What this covers
Patrick interviews Jerry Neumann, a venture investor, about why venture capital is hard. Jerry starts from the Risk Versus Uncertainty Distinction: venture money goes into things nobody has done, so there is no history to count. He then turns on gut investing. Intuition needs stable signals and many repeated experiences, which venture lacks. He cites a dissertation on 89 investments in which gut-picked founders did worst and founders with prior success in the same job did best, and contrasts venture with the Naturalistic Decision Making research on fire chiefs.
The middle of the conversation is a framework for where lasting profit comes from. Companies earn excess profit either by being cheaper or by being better, and Jerry argues that Efficiency Versus Value Innovation is the key divide, since efficiency has a ceiling and new value does not. Uber is his example of a market that grew by an order of magnitude. Google beating Yahoo and Simple taking on retail banks illustrate the Value Chain: an entrant wins by doing things the incumbent cannot easily change. He then surveys Barriers to Entry, saying software patents, scale and expertise are weak, while pharma's R&D costs keep rivals out. The Trade Desk story shows software's Capital Efficiency.
The last stretch is about market structure. Auctions for term sheets reward investors who cannot value companies, small funds are pushed toward short-term traction, and the model only works for outcomes of $100 million or more. Jerry also takes a contested detour into college pricing and studies suggesting elite schools add little.
Neumann argues venture returns rest on uncertainty that cannot be priced or counted, so gut-driven decisions, pattern matching, and easy-to-copy edges fail, while durable advantage comes from value innovation, hard-to-replicate expertise, and capital-efficient business models.
- Venture uncertainty is unquantifiable because the investments are for things that have never been done, so probability-based risk pricing does not apply
- Gut investing fails because venture lacks the repeated, stable signals needed for valid pattern matching, and founder judgment is better made from track record than instinct
- Efficiency gains are capped while value creation is uncapped, and most barriers to entry in software and networks are eroding
Current venture gains are efficiency improvements on existing systems, not creation of big new value.
- Some prominent venture capitalists argue that big new value has not been created in a long time and that current gains are mostly efficiency improvements on existing systems.
“which you hear a lot of really smart VCs would say we haven't done big things in a long time”
- Smil's history of energy shows efficiency gains in turbines capturing much more of the same fuel, rather than new fuel sources, illustrating the difference between efficiency innovation and value innovation.
“now we're getting 98% of the energy out of the turbine, we used to get 20 or something like that”
Opacity and gut-driven decisions increase perceived value of businesses and investment approaches.
- People value businesses and investment approaches more when they cannot fully understand how they work or how hard they would be to replicate, so opacity and mystique, as embodied by gut decisions, increase perceived value.
“everyone does love black boxes”