winner's curse
The tendency for the winner of an auction or bidding contest to overpay, because winning means having bid more than everyone else valued the asset.
As defined in Ben Thompson
Other definitions
In competitive bidding, the tendency for the winning bidder to have overestimated value or underestimated cost, thereby winning the bid but losing money on it.
Bent Flyvbjerg on MegaprojectsIn competitive auctions, the winner tends to overpay relative to the true value because they bid the highest among multiple bidders.
Why Venture is Hard
Where it comes up · 14
- Esoteric Assets3 claims
- Hal Varian2 claims
- Phil Rosenzweig on Leadership, Decisions, and Behavioral Economics2 claims
- 19 | Tyler Cowen on Maximizing Growth and Thinking for the Future2 claims
- Investing Pre Company1 claim
- Ben Thompson1 claim
- Conversations with Tyler 2024 Retrospective1 claim
- Matt Levine1 claim
and 6 more
Most important claims · 10 of 19Search all claims for “winner's curse” →
- The first person to publish a discovery often suffers a 'winner's curse': because of the data mining that preceded publication, the reported effect is likely overstated or nonexistent, so replications typically find a much smaller or absent effect.Campbell Harvey on Randomness, Skill, and Investment Strategies
- The winner's curse lesson applies to common value auctions (where the item is worth the same to all), but in private value auctions—like an oil tract whose value depends on your future extraction capabilities over a 10-20 year life—you may rationally pay more, and in competition you must bid somewhat beyond your present capabilities (trusting your historic rate of improvement) or you will never win.Phil Rosenzweig on Leadership, Decisions, and Behavioral Economics
- Capital cycles overbuild because the society keeps pushing until it overdoes it, since lead times and the winner's curse mean the last person to stop investing will regret it, and the rapid technological dynamism makes this harder than past infrastructure buildouts.Cliff Sosin - Owning the Complements to Intelligence - [Invest Like the Best, EP.497]
- The winner's curse is not a cognitive bias or individual estimation error but an outcome of a bidding process: in a distribution of bids, even if everyone bids conservatively on average, the highest bidder—who is wildest on the high side—wins the auction and therefore probably overpaid (and conversely, the lowest contractor bid wins but probably won't make money).Phil Rosenzweig on Leadership, Decisions, and Behavioral Economics
- If there are even two bidders in a market, they squeeze out all the alpha that exists, because alpha is the gap between price and fair value and competition closes that gap.Esoteric Assets
- Investment managers who are paid two and 20 generally bid between $1.02 and $1.12 for assets, so on a risk-adjusted basis the asset management industry loses money even when headline returns of around 20 percent look good.Esoteric Assets
- The winner's curse is most relevant under asymmetry of information, and while naive players do exhibit it, the experimental literature shows they learn over time to shade their bids for a better outcome, indicating learning behavior rather than a permanent irrationality.Hal Varian
- The rate of return on private investment, including small businesses, is highly skewed: only a few percent of people doing it make anything at all, with a bifurcated distribution between foolish optimists who should just take stable jobs and a smaller group who are genuinely innovating with very high social returns.Tyler Cowen — Hayek, Keynes, & Smith on AI, animal spirits, anarchy, & growth
- When megaprojects overrun, the cost typically falls on taxpayers for public projects and on shareholders for private projects; contracts rarely transfer enough risk to contractors because regulations and political decisions change unpredictably over the 5-15 year construction period and cannot all be written into a contract.Bent Flyvbjerg on Megaprojects
- Auction houses like Sotheby's likely earn higher revenue from the ascending/descending-bid auction than from the theoretically equivalent Vickrey auction because excitement, irrationality, and madness of crowds cause bidders to get caught up in the bidding, departing from theoretical equivalence.Hal Varian