What this covers

This is a university lecture in a history-of-philosophy series, delivered by a single lecturer who also appears in the material as a philosophy professor. It splits into two halves. The first finishes with Friedrich Nietzsche, and the second introduces phenomenology through Edmund Husserl and the thinkers who came out of his orbit.

The Nietzsche portion covers a good deal besides the postmodern legacy. It separates his biological vitalism, in which life is a creative force that overcomes its environment, from Darwinian adaptation, and notes that vitalism has been outdated since biochemistry and the discovery of DNA. It describes his dismantling of every rational account of the universe, his claim that logic arose from the illogical, and his view that false opinions can be indispensable to life. His emotivist ethics and thoroughgoing egoism come up, as does the self-undermining paradox of denying all truth while demanding commitment, which the professor compares to the liar's paradox. The lecture also groups him with Sigmund Freud and Karl Marx, since each places a non-rational substructure beneath conscious belief. The idea of inverted Platonism, in which theory determines fact, is used to read contemporary academic culture.

The phenomenology half begins with Husserl's opposition to naturalism and his insistence that phenomenology is a method and project, not a theory or position. It distinguishes his study of the transcendental ego from existential phenomenology, and places Søren Kierkegaard and Nietzsche as an earlier, introspective phase of existentialism. Along the way it sketches Heidegger's and Sartre's departures from Husserl and the French line through Merleau-Ponty and Paul Ricoeur. It then turns to hermeneutics and Gadamer's treatment of subjectivity in interpretation. A biographical aside recounts how Husserl's papers, smuggled across the Belgian border, led Louvain to shift from Thomism to phenomenology.

Sharpest takeaway

This lecture traces Nietzsche's philosophical influence on postmodernism through his rejection of objective truth, his biological vitalism, and his reduction of knowledge to expressions of will to power rather than rational correspondence to reality, arguing this intellectual current fundamentally shapes contemporary university culture and epistemology.

  • Nietzsche deconstructs every rational theory about the universe, arguing all knowledge claims are expressions of will to power and biological utility rather than truth-seeking
  • His biologism (vitalism rather than Darwinian evolution) combined with his epistemological relativism creates a framework where power politics, not truth, becomes the arbiter of competing claims
  • Contemporary postmodernism and university politicization represent Nietzsche's influence inverted—truth claims replaced by power assertions justified through competing ideological frameworks

The claims · ranked40 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

Nietzsche deconstructs every known rational theory about the universe—treating them as mechanisms, machines, laws of nature, design, chance, eternal creation, and enduring substances—and argues none of them work because rationality itself is fundamentally illogical

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“what he is doing is and I use the word advisedly deconstructing every known theory about the universe you see here are these attempts at rational explanation none of which work that seems to be his point so you might just as well say let's be on our guard against thinking period”

0.75

Nietzsche, Freud, and Marx all share a similar structure: they posit a non-rational substructure (will to power, unconscious id, material conditions) beneath conscious ideological superstructures, making all conscious claims downstream of hidden drives

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“you see I think that would be sort of nichan if you're willing to say that the ideologies are basically expressions of Will To Power emotion in that sense yeah and that perhaps is helpful because it helps you to see that there are similarities between n Freud and Marx um did you get that uh you know this much about nature you you know something about Freud that he talks of the subconscious which um asserts itself in all sorts of ways in our thinking as well as our acting you see um the role of the udus complex in Freud his book Moses and monotheism in which belief in God is the projection of an idus complex you see um that is to say that um the uh the substructure here is the um emotional life to thr um marks yeah they're the uh the substructure is the um material conditions of existence and the alienation that creates”

0.75

Nietzsche's biological vitalism differs fundamentally from Darwinian natural selection because it posits life as a creative force that overcomes its environment rather than merely conforming to it through gradual adaptation

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“his evolutionary theory is not that of darwinian natural selection that is far too gradual a kind of process and it would produce is weak willed conformists adjusting to an environment rather than overcoming it his biology is rather biological vitalism that is to say that life is a creative force that pervades all of organic existence”

0.70

Nietzsche creates a paradox: he claims nothing is true, not even his own assertions, yet demands that philosophers commit to his position; this echoes the ancient liar's paradox where a Cretan saying all Cretans are liars creates a logical contradiction about the truth-value of the statement itself.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker - Philosophy Professor

