honest income
Income earned through private enterprise within the bounds of commutative justice—without violating others' person, property, or promises, and without misleading or jerking people around—excluding income derived from government.
As defined in Daniel Klein on Honest Income
Where it comes up · 1
- Daniel Klein on Honest Income8 claims
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “honest income” →
- Honest income is money made within the bounds of commutative justice—not messing with other people's person, property, and promises—extended to also exclude misleading people or jerking them around, and Klein further sets aside income derived from government.Daniel Klein on Honest Income
- Even a person who helps many barefooted children wear shoes can make a vice of acquisitiveness, letting it become cupidity that is too single-minded or narrow in his private life, so pursuing the maximum honest income is not automatically the best way to be virtuous.Daniel Klein on Honest Income
- Adam Smith's two major moral authorizations—that the pursuit of honest income is presumptively just in a broad sense, and that there is a presumption of liberty in policy and politics—came forward more completely after the Wealth of Nations, and these produced the Great Enrichment.Daniel Klein on Honest Income
- Honest income should carry not merely a presumption of innocence but a presumption of praiseworthiness; it is wrong-headed to presume wrongdoing or evil in someone being wealthier, and until shown otherwise one ought to assume their wealth reflects some good they have done.Daniel Klein on Honest Income
- While giving honest income to charity can be becoming, investing it at a high return such as 15% in plastics can be at least as beneficial and perhaps more beneficial than charitable giving, because the productive enterprise yields broad gains—though Klein makes no categorical claim.Daniel Klein on Honest Income
- The justness of honest income is not that wages or income reflect virtue or are adjusted to an ideal pattern of contributions; rather, justness lies in a person deciding justly his own action—choosing course A over course B given his own options—so income is not a virtue-meter and earning less is no failing.Daniel Klein on Honest Income
- Earning more honest income—bringing home more bacon—is itself a distributive choice, and Smith makes the case that doing so is presumptively distributively just and a becoming use of one's own.Daniel Klein on Honest Income
- The most profound takeaway is the trivial-but-hard-to-remember insight that the morality of making money is complicated—not shameful in itself, not automatically virtuous—even though people crave a simple yes-or-no answer.Daniel Klein on Honest Income