Scientism
Hayek's term for the false application of natural-science methods and pretense of knowledge to complex systems that cannot truly be modeled that way
As defined in Eric Topol on the Creative Destruction of Medicine
Other definitions
The error of treating questions that are not scientific (such as moral questions) as if they could be settled by science or empirical study.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge - Taking Children Seriously | The Lunar Society #15
Where it comes up · 41
- The 4 Horsemen of Meaning | Bishop Barron, John Vervaeke, and Jonathan Pageau | EP 2044 claims
- Nassim Nicholas Taleb on the Precautionary Principle and Genetically Modified Organisms3 claims
- Robert Burton on Being Certain3 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 73 19th Century Empiricism2 claims
- Bruce Caldwell on Hayek2 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 75 Ludwig Wittgenstein2 claims
- Valerie Ramey on Stimulus and Multipliers 10/24/20111 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 69 Nietzsche and Introduction to Phenomenology1 claim
and 33 more
Most important claims · 10 of 51Search all claims for “Scientism” →
- Although Hayek became associated with the Chicago School, his thinking diverged sharply: the Chicago School exhibited an epistemological arrogance, believing it possible through rigorous empirics and theory to know a great deal about the economy and was untroubled by uncertainty, whereas Hayek's 1930s-40s work was motivated by a fear and distrust of 'scientism'—the idea that social science could be modeled on the methods of natural science—and by the impossibility of full social-scientific knowledge.Will Davies on the Economics, Economists, and the Limits of Neoliberalism
- A young person who wants to be part of the robotics evolution should study computer science and the social sciences at the same time, because designing engineering systems that are situated within social and political systems makes for better, more successful systems—a rejection of 'scientism,' the idea that you can calculate everything about the world in advance and that the user is an idiot with nothing to add.David Mindell on Our Robots, Ourselves
- The problem is not scientism per se but scientism—the elevation of physical science to the supreme position among all forms of knowledge, when properly it should be subordinate to philosophy and theology, which deal with ultimate meaning and the summum bonum.The 4 Horsemen of Meaning | Bishop Barron, John Vervaeke, and Jonathan Pageau | EP 204
- The most important way to do science better is for people to be more willing to accept they might be wrong; we romanticize the objectivity of scientists, who in fact have their own pet theories, fads, and reputations, so good science is genuinely hard.Russ Roberts
- Scientism—the position that scientific method is the only acceptable method for obtaining reliable knowledge—extends through 19th-century philosophy into Russell's early 20th-century logical atomism and early Wittgenstein's Tractatus.A History of Philosophy | 75 Ludwig Wittgenstein
- A skeptical empiricist should refuse to accept the ex-post narrative and instead demand the data to infer the general distribution, including estimating the probability of extreme events, in contrast to the deceptive use of data that gives statements an air of scientism without being scientific.Nassim Nicholas Taleb on Black Swans
- Hayek's concept of 'scientism' applies to the Wakefield case: it is the use of the language and tools of science to create a scientific impression that is not actually scientific.Brian Deer on Autism, Vaccination, and Scientific Fraud 01/31/2011
- The boundaries between academic disciplines are mere conventions, like political borders on a map; we inhabit a single sphere in which to form true beliefs about the world, so there is no real boundary between physics and biology or even physics and sociology, and a thinker in one field can legitimately make breakthroughs in any other—what matters is the nature of reality, not how we organize our talk about it in universities.364 - Facts Values
- By the 1950s Hayek reframed his scientism critique not as a contrast between natural and social sciences but as a contrast between sciences that study simple versus complex phenomena; economics belongs to the complex category, where you can make pattern predictions but not specific predictions, meaning we cannot do what would be needed to intervene successfully in social phenomena.Bruce Caldwell on Hayek
- Like the financial sector where people build complicated models and believe they know what they're doing while being poorly incentivized, medicine risks hubris and overconfidence—evidence-based medicine practitioners think they are doing science but are engaged in what Hayek called 'scientism', fooling themselves about complex systems they cannot truly model.Eric Topol on the Creative Destruction of Medicine