substitution effect
The way technology substitutes for and replaces human labor in performing tasks.
As defined in 97 | John Danaher on Our Coming Automated Utopia
Other definitions
The shift toward cheaper or more attractive alternatives when a good's relative cost changes, here used for reading choices
Tyler Cowen on Your Inner Economist 9/10/2007When a shortage or price rise in one input causes users to switch to alternatives, which then reduces demand for the original input.
An Uncertain Crisis
Where it comes up · 6
- 97 | John Danaher on Our Coming Automated Utopia3 claims
- Conversations with Tyler - Luis Garicano2 claims
- An Uncertain Crisis1 claim
- Erik Hurst on Work, Play, and the Dynamics of U.S. Labor Markets1 claim
- Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee1 claim
- Ed Leamer on Manufacturing, Effort, and Inequality1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “substitution effect” →
- Before 1985 leisure time rose together for both higher- and lower-educated men and women, but after 1985 the trends diverged sharply, coinciding with the rising skill premium (faster wage growth for the more educated), suggesting that a substitution effect became important: as leisure became expensive for high-skilled workers they took less of it while low-skilled workers took more.Erik Hurst on Work, Play, and the Dynamics of U.S. Labor Markets
- Work is not any particular activity but a condition under which humans perform tasks in return for economic reward, and a job is a socially or economically defined role made up of a bundle of tasks; this distinction matters because technology automates tasks rather than whole jobs.97 | John Danaher on Our Coming Automated Utopia
- Jevons effects operate in work decisions, as productivity gains make people work more, and Garicano's own sleep tracking suggests he works more after gaining productivity, with his WHOOP-measured physical age rising from 53 to 57 in six months.Conversations with Tyler - Luis Garicano
- Historically automation has disrupted jobs without causing structural mass unemployment because, alongside the substitution effect where machines replace human labor, a complementarity effect opens up new tasks in which humans have a comparative advantage, allowing workers to redefine their roles around different tasks.97 | John Danaher on Our Coming Automated Utopia
- Empirical work by Acemoglu and Restrepo on US labor markets from 1990-