“if on the other hand you say to Nia well is all this that you're telling us true you see I remember asking that in a graduate school course one time uh to which the professor responded H need you would just have a good belly laugh at that...now you know that um obviously poses the old um liar uh dilemma in from Antiquity when um certain creton says all cretans a liar now if a creton tells you all Catans are liars is he telling the truth if he's telling the truth he's telling falsehood if all Catans are liars then he's a liar but if he's telling you a falsehood then he's not telling you the truth”

0.69

Nietzsche's ethics is emotivist—moral judgments are expressions of emotion and will to power rather than objective truths, making ethics non-cognitive and fundamentally a matter of feeling and assertion rather than knowledge

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“I didn't catch tivism oh the emotivism in his ethic yeah I should have linked that up that last um thing there are no moral facts that is to say there is no truth about right or wrong virtue and vice uh there are no objective moral facts at all that could be known well what then are moral judgments um expressions of emotion of Will To Power or weak wedness the case may be yeah uh what are we doing when we approve of something or disapprove of something you see we're we're asserting emotion about that so you get this emotivist interpretation of ethic”

0.69

Edmund Husserl was primarily concerned with opposing philosophical naturalism (the reduction of knowledge to psychological, historical, sociological, or scientific explanations) because it fails to provide solid foundational premises for logic, mathematics, and science

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“hurl has three primary concerns one is what he takes to be the failure of philosophical naturalism the failure of philosophical naturalism now he's using naturalism in the sense of purely um um scientific explanations of things so that in terms of trying to find the foundations of logic yes on what grounds to the laws of logic rest or the foundation of meth of mathematics which is much the same thing or the foundations of Natural Science you see all of which have presuppositions about human knowledge and Truth uh in trying to provide those uh foundations for math Natural Science logic all the naturalist has done is to say they're all due to non rational processes psychological explanations”

0.69

The falseness of an opinion is not an objection to it if the opinion is life-furthering, life-preserving, and species-promoting; the falsest opinions are indispensable for life, and renouncing false opinions would be a renunciation of life itself

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“the falseness of an opinion is not for us an objection now it's here perhaps that our new language sounds most strangely the question is how far an opinion is life furthering life preserving species Pro preserving perhaps species rearing and were fundamentally inclined to make the falsest opinions to maintain that the falsest opinions are the most indispensable to us that without a recognition of logical fictions without comparison of reality to the purely imagined world without a constant counterfeiting of the world man couldn't live the renunciation of false opinions would be a renunciation of Life a negation of life”

0.69

Husserl's phenomenology must be a science of the creative and constructive activities of the human spirit in organizing experience, acknowledging the Copernican revolution by studying how the transcendental ego constitutes experience through forms and categories

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“what hurl wants is a new foundationalism that acknowledges kernic Revolution it must be a science of the creative constructive activities of the human spirit in organizing experience you see and that is why it has to be a phenomenology of the transcendental ego yes see that ego that transcends all of the particulars of concrete experience that ego which is the incant the the thing that has the forms and the categories all nicely schematized into the transc in a transcendental Unity of a ception”

0.69

The Catholic University of Louvain changed its philosophical identity from Thomistic to phenomenological after 1945-1946 when it received Husserl's archived papers from a priest who had smuggled them across the Belgian border during World War II

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“word got out to um hur's um former students um he was dead uh that the Nazis were going to seize all his writings and Destroy them uh because of his Jewish um background so in the depth of the night a Catholic priest who was one of these students secreted all of the hural papers in the back of his car and raced across the Belgian border to the University of louisan Catholic University University at Lan and secreted hural archives now University of Len had been major Catholic University in Europe very influential back in 1878 um the pope had issued an encyclical uh in the light of all of the religious and social and philosophical developments of the 19th century an encyclical called the 18 tyranny petris of the Eternal Father uh calling for a return to the philosophical and Theological resources of Thomas aquinus this marks the beginning of the neot toist movement uh that has continued into the 20th century University of Lan immediately seized initiative and got on the bandwagon and became the center for neotonus studies in Europe”

0.69

Nietzsche was a thoroughgoing egoist who rejected any renunciation of egoism as an attack on oneself, using this radical egoism as the foundation for his rejection of altruistic ethics and his reconception of morality as an expression of will to power.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Philosophy Professor

