and the problem is, what does 'virtuous' mean? Because if we zoom in on any different culture and any different time, what people define as right and wrong and good and bad will change from person to person, from philosopher to philosopher.”
Life can be understood through a Daoist metaphor as a dense, thorny forest with a well-paved superhighway down the middle; the easy path is the mainstream route, but there are many alternative paths through swamps, thorns, and hills that are difficult but may lead to happiness.
“I think Daoism offers a really good analogy here. So imagine life as like a dense, thorny forest, and in the middle of this forest is a well-paved superhighway. And it's easy to walk along that path, but there are other paths, but these paths go through swamps, they go through thorns, they go up and down hills, and they are difficult, and I think happiness is a little bit like that.”
The history of philosophy, when mapped like a heat map, reveals certain recurring themes across all traditions: happiness, how to live the best life, and how to be a good person.
“if you imagine the history of philosophy as some kind of big heat map, there are certain themes start to emerge, and they're all to do with happiness, they're all to do with how to live the best life and how to be a good person.”
If one is unhappy, the foundational question becomes: what is going on? The task is then to find the right path again, guided by universal 'lights' or beacons that emerge across philosophical and theological traditions.
“So if we imagine happiness as being on the right path, if we follow the Daoist metaphor, then the question we've got to ask ourselves is if we are unhappy, what's going on there? And the question then is about finding the right path again. There are certain lights which emerge in the history of philosophy and theology as well which are meant to act as beacons or guides which we can walk towards.”
When viewing the history of philosophy as a 'heat map,' certain universal themes emerge across all traditions: they all address how to achieve happiness and how to live the best life and be a good person, with different schools (epicureanism, cynicism, stoicism, skepticism) each offering their own version of happiness.
“If you imagine the history of philosophy as some kind of big heat map, there are certain themes start to emerge, and they're all to do with happiness, they're all to do with how to live the best life and how to be a good person. You have epicureanism, you have cynicism, you have stoicism, and you have skepticism. And they're all trying to sell their different version of happiness, and they're literally trying to sell to their disciples that their way is the best way to be happy.”
Daoism offers a useful analogy for understanding happiness: life is like a dense, thorny forest with a well-paved superhighway through the middle, but there are also difficult alternative paths through swamps and over hills—happiness emerges from finding and walking the 'right path' while avoiding the seductive 'sirens' calls' that lead one astray.
“I think Daoism offers a really good analogy here. So imagine life as like a dense, thorny forest, and in the middle of this forest is a well-paved superhighway. And it's easy to walk along that path, but there are other paths, but these paths go through swamps, they go through thorns, they go up and down hills, and they are difficult, and I think happiness is a little bit like that. There's certain paths to happiness which feel right and are right, but there are so many different paths with their different sirens' calls which attract us, and I think we don't realize we're on the wrong path often until it's too late and we find the going really difficult.”
Thompson's three pillars can be applied practically as a diagnostic tool: when people feel unhappy, they can examine which pillar they are not meeting—whether they are confusing a difficult patch of life with unhappiness, going to extremes instead of seeking moderation, or failing to be virtuous—and taking steps to address the specific deficit.
“What I find really interesting is if you zoom out and look at the history of philosophy, you see these three pillars emerging, and they act essentially as a diagnostic tool. If you feel you are unhappy in life, you can look at these pillars and think, "Which of these three am I not meeting? Is it that I'm confusing a hard patch of my life with being unhappy? Is it that I'm going to two extremes? Or is it that possibly I'm not being as good as I could be?" If we recognize that those are the problems in our life, we can take steps to fix it.”
Happiness is elusive and often misunderstood because it is conflated with shallow emotional states (beaming smiles and social media celebration), when happiness is actually a 'smiling soul' rather than a smiling face.
“I think it's so elusive because the term itself is so laden. We associate happiness as being this beaming smile with a selfie on social media, but I think happiness is not a smiling face, it's more a smiling soul.”
The three pillars function as a diagnostic tool: if one feels unhappy, one can examine which pillar is being violated—is one confusing a hard patch with unhappiness, going to extremes, or failing to be as good as one could be?—and take steps to fix it.
“What I find really interesting is if you zoom out and look at the history of philosophy, you see these three pillars emerging, and they act essentially as a diagnostic tool. If you feel you are unhappy in life, you can look at these pillars and think, 'Which of these three am I not meeting? Is it that I'm confusing a hard patch of my life with being unhappy? Is it that I'm going to two extremes? Or is it that possibly I'm not being as good as I could be?' If we recognize that those are the problems in our life, we can take steps to fix it.”
