causal

Organ-Harvesting Surgeon Refutes Pure Utilitarianism

The trolley problem can be complexified into the case of a surgeon who murders an innocent person to harvest organs and save five dying patients; the math is identical (one life for five), yet most people find it deeply repugnant, which shows the problem is not one of complexity but of the trolley problem's excessive simplicity.

causalpending

Speaker

Erik Hoel

Evidence Quote

“most people would find that deeply repugnant... But the math is the same. It's one person for five. So, why shouldn't you do it?”

Source

Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:17:40 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...