“he's not afraid of egoism you see any rejection of egoism would simply be an attack on himself keep that in mind he's a thoroughgoing egoist uh but the first to formulate this there are altogether no moral facts”

0.68

Phenomenological description has philosophical roots in Hegel and operates informally in existential thinkers like Kierkegaard, Jaspers, Marcel, and Buber, but was formulated as a rigorous technical method by Edmund Husserl

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“phenomenological description as I've said goes all the way back to Hegel and informally in people like Jaspers and some of the other existential writers I've mentioned like Mar cell and bber and so on and so forth but the method as such was formulated by herur uh at least a more technical method was formulated by hurl who died in 1938”

0.66

Husserl's phenomenology of the transcendental ego differs from existential phenomenology: Husserl was interested in the transcendental structures of consciousness itself, not in the existential dimensions of human existence

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“a phenomenology that we usually ascribe in its most rigorous form oops to the um German philosopher Edmund huro though uh it also operates um earlier and parallel to her in a whole variety of other philosophers in the European tradition this sort of description of the structures of the inner Consciousness so um that combination then becomes evident in notably Martin heiger... but that's not what hur's phenomenology was developed to do herur was more interested in a phenomenology of the transcendental ego and so his original work is spoken of as transcendental phenomenology to mark it off from existential phenomenology in no sense would you want to talk all huser all an existentialist you flunk if you do that you see yeah U what he's doing is developing a method”

0.65

The quest for truth has purely instrumental value—theories and beliefs are created for our own purposes as expressions of the will to power, not as correspondences to reality

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“the Quest for truth is not an issue that's not the point he has a purely instrumental value to the theories and beliefs we come up with we create them for our own purposes an expression of the will to power”

0.63

Martin Heidegger worked as Husserl's graduate research associate and then departed from Husserl's approach in significant ways, as did other phenomenologically-trained philosophers like Sartre

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“that combination then becomes evident in notably Martin heiger who at one time was The Graduate research associate working with Hur and um then in his thinking parted company with herur in some regards and um by the same token people like s so that sat whom you're reading next week uh represents this uh more um philosophically rigorous phenomenological method in an existentialist”

0.63

Kierkegaard and Nietzsche represent the first phase of existentialism in reaction against the Enlightenment, characterized by descriptive and introspective psychology of self-discovery rather than rigorous philosophical method

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“you have uh kick and good and need nature in the first phase of existentialism in reaction against the enlightenment okay kick aard in nature and you notice that their work is indeed descriptive it's more like an introspective kind of psychology of self-discovery or something of that sort uh than anything else uh there's no rigorous philosophical method involved”

0.63

Hermeneutics (interpretation) applies broadly across disciplines—science, social sciences, history, literature, philosophy—not just in theology, and involves interpreting situations, human actions, and texts

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“the kind of hermeneutic um that talks about subjective grids and influences is intruding in the interpretive process you see to talk about that involves doing a phenomenology of how the subjectivity is at work in the interpretation and it's gader who has done that par Excellence you and uh that subjectivity is given excessive role in deconstructionists like Paul De man but um it's gader who really is the key philosophical figure in the development of that modern hermeneutic incidentally for those of you um oriented to theology let me say the word hermeneutic is used much more broadly than just in terms of theology it means interpretation so it's used in relationship to science in relationship to the social sciences yeah I said interpreting situations interpreting human actions you see it's used in history it's used in literature all the rest of it it's used in terms of reading a philosophical text”

0.63

Maurice Merleau-Ponty and Paul Ricoeur are French philosophers influenced by Husserl's early phenomenology rather than by existentialism

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“there are other European writers who um appear who also I think are more influenced by the earlier Hass and among them I'd list the French philosopher Maurice Mero Ponte i' list the French philosopher Paul rur probably the greatest living French philosopher today”

0.61

Hans-Georg Gadamer is the major figure in developing phenomenological hermeneutics, showing how subjectivity and subjective grids intrude into the interpretive process and must be phenomenologically investigated rather than eliminated

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“Hans George gader uh who is really the the main figure that doesn't look very much like gam does it uh who's um really the um the major figure in the development of what we call phenomenological hermeneutics uh because the kind of hermeneutic um that talks about subjective grids and influences is intruding in the interpretive process you see to talk about that involves doing a phenomenology of how the subjectivity is at work in the interpretation and it's gader who has done that par Excellence”