People often do not realize they are on the wrong path to happiness until it is too late and they find the going really difficult, because there are many seductive alternative paths ('sirens' calls') that attract them away from the right path.
“There's certain paths to happiness which feel right and are right, but there are so many different paths with their different sirens' calls which attract us, and I think we don't realize we're on the wrong path often until it's too late and we find the going really difficult.”
To apply the second pillar (moderation), dieting provides the best example: most diets fail within weeks or months because they are extreme ('I will go to the gym every day,' 'I will never drink alcohol again'), whereas the most effective diets allow flexibility and moderation—the middle way works for most people.
“Pillar number two is the idea of moderation in all things, and I think this is best seen in dieting. So most diets end within a month, if not weeks, and most new year's resolutions end pretty quickly. It's 'I'm gonna go to the gym every day and run half marathons' or 'I'm going to give up chocolate' or 'I'm never gonna drink alcohol ever again.' And they fail because they are so extreme. And the best diets in history allow a degree of flexibility and moderation. So dieting when it's done at these extremes does work for some people, no doubt, but for most people, dieting is best when it happens in the middle way.”
Major philosophical schools—epicureanism, cynicism, stoicism, and skepticism—all attempt to sell their own version of happiness to their disciples, each claiming theirs is the best way to be happy.
“You have epicureanism, you have cynicism, you have stoicism, and you have skepticism. And they're all trying to sell their different version of happiness, and they're literally trying to sell to their disciples that their way is the best way to be happy.”
Happiness is often confused with pleasure or a beaming smile on social media, but genuine happiness is better understood as 'a smiling soul'—an internal state rather than an emotional expression.
“I think it's so elusive because the term itself is so laden. We associate happiness as being this beaming smile with a selfie on social media, but I think happiness is not a smiling face, it's more a smiling soul.”
Most diets and New Year's resolutions fail within weeks or a month because they are extreme ('go to the gym every day,' 'give up chocolate entirely,' 'never drink alcohol again'), but the best diets in history allow flexibility and moderation, showing that for most people dieting works best when pursued in the middle way.
“So most diets end within a month, if not weeks, and most new year's resolutions end pretty quickly. It's "I'm gonna go to the gym every day and run half marathons" or "I'm going to give up chocolate" or "I'm never gonna drink alcohol ever again." And they fail because they are so extreme. And the best diets in history allow a degree of flexibility and moderation. So dieting when it's done at these extremes does work for some people, no doubt, but for most people, dieting is best when it happens in the middle way.”
Parenting is a concrete example of Pillar 1 (happiness ≠ pleasure): parents often post about their stress, sleep deprivation, and misery, yet when questioned about whether children make them happy, they respond that they are 'the happiest they've ever been,' showing that looking back at an entire stage of life reveals deep existential happiness despite the hard ingredients within it.
“If you ever go on social media and you see a reel or a post about a new parent, it's inevitably moaning about something: Their sleep-deprived nights or the germs or their kids aren't eating anything, and it's full of stress and what appears to be misery. But then if you commented on those posts saying, "Well, why did you bother having kids in the first place?" or "Why do kids make you unhappy?" often parents will reply, "I'm the happiest I've ever been." And I think parenting is an example of looking back at a stage of your life and thinking, "All of the ingredients might have been pretty hard in themselves, but as a whole, I was deeply, existentially happy."”
When zooming out to examine all philosophical traditions, certain commonalities emerge: if happiness involves being on the right path (per the Daoist metaphor), then unhappiness signals being on a wrong path, and across philosophy and theology, there are certain 'lights' or 'beacons' that can guide people back to the right path—found in Confucius's idea of right virtue, Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics, and Al-Ghazali's idea that the right way accords with Allah.
“But if you zoom out, you do start to notice certain commonalities and certain themes. So if we imagine happiness as being on the right path, if we follow the Daoist metaphor, then the question we've got to ask ourselves is if we are unhappy, what's going on there? And the question then is about finding the right path again. There are certain lights which emerge in the history of philosophy and theology as well which are meant to act as beacons or guides which we can walk towards. It's found in Confucius's idea of right virtue, it's found in Aristotle's Nicomachean ethics, and it's found in Al-Ghazali's idea that the right way is in accordance with Allah.”
Thompson identifies three universal 'pillars' or 'lights' of happiness emerging across all philosophical and theological traditions: (1) happiness is not measured by pleasure, (2) moderation and balance are essential, and (3) happiness is an unavoidable emergent state of virtue—one cannot be truly and meaningfully happy unless one is also virtuous.
