Daniel Klein on Honest Income
What this covers
Daniel Klein and Russ Roberts conduct a wide-ranging conversation about the ethics of income and work, anchored in Adam Smith's moral philosophy. The discussion moves between economic theory, personal virtue, and concrete examples—from basketball salaries to disaster-zone price spikes to Se7en and Sabrina—to explore whether pursuing money can be morally good and under what conditions. Klein argues that honest income, money earned within bounds of fair dealing, carries a presumption of moral worth because it typically serves the good of the whole. But he insists this presumption is not automatic: intention matters deeply to virtue, and we face knowledge problems so severe that we cannot reliably judge whether someone's income-seeking choices actually advance collective welfare.
The conversation splits into two main currents. One traces the philosophical ground: the difference between commutative justice (precise rules against harm or theft) and distributive justice (the loose, aesthetic question of becoming use of one's own), and why Adam Smith's presumption of liberty in policy mattered to human flourishing. The other current worries the edges—where income signals virtue badly because of scarcity rents or compensating differentials, where knowledge problems extend even to oneself, where high prices signal urgency but can masquerade as gouging, and where the invisible hand's logic invites abuse. Throughout, Klein and Roberts resist easy equations between wages and worth, between profit and goodness, while defending the intuition that earning honestly usually does some good—a position easier to live by than to prove.
Klein argues that, following Adam Smith, the pursuit of honest income carries a presumption of being morally just because it serves the good of the whole, but that whether any particular case is truly 'becoming' is governed by deep knowledge problems and intention, so income should never be treated as a direct virtue-meter.
- Smith's two moral authorizations are the presumptive justice of honest income and the presumption of liberty in policy
- Distributive justice ('the becoming use of one's own') is aesthetic, loose, and indeterminate, unlike precise commutative justice
- Knowledge problems make it nearly impossible to second-guess whether someone's income-pursuing choices advance the good of the whole
Markets coordinate behavior and incentivize productive help through prices and wages that reflect supply, demand, and scarcity rather than moral merit.
- When prices rise in the aftermath of a natural disaster, this has the great virtue of signaling that supplies and labor are needed, encouraging those who already have a generator to step aside and compensating people enough to drive hours and risk their lives to bring help—so high prices are a powerful coordination signal in a world of imperfect information, not merely gouging.
“prices rise to the aftermath of that has this great virtue of signaling to people that they're needed. It encourages other people to step aside who might already have a generator not to buy one at the store.”
- A high-paying job such as chief economist at a car company often pays well precisely to compensate a person for giving up the relatively pleasant academic life, so the high pay reflects a compensating differential rather than any special virtue of the work.
“One of the reason that it paid really well was to get you to give up the relatively pleasant life of being an academic, you had to compensate a person to take that job.”
- A great basketball player's high wage reflects not only the value or demand for the talent but also its scarcity, and there is probably nothing meritorious in the scarcity component, which troubles the attempt to read wages as a signal of virtue or contribution.
“Do I really want to use the scarcity of talent, which is part of the wage--not just the value or demand for the talent--it's also the scarcity of it. Is there really anything meritorious there? Probably not.”
Knowledge problems about ourselves and others, plus incentives to care less about strangers, mean simple self-abnegation and distant benevolence are ineffective and counterproductive.
- Beyond knowing more about people near us, we care more about them, so there is also a skin-in-the-game or incentives problem: people spend money less carefully on strangers than on friends or themselves, which compounds the difficulty of effective distant benevolence.
“it's not just that there's a knowledge problem. There's a skin-in-the game, an incentives problem that--I probably don't spend my money so carefully on strangers as I spend it on my friends, as I spend it on myself.”
- The knowledge problem applies to oneself: you don't know enough about your own potential or the future to have a fixed plan or goal, and some of the things you might become don't yet exist, so a rigid plan can be counterproductive.
“'Probably not a good idea to have a plan, and a goal, because you don't know enough to have a goal.'”
- If you gave away almost all your money on the grounds that others need it more, you likely could not work as hard or be as productive, so total self-abnegation makes you a different kind of slave; indulgences may be necessary to sustain productivity rather than mere excuses.
“I'd also argue that if all you do is serve others, you're a different kind of slave... If you gave all, almost all your money away on the grounds that there are people who need it more than you do, could you work as hard as you do? Could you be as productive?”
- Because we cannot even figure out how to spend money effectively to improve schools in our own country, presuming we could improve schools in Africa is unfounded, and the real danger is that such intervention would actually hurt the intended beneficiaries.
“'We can't even figure out how to spend money to have better schools here in the United States. Why would I presume that I could help them? In fact, I'd hurt them.' That's the worst. That's the real problem.”
Commercial work serves genuine moral purposes by helping others, though most people fail to recognize the real good their ordinary labor accomplishes for their communities.
- Most people rarely think about the genuine good their commercial work accomplishes for others—like a real estate agent helping people obtain not just a house but a home through a frightening process—and remembering this is important to understanding what commercial life is really about.
“how often do you think about the pleasure you bring to people getting them into a house, which is scary, and hard, and frightening... She said, 'You know, I never thought about it.'”
- In the Henry Hikes to Fitchburg story, Henry's friend who works to earn train fare is portrayed as the fool for missing nature's beauty, but he should be credited with serving the people in his community whose floors he cleaned or basements he refinished—the spirit of helping others is its own kind of flower-smelling.
“I taught my children that Henry's friend didn't just forego the beauties of nature. He also helped serve the people in his community who needed their floor cleaned, or their basement refinished”
The economist's justification that policies are acceptable because winners could compensate losers is fundamentally immoral despite making aggregate pie bigger being often right.
- The economist's standard of justifying a policy because it makes the pie bigger so that winners could compensate losers is a utilitarian rule that is fundamentally immoral and should often be rejected, even though making the pie bigger is frequently the right thing to do.
“justifying on the basis that winners could compensate losers strikes me as--I guess fundamentally immoral, actually.”
- The most profound takeaway is the trivial-but-hard-to-remember insight that the morality of making money is complicated—not shameful in itself, not automatically virtuous—even though people crave a simple yes-or-no answer.
“the thing I probably take away from this conversation that I found most profound is this idea that--it's so trivial Dan actually, this insight, and then yet it's so hard to remember--which is that: It's complicated.”
Beneficial deception that wealth brings happiness has historically driven human civilization's greatest achievements in cultivation, building, and invention.
- Smith presents the deception that wealth will make us happy as beneficial because, even though the ambitious poor man's son ends up no happier, that very deception is what first prompted humanity to cultivate the ground, build cities, and invent the sciences and arts that changed the face of the globe and supported a greater multitude—paralleling the Talmudic teaching that the evil inclination toward acquisition is what builds civilization.
“this deception of that money will make us happy. This deception, which, first prompted them to cultivate the ground, to build houses, to found cities and commonwealths, and to invent and improve all the sciences and arts”
Listeners should complete the EconTalk survey before its February 2nd deadline.
- Listeners should go to EconTalk.org to fill out the survey about their favorite episodes before it closes on February 2nd.
“go to EconTalk.org... where you'll find a link to the survey where you can tell me your favorite episodes of last year. The survey closes on February 2nd”