0.60

Phenomenology is not a theory, system of thought, or philosophical position but rather a method and project for rigorous philosophical investigation

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“phenomenology is not a theory I underscore that again it's not a system of thought it's not a philosophical position it's a method a project”

0.59

Marx claims all moral standards are merely expressions of class conflict, making ethics a downstream effect of material conditions rather than objective principles

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“if you've read read The Communist Manifesto uh you find the assertion that um that all our moral standards are simply uh expressions of the class conflict”

0.55

Biological vitalism as a theory of life has been outdated since the mid-20th century with the development of biochemistry and understanding of DNA, replacing the notion that life is a distinct creative force with the understanding that life is a function of complex biochemical compounds

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“biological vitalism rather now this um biological vitalism is plainly along with the volunteerism going to affect whatever he says about human knowledge human thought epistemology and in order to pick up on that in particular which nowadays I suspect is the most influential part of nature uh because it feeds into postmodernism uh biological vitalism is um or popular through the 19th century until about 1940 19 50 um the um gradual development of biochemistry and the recognition of all the W what is it the Watson cck uh material and so forth about um DNA and such like um that so outdated vitalism you'll see that we no longer viewed life as itself a creative Force distinct from the material elements on which it works but rather life is a function of certain highly complex biochemical compounds”

0.52

The influence producing contemporary relativism is not solely Continental philosophy but also the Anglo-American positivist and pragmatist traditions, which hold that truth is purely instrumental and all values are expressions of emotion

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“my reaction is that that's not the whole story um that at least in the english-speaking world the influences is as much I think from the positivist tradition um with its assertion that um we well the pragmatist tradition that we only have an instrumental view of Truth meaning the positivist tradition that all values are just expressions of emotion you see that whole thing so there's a complex that is produced that in society”

0.52

Logic originated in humans' heads from the illogical through an arbitrary creative force, not from rational foundations; the logical processes in our modern brain correspond to a struggle of illogical and unjust impulses that operate so rapidly we experience only the result

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“where has logic originated in men's heads undoubtedly out of the illogical yeah this creative impulse that's unpredictable irrational so forth the domain of which must originally have been immense and towards the bottom of the page no living being would have been preserved unless the contrary inclination to affirm rather than suspend judgment to mistake rather than wait to Ascent rather than deny decide rather than be in the right unless that had been cultivated with a extraordinary acidity the course of logical thought and reasoning in our modern brain corresponds to a process and struggle of impulses which singly and in themselves are all illogical and unjust we usually experience only the result of the struggle so rapidly and secretly does this primitive mechanism Now operate in us”

0.52

Moral judgments belong to a stage of ignorance where the distinction between real and imaginary are still lacking; they are not to be taken literally but retain semiotic value as symptoms revealing underlying cultural and psychological realities

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“moral judgments like religious ones belong to a stage of ignorance at which the very concept of the real and the distinction between what is real and imaginary are still lacking thus truth at this stage designates all sorts of things which today we call imaginings moral judgments are therefore never to be taken literally they always contain mere absurdity semiotically they remain invaluable uh semiotically that is to say they are a sign of something they reveal at least for those who know the most valuable realities of cultures and inwardness which did not know enough to understand themselves”

0.52

Inverted Platonism would hold that ideology (or theory) is the fundamental reality, driving and determining factual assertions, inverting the Platonic hierarchy where facts determine ideology

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“I suppose that an inverted platonism would be to the effect that theory is down here or better still ideology is down here would that be it and um factual assertions are up here so that in that sense the factual assertions we make are driven by our ideologies okay now you see I think that would be sort of nichan if you're willing to say that the ideologies are basically expressions of Will To Power emotion in that sense”

0.52

Karl Jaspers critiques Nietzsche for overemphasizing inner subjective depth (will to power, creative destruction) while neglecting the integration of empirical existence, conscious rationality, and cultural creativity into a coherent authentic human existence

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“Jaspers was not satisfied with what nii was doing it seemed to him that um that people like kick good and nature put too much of a gap between human subjectivity that is to say this these depth dimensions of the inner life of which nature speaks uh K good um far too much of a gap between those inner dimensions and what he calls the empirical existence which we have as beings in this world”