“I've identified three lights or what I like to call pillars of happiness. The first pillar or like number one is the idea that happiness is not measured by pleasure... But the second pillar, the second light which emerges across all these traditions is moderation... But the third thing that I notice appearing is the idea that happiness is an unavoidable, emergent state of goodness, that you cannot be truly and meaningfully happy unless you are also virtuous.”
There are many moments in life where people look back on difficult experiences (such as raising young children or going through school) and recognize they were supremely happy at the time, even though the experiences involved significant hardship.
“there are many moments in life where we look back on our experiences and think they were really hard at the time, but actually we were supremely happy. For example, raising young kids or even school can be quite hard at the time, but we look back and think, 'Those were moments when I was deeply, supremely happy.'”
To apply the three pillars to daily life, the first pillar (happiness is not pleasure) is exemplified by parenting: parents report stress and misery on social media, but when asked why they had children, often reply that they are 'the happiest I've ever been,' demonstrating that all the hard ingredients together constitute deep, existential happiness.
“for pillar number one, which is the idea that happiness cannot be measured by pleasure, I think a really good example of this is parenting. If you ever go on social media and you see a reel or a post about a new parent, it's inevitably moaning about something...it's full of stress and what appears to be misery. But then if you commented on those posts saying, 'Well, why did you bother having kids in the first place?' or 'Why do kids make you unhappy?' often parents will reply, 'I'm the happiest I've ever been.' And I think parenting is an example of looking back at a stage of your life and thinking, 'All of the ingredients might have been pretty hard in themselves, but as a whole, I was deeply, existentially happy.'”
If people are to be happy at all, happiness must be found outside the notion of pleasure; they must step beyond hedonia.
“If we're to be happy at all, it has to be found outside of this notion of pleasure. We have to step beyond hedonia.”
If one is having coffee with a friend, that is fun and enjoyable; however, if one has seven coffees, it is not so much—demonstrating that moderation and balance appear repeatedly through different philosophical threads.
“if I'm having a coffee with a friend, that's fun, that's enjoyable, but if I have seven coffees, it's not so much. And this idea of moderation and balance appears again and again through different threads in philosophy.”
It is a logical fallacy to infer from 'pleasure does not equal happiness' that 'suffering therefore must equal happiness'; the risk is fetishizing suffering as essential to flourishing, which is false.
“It's a logical fallacy to say that just because pleasure doesn't equal happiness, that suffering therefore must. And it's a risk that we fetishize suffering, that we enjoy this kind of masochistic misery and we see that as essential to flourishing. But of course, that's not true.”
It is a logical fallacy to conclude that because pleasure does not equal happiness, suffering therefore must; this would be fetishizing suffering and mistaking masochistic misery for flourishing, which is incorrect.
“But the problem is that we risk going too far. It's a logical fallacy to say that just because pleasure doesn't equal happiness, that suffering therefore must. And it's a risk that we fetishize suffering, that we enjoy this kind of masochistic misery and we see that as essential to flourishing. But of course, that's not true.”
The Swedish lifestyle concept lagom ('just the right amount') embodies the principle of moderation and has two elements: (1) a fair usage policy recognizing that overconsumption affects others, and (2) recognition that less is often more—having one coffee with a friend is enjoyable, but seven coffees diminishes the benefit.
“And the Swedish lifestyle concept of lagom, which means "just the right amount." And there's two elements to it, really. The first element is a kind of fair usage policy where if I take all of the cookies in the cookie jar, then it leaves none for anybody else. And so what I do will affect other people. The second element of lagom is a kind of recognition that sometimes less really is more. And so for example, if I'm having a coffee with a friend, that's fun, that's enjoyable, but if I have seven coffees, it's not so much.”
The principle of moderation and balance appears repeatedly across different threads in philosophy, not just in Daoism and lagom, indicating its universality as a requirement for happiness.
“And this idea of moderation and balance appears again and again through different threads in philosophy.”
If one zooms out from the details of individual philosophical schools, one begins to notice certain commonalities and recurring themes across traditions.
“But if you zoom out, you do start to notice certain commonalities and certain themes.”
Thompson founded the Mini Philosophy project seven years ago with the aim of teaching philosophy to everybody by identifying common themes across different philosophical traditions and schools.
“So I started the Mini Philosophy project about seven years ago, and the aim was to try to teach philosophy to everybody. The idea was to duck and weave my way through the different philosophical traditions and different philosophical schools.”