knowledge problem
The difficulty, emphasized by Hayek, that relevant information about value and effective action is dispersed, local, and often inarticulable, making it hard to second-guess others' choices or help distant strangers effectively.
As defined in Daniel Klein on Honest Income
Where it comes up · 11
- Daniel Klein on Honest Income6 claims
- Russ Roberts on the Price of Everything 08/25/20083 claims
- Don Boudreaux on Coase2 claims
- James Otteson on the End of Socialism2 claims
- The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)2 claims
- Conversations with Tyler - Luis Garicano1 claim
- Tyler Cowen on Inequality, the Future, and Average is Over1 claim
- Joshua Greene on Moral Tribes, Moral Dilemmas, and Utilitarianism1 claim
and 3 more
Most important claims · 10 of 21Search all claims for “knowledge problem” →
- When activity is brought inside a firm rather than coordinated through markets, the firm gives up the price system's ability to aggregate dispersed, tacit knowledge (Hayek's knowledge problem), and must instead solve the problem of preserving and accessing knowledge embedded in employees who are scattered and who leave.Don Boudreaux on Coase
- Beyond knowing more about people near us, we care more about them, so there is also a skin-in-the-game or incentives problem: people spend money less carefully on strangers than on friends or themselves, which compounds the difficulty of effective distant benevolence.Daniel Klein on Honest Income
- Hayek argued that when a town or nation tries to allocate scarce goods fairly by central decision, it tends toward tyranny, because decision makers beyond a neighborhood lack the information needed to make the allocation.Russ Roberts on the Price of Everything 08/25/2008
- The most important missing piece is Hayek's knowledge problem: we don't know in advance which technology is best (iPod, VHS). Amazon lost money year after year, and its investors bore that risk voluntarily; it is now profitable. Failed rival e-retailers' investors simply lost their money and need no compensation.Mike Munger on Private and Public Rent-Seeking (and Chilean Buses) 08/23/2010
- Parents allocate scarce goods to children using love and information about each child's situation, which is a natural and egalitarian process; scaling this ethos to a nation fails because larger groups lack the information.Russ Roberts on the Price of Everything 08/25/2008
- Smith taught that when we get much beyond the local our knowledge declines so much that our benevolence is not as effective, so it is ineffective to try to help people you don't know anything about; yet befriending distant people to gain relational knowledge paradoxically returns you to helping your local community.Daniel Klein on Honest Income
- Quoting Freedom and the Law, Leoni argued that no legislator could establish the rules governing everyone's actual behavior without continuous collaboration from all concerned—no polls or referenda suffice—just as planners cannot discover total supply and demand; therefore a legislation-centered legal system resembles a centralized economy run by a handful of directors with fatally limited knowledge, making it arbitrary and possibly a road to tyranny.The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)
- Hayek's knowledge problem and Manzi's causal density mean that simple metrics like a lawyer's grades or a hospital's success rate are not very helpful for judging quality, because difficult cases distort raw success rates; Cowen counters that grades adjusted per case, supplemented by personal recommendations, need only be better than knowing nothing, like credit scores or Yelp reviews.Tyler Cowen on Inequality, the Future, and Average is Over
- Whether a person is making a becoming use of his own is a delicate question because we don't even know what 'his own' is—his capabilities, interests, potentialities—nor what his alternative (Option B) was, and he himself may not be able to articulate it, creating serious knowledge problems in second-guessing people's ethical choices.Daniel Klein on Honest Income
- Coase's recurring theme, akin to Hayek's, is that even the most elegant 'blackboard' model imposed on reality will always be too simple; if bottom-up forces are allowed to operate they devise more nuanced solutions that outperform engineering models, so a Pigovian tax that looks good on paper will not work as well as emergent methods of dealing with externalities.Don Boudreaux on Coase