0.52

The world's general character is chaos, not by absence of necessity but in the absence of order, structure, form, or beauty—meaning there are no laws of nature, only necessities; no one commands, obeys, or transgresses; and there is no design, chance, or enduring substance.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Philosophy Professor

“the general character of the world on the other hand is to all eternity chaos not by the absence of necessity but in the sense of the absence of order structure form Beauty wisdom and then on 324 about halfway through that first paragraph let's be on our guard against saying there are laws of nature there are only Necessities there's no one who commands obeys transgresses”

0.51

Radical postmodernism of the current day has been most significantly influenced by Nietzsche, having shifted from modest epistemicism that still made truth claims to abandoning truth-talk entirely in favor of power politics and the politicization of knowledge

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“no such thing as Truth uh no objective moral qualities no basis in reality for moral knowledge no basis for any kind of knowledge now you see why I write on the board nature parenthesis uh and postmodernism because I suspect that in the radical postmodernism of our day um it's nii who's the most single influential force that is to say the postmodernism that has turned be from uh more modest epistemes still want to make truth claims but more modestly so um the radical postmodernism of today has turned from that from talking about truth altogether to essentially power politics you see and the politicization of the University which you read about in the press these days is simply in the Nan Willer power of certain interest groups”

0.50

Behind all logic stand physiological demands and value judgments for preserving a certain kind of life; all arguments ultimately prove only something about why the speaker finds it necessary to argue at all

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“behind logic stand value judgments or to speak more plainly physiological demands for preserving a certain kind of life you see all your arguments prove is something about why you find it necessary to do that at all”

0.47

Jaspers' authentic human existence emerges through transcendence of purely inauthentic empirical existence, rational consciousness, and cultural particularism via an act of faith toward some all-encompassing transcendent ground of being that can only be articulated through symbols and ciphers, never conceptualized

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“what Jaspers um talks about then is transcending a purely um uh impersonal inauthentic empirical kind of existence uh transcending simply that Enlightenment um notion of being a conscious rational being um transcending even the life of the culture do you get the kicker Guardian note in this stages On Life's way you see transcending all of that in an act of uh faith that begins to sound almost as if it's religious um and the um the identity the nature of that Transcendent being the all encompassing being is something we only speak of in symbols and ciphers uh we can't conceptualize it”

0.45

Contemporary university students have lost all sense of personal identity, lack any world view on which to ground truth or value judgments, and speak as if there is no such thing as truth and falsity

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“Bloom um begins that book with the complaint that the Contemporary University student talks as if there is no such thing as truth and falsity right and wrong have you heard that before GL you've heard it today um has lost any uh sense of personal identity and has no world view on which to ground any of those things you see”

0.45

Alan Bloom traces contemporary student relativism and loss of truth-sense to Continental thinkers, particularly Nietzsche, as the source of the problem

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“what he does is to trace this situation to these Continental thinkers whom he takes to be the um source of the problem”

0.42

Positivism represents a democratic self-glorification of the free intellect because anybody can allegedly gain empirical data; skepticism is physiological weakness and nervous sickness that lacks decisiveness and the will to truth

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“he speaks of positivism with its objective empirical data as a democratic self-glorification of the free intellect Democratic because anybody can gain empirical data you think and skepticism as a vague physiological quality which in common language is called nervous weakness a sickness that lacks decisiveness lacks the will the truth you see if you don't have the will to power to assert something is true um you're weak will nervous weakness that's sick”

0.39

Dallas Willard, a Husserl specialist, argues that phenomenological method can oppose postmodernism and anti-realism by opening up sufficient understanding of consciousness structures to avoid skepticism and relativism

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“last year we had Dallas Willard from um you University of Southern California speaking did any of you hear him he gave a series of lectures against postmodernism against the anti-realism of the day now Willard is um a hural specialist and uh his argument was drawing on phenomenological method in order to oppose the postmodernism and anti-realism of the day in other words trying to say that phenomenological description can open up a sufficient understanding of certain structures of the cont ious as to avoid the skepticism the relativism that is involved in that anti-realistic view”

0.34

Carl Jaspers and his wife avoided deportation to an extermination camp only because they were in a city liberated by the Allies during the German invasion, having been listed for deportation the following week.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker - Philosophy Professor

