social welfare function
A mathematical construct that purports to rank different social states by aggregating the well-being of all individuals, used in welfare economics to compare policy outcomes.
As defined in Who Won the Socialist Calculation Debate (with Peter Boettke)
Where it comes up · 8
- Arnold Kling on Morality, Culture, and Tribalism3 claims
- Martha Nussbaum on Creating Capabilities and GDP2 claims
- Daniel Klein on Honest Income2 claims
- Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/20081 claim
- Daron Acemoglu on Inequality, Institutions, and Piketty1 claim
- Kimberly Clausing on Open and the Progressive Case for Free Trade1 claim
- Tyler Cowen on the Risks and Impact of Artificial Intelligence1 claim
- Who Won the Socialist Calculation Debate (with Peter Boettke)1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “social welfare function” →
- The belief that a benevolent dictator could maximize a social welfare function for 'the economy as a whole' is intellectually bankrupt and dangerous, because it ignores that people have different goals, that trade-offs persist, and that interpersonal comparisons of well-being cannot validly be made—yet this seductive welfare-economics framework gives economists pretensions of being engineers who can make society as a whole better off.Who Won the Socialist Calculation Debate (with Peter Boettke)
- The good of the whole, like a good movie, cannot be reduced to a well-specified algorithm or social welfare function; we evaluate it the way we evaluate movies—without being able to articulate the underlying weighted index—and that lack of rigor must be accepted rather than disguised.Daniel Klein on Honest Income
- Gary Becker's work on social interactions and the family was clever and won him the Nobel Prize and was powerful in his own hands, but it had little or no impact on how economists generally think about economic wellbeing; the dominant modern perspective instead became the social welfare function, which Roberts considers a ghastly concept because it purports to aggregate utility across individuals and trade off one person's wellbeing against another's via policy.Arnold Kling on Morality, Culture, and Tribalism
- Coordination differs fundamentally from efficiency/optimality/social-welfare-function economics because coordination requires no well-defined maximum and makes no pretense of one, whereas the modern paradigm presumes a well-defined maxim—a presumption driven by the urge toward scientific status and positivism.Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/2008
- The economist's standard of justifying a policy because it makes the pie bigger so that winners could compensate losers is a utilitarian rule that is fundamentally immoral and should often be rejected, even though making the pie bigger is frequently the right thing to do.Daniel Klein on Honest Income
- Economists' habit of judging policy by whether it makes the total economic pie bigger—and assuming gains could in principle compensate losers even though compensation rarely happens—is a misleading and amoral way to think about public policy, because adding up winners' and losers' wellbeing the way one might claim a vacation is good because happy Johnnie outweighs depressed Susie is nonsense; real distributional choices must be confronted rather than summed away.Arnold Kling on Morality, Culture, and Tribalism
- Repeatedly teaching and absorbing the Max-U model—treating human beings as calculating machines that convert purchased inputs into happiness outputs—leads economists to ignore non-material goods and to imagine they have the insight, via a social welfare function, to manipulate the levers and dials of policy to determine who should gain and lose and engineer human wellbeing, which Roberts considers grotesquely wrong-headed.Arnold Kling on Morality, Culture, and Tribalism
- The dominant word 'alignment' embeds a social-welfare-function assumption—a single Benthamite/Arrovian notion of the good that machines should be aligned with—whereas the right framework is Hayekian and Polanyian: decentralization, checks and balances, and changing the incentives of decentralized agents, not controlling everything via one notion of good.Tyler Cowen on the Risks and Impact of Artificial Intelligence
- One should distinguish three separable judgments about inequality: first, the static welfare judgment about whether a more unequal allocation is bad holding all else equal (most people are somewhat against it, though increasing inequality also changes incentives); second and more important, equality of opportunity—whether being born into a rich family guarantees the top position regardless of talent or effort, which greater inequality can worsen via credit-market constraints that block the poor from schooling; and third, political inequality—whether a handful of people dominate political voice while the rest are 'like sheep.'Daron Acemoglu on Inequality, Institutions, and Piketty
- Most of the mathematics in economics is a barrier to understanding, particularly in welfare economics where simply being able to write down a social welfare function is mistaken for science.Martha Nussbaum on Creating Capabilities and GDP