utilitarianism
An ethical theory holding that the right action is the one that maximizes overall well-being, happiness, or good, counting everyone's interests impartially.
As defined in Peter Singer
Where it comes up · 46
- Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion15 claims
- Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals: Bibliotheca Webinar6 claims
- 305 - Moral Knowledge5 claims
- 176 | Joshua Greene on Morality, Psychology, and Trolley Problems4 claims
- Paul Bloom on Cruelty3 claims
- 443 - What Is Christian Nationalism3 claims
- 50 | Patricia Churchland on Conscience, Morality, and the Brain3 claims
- Brave New World: Bibliotheca Webinar3 claims
and 38 more
Most important claims · 10 of 94Search all claims for “utilitarianism” →
- The economic efficiency standard—maximizing net benefits (benefits minus costs)—descends from Vilfredo Pareto's idea that if a policy's monetary gains exceed losses, a surplus exists that could be redistributed so everyone is at least as well off; but because that compensation rarely actually takes place, every such policy has real winners and losers, making a sole focus on efficiency a narrow utilitarian argument that ignores both that losers are harmed and that winners often care about losers.Will Davies on the Economics, Economists, and the Limits of Neoliberalism
- We should take the same attitude toward moral theories as Popper does toward scientific theories: regard all theories claiming to give morality a foundation—Kant's categorical imperative, utilitarianism, Rawlsian fairness, the will of God, human flourishing—as mistaken qua foundations, but all of them have value when regarded instead as critiques; utilitarianism as a fundamental theory is rubbish but as a critique of other theories it is very powerful.52 - Finding Our Way In The Cosmos
- The trolley problem can be complexified into the case of a surgeon who murders an innocent person to harvest organs and save five dying patients; the math is identical (one life for five), yet most people find it deeply repugnant, which shows the problem is not one of complexity but of the trolley problem's excessive simplicity.Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion
- If you hold that any human life has positive value, utilitarianism quickly implies the morally right thing is simply to increase the number of people regardless of anything else—Derek Parfit's 'repugnant conclusion'—showing that maximizing an aggregate utility number conflicts with our moral intuitions.53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality
- Harris argues that when Wilson's theology is drilled down, what he ultimately cares about—the difference between eternal agony and eternal union with God—is experiential, so Wilson is effectively a consequentialist whose utilitarian-style concerns about suffering and glory are framed by Christianity and his expectations about the afterlife.443 - What Is Christian Nationalism
- Utilitarianism (maximize aggregate utility) and deontology/Kantianism (follow hard-and-fast rules regardless of consequences) both claim to possess a formula that makes moral intuition unnecessary, yet each refutes the other only by appealing to moral intuition—the utilitarian invokes our gut sense that betraying Anne Frank is wrong, and the deontologist invokes our gut sense that harvesting one healthy visitor's organs to save five patients is wrong—proving moral intuition is inescapable.Moshe Koppel on Norms, Tradition, and Resilient Societies
- There is a big moral difference between what you do and what you allow to happen, and we have special obligations to the near and dear; even where you ought to rescue a drowning child and it would be indecent not to, you may not owe them compensation as a paid lifeguard would, because need does not automatically create an entitlement to your aid.Daniel Haybron on Happiness
- Parfit's repugnant conclusion follows from utilitarianism: since more lives saved is always better and more people is better, the optimal world is one with a huge number of people all living barely above subsistence—like the slums of Bangladesh universalized—because the summed wellbeing of many barely-tolerable lives exceeds that of fewer flourishing ones.Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion
- The limits of utilitarian reasoning are fairly tight around marginal changes and small events; large total comparisons—like whether humans should never have settled the New World, leaving more intelligent mammals alive—are intractable and cannot be resolved by summing values.Peter Singer
- At the theoretical philosophical level Singer maintains that retributive and other moral intuitions are all explicable in terms of utility, even though he admits to having non-utilitarian intuitions—declining Cowen's invitation to become a 'two-thirds utilitarian' who lets in an independent, non-reducible reason of justice.Peter Singer