“Carl Jaspers uh interesting person he his wife was a Jews and um when I forget which city it was was um liberated by the Allies in the invasion of Germany it was discovered that um Jaspers and his wife were listed to be deported to the extermination camp the following week so he just escaped in that way”

0.29

Cardinal Mercier, a French cardinal at the University of Louvain, advocated vigorously for Thomism as the Christian philosophy for his era, following the papal 1878 encyclical calling for a return to Thomistic resources

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“University of Lan immediately seized initiative and got on the bandwagon and became the center for neotonus studies in Europe Cardinal Mercier French cardal located there um wrote um vigorously um along those lines um maintaining that tomis was the Christian Philosophy for the day”

0.27

The present Pope (as of the lecture) was educated at Louvain and has published phenomenological studies, representing the influence of the phenomenological tradition within Catholic theology

factualnovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“45 I guess it was uh Lan woke up to find it had the hural archives changed its philosophical identity and it became the center for phenomenological studies and Catholics still going there became phenomenologically oriented among them incidentally was the present Pope who um going back to Poland uh has actually published phenomenological studies of his own”

0.25

Paul Ricoeur is a French Protestant in the French Reform tradition, representing a theological as well as philosophical tradition

factualnovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“Paul recur now um another name uh influenced by the early hural very much is um uh Hans George gader uh who is really the the main figure that doesn't look very much like gam does it uh who's um really the um the major figure in the development of what we call phenomenological hermeneutics uh because the kind of hermeneutic um that talks about subjective grids and influences is intruding in the interpretive process you see to talk about that involves doing a phenomenology of how the subjectivity is at work in the interpretation and it's gader who has done that par Excellence you and uh that subjectivity is given excessive role in deconstructionists like Paul De man but um it's gader who really is the key philosophical figure in the development of that modern hermeneutic incidentally for those of you um oriented to theology let me say the word hermeneutic is used much more broadly than just in terms of theology it means interpretation so it's used in relationship to science in relationship to the social sciences yeah I said interpreting situations interpreting human actions you see it's used in history it's used in literature all the rest of it it's used in terms of reading a philosophical text so um that now what um what we want to do first of all is to get clear on the phenomenological method we'll start on that today want to get clear on that want to say something about um what haer does with it then more extensively of course sat because you're reading sat as the sample of this phenomenological method and then I want to say something about the hermeneutical tradition um and particularly GMA okay so that's our agenda through to the end of next week now um what is phenomenology um which um as a philosophical method dominates European philosophy um in this country it is dominant in Roman Catholic philosophy due I might say to almost a clo and Dagger story the story being this that um um in the uh early days of World War II or was it just before um word got out to um hur's um former students um he was dead uh that the Nazis were going to seize all his writings and Destroy them uh because of his Jewish um background so in the depth of the night a Catholic priest who was one of these students secreted all of the hural papers in the back of his car and raced across the Belgian border to the University of louisan Catholic University University at Lan and secreted hural archives now University of Len had been major Catholic University in Europe very influential back in 1878 um the pope had issued an encyclical uh in the light of all of the religious and social and philosophical developments of the 19th century an encyclical called the 18 tyranny petris of the Eternal Father uh calling for a return to the philosophical and Theological resources of Thomas aquinus this marks the beginning of the neot toist movement uh that has continued into the 20th century University of Lan immediately seized initiative and got on the bandwagon and became the center for neotonus studies in Europe Cardinal Mercier French cardal located there um wrote um vigorously um along those lines um maintaining that tomis was the Christian Philosophy for the day this day incidentally some Catholic philosophers uh if you use the phrase Christian philosophy with them they'll be thinking of Thomas aquinus I remember when the Society of Christian philosophers was organized some 10 or 12 years ago we were discussing uh what the society should be called um the initial proposal was that we called it the Society of Christian philosophy then it became apparent that our Catholic friends in the group thought of Christian philosophy as um tomis and I'd been accustomed to using the term Christian Philosophy for a pluralistic tradition of doing philosophy in a Christian perspective and the ambiguity became evident so we called it the Society of Christian philosophers and uh that eliminated the ambiguity um but in any case um the fact that in 1945 46 45 I guess it was uh Lan woke up to find it had the hural archives changed its philosophical identity and it became the center for phenomenological studies and Catholics still going there became phenomenologically oriented among them incidentally was the present Pope who um going back to Poland uh has actually published phenomenological studies of his own so um Cloak and Dagger story well not quite cloak yeah yeah cloak but not quite dagger okay on that story um so the influence there um phenomenolog phenomenology is not a theory I underscore that again it's not a system of thought it's not a philosophical position it's a method a project and um phenomenological description as I've said goes all the way back to Hegel and informally in people like Jaspers and some of the other existential writers I've mentioned like Mar cell and bber and so on and so forth but the method as such was formulated by herur uh at least a more technical method was formulated by hurl who died in 1938 now hurl has three primary concerns one is what he takes to be the failure of philosophical naturalism the failure of philosophical naturalism now he's using naturalism in the sense of purely um um scientific explanations of things so that in terms of trying to find the foundations of logic yes on what grounds to the laws of logic rest or the foundation of meth of mathematics which is much the same thing or the foundations of Natural Science you see all of which have presuppositions about human knowledge and Truth uh in trying to provide those uh foundations for math Natural Science logic all the naturalist has done is to say they're all due to non rational processes psychological explanations in terms of certain psychological processes which give rise to identifying this that and the other if you like n is giving a psychological explanation isn't he Freud is or historical explanations this is the way it happened historically or sociological explanations cultural influences so herur is cred is criticizing psychologism historicism soci olism scientism now get the isms there the claim that everything can be explained through those scientific methods including the foundations of logic mathematics science all human learning now um that's what herur was opposed to he wants more solid foundations so that uh so that logic mathematics philosophy can really be founded on unquestionable premises in other words he wants a new foundationalism he wants a new foundationalism M and his idea is that the phenomenological method can get us back to those foundations in the very structure of human nature the structure of Consciousness uh incidentally um last year we had Dallas Willard from um you University of Southern California speaking did any of you hear him he gave a series of lectures against postmodernism against the anti-realism of the day now Willard is um a hural specialist and uh his argument was drawing on phenomenological method in order to oppose the postmodernism and anti-realism of the day in other words trying to say that phenomenological description can open up a sufficient understanding of certain structures of the cont ious as to avoid the skepticism the relativism that is involved in that anti-realistic view I'll come back to that in a little while uh the second concern which uh he has about naturalism is um that it perpetuates the subject object dichotomy perpetuates the subject object dichotomy because it wants to talk simply about object objective matters historical causes objectifying psychological processes sociological processes it's only interested in objectivist explanations that exclude the role of human subject there is therefore a loss of the creativity of the constructive contribution of the human spirit that is to say the naturalist has bypassed the Canan cernic Revolution so what hurl wants is a new foundationalism that acknowledges kernic Revolution it must be a science of the creative constructive activities of the human spirit in organizing experience you see and that is why it has to be a phenomenology of the transcendental ego yes see that ego that transcends all of the particulars of concrete experience that ego which is the incant the the thing that has the forms and the categories all nicely schematized into the transc in a transcendental Unity of a ception okay now he wants to take a much closer look at that sort of thing well next time we'll um try and say how he does it”

0.20

Paul Ricoeur is probably the greatest living French philosopher (at the time of lecture) and has been retired from university teaching for half a year but still teaches occasionally at the University of Montreal and the Sorbonne

factualnovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Lecturer)

“i' list the French philosopher Paul rur probably the greatest living French philosopher today um he's still alive uh retired um at University of Chicago for half a year for the last several years um teaching occasionally at the University of Montreal but still teaching um half a year at the suran now I think he's retired”

0.17

Some Catholic philosophers identify Christian philosophy specifically with Thomism, as evidenced by ambiguity that arose when the Society of Christian Philosophers was being named, leading to the adoption of 'Society of Christian Philosophers' instead of 'Christian Philosophy' to clarify that the field is pluralistic rather than exclusively Thomistic.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker - Philosophy Professor

“some Catholic philosophers uh if you use the phrase Christian philosophy with them they'll be thinking of Thomas aquinus I remember when the Society of Christian philosophers was organized some 10 or 12 years ago we were discussing uh what the society should be called um the initial proposal was that we called it the Society of Christian philosophy then it became apparent that our Catholic friends in the group thought of Christian philosophy as um tomis and I'd been accustomed to using the term Christian Philosophy for a pluralistic tradition of doing philosophy in a Christian perspective and the ambiguity became evident so we called it the Society of Christian philosophers”