Invisible Hand
Adam Smith's metaphor, used only twice in his works, that has come to mean a self-working market process producing good outcomes—a meaning Roberts argues departs from Smith's original usage.
As defined in Don Boudreaux, Michael Munger, and Russ Roberts on Emergent Order
Other definitions
Adam Smith's metaphor for how individuals pursuing their own self-interest in markets unintentionally promote the wider benefit of society.
John Papola on the Keynes Hayek Rap Videos 05/02/2011Smith's principle that individuals pursuing self-interest in profit-maximization inadvertently produce socially beneficial outcomes through the market mechanism, as if guided by an invisible hand directing them to provide goods society wants and needs.
HISTORY OF IDEAS - Capitalism
Where it comes up · 27
- Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 5--A Discussion of Parts III (cont.), IV, and V11 claims
- James Otteson on Adam Smith 06/27/20114 claims
- Mike Munger on the Nature of the Firm 01/14/20083 claims
- George Friedman on How Geopolitics Drives Trump's Tariffs3 claims
- Russ Roberts on the Price of Everything 08/25/20082 claims
- Peter Boettke on Living Economics2 claims
- Don Boudreaux, Michael Munger, and Russ Roberts on Emergent Order2 claims
- The 10 Core Myths Still Taught in Business Schools | Frankly 992 claims
and 19 more
Most important claims · 10 of 53Search all claims for “Invisible Hand” →
- People would voluntarily yield a scarce good like a carpenter to a neighbor whose house was destroyed, but the knowledge needed to identify who needs what and to arrange such kindness is not available, so prices do this work instead.Russ Roberts on the Price of Everything 08/25/2008
- Many self-organizing systems produce bad outcomes (pollution, traffic) where individuals acting in self-interest via the invisible hand reach outcomes everyone agrees would be better if different; humans naturally want to fix these but, lacking intuition about self-organizing behavior, often impose solutions with unintended consequences—e.g. widening a highway only to find it just as crowded a year or two later.Deborah Gordon on Ants, Humans, the Division of Labor and Emergent Order 8/20/2007
- Adam Smith used the phrase 'invisible hand' only once in the Wealth of Nations and once in The Theory of Moral Sentiments, and in neither case did it mean what we use it to mean today (a self-working process with a good outcome); the modern usage has become a straw man for critics who claim economists think it solves everything, when in fact it does not solve many things like pollution.Don Boudreaux, Michael Munger, and Russ Roberts on Emergent Order
- Smith presents the deception that wealth will make us happy as beneficial because, even though the ambitious poor man's son ends up no happier, that very deception is what first prompted humanity to cultivate the ground, build cities, and invent the sciences and arts that changed the face of the globe and supported a greater multitude—paralleling the Talmudic teaching that the evil inclination toward acquisition is what builds civilization.Daniel Klein on Honest Income
- Classical Darwinian evolutionary theory and classical liberal economic theory come from the same intellectual moment and influenced one another: Darwin had in mind an invisible-hand-like struggle and competition when developing natural selection, while the authors of classical economic theory, including Smith, took late-17th and early-18th-century natural science as the model for how social explanation should work.Jessica Riskin on Life, Machinery, and the Restless Clock
- The invisible hand and the concept of natural equilibrium are very important to Smith, though the particular famous formulation appears quite late in the book and is not actually a central focus; the key idea is that free, rationally self-interested people will maximize productivity and output.Smith's Wealth of Nations
- The invisible-hand result is that people make choices in disparate circumstances without ex ante expectation of coordination, yet well-functioning markets make their individual choices add up to what they intended, which is the beautiful property that a central planner cannot reproduce.Mike Munger on the Nature of the Firm 01/14/2008
- The invisible hand is what most people remember about Smith, yet it is caricatured as 'greed is good'. Although the phrase appears once in WN, the idea that people create macro order from micro intentions pervades the whole book and is its central scientific insight. That pervasiveness is why WN is justly regarded as a great work of the West.James Otteson on Adam Smith 06/27/2011
- The same profit motive and invisible hand that lure producers to introduce quality improvements and cost-saving innovations also all but guarantee that if there is any way to cheat someone out of money, someone will be willing and eager to do it.Robert Frank on Dinner Table Economics
- Adam Smith's concept of the invisible hand—that individuals pursuing their own interests create collective benefit—applies to geopolitics at the nation-state level: when nations pursue their interests, they force other nations to understand each other's incentives and adjust accordingly, creating a stable equilibrium.George Friedman on How Geopolitics Drives Trump's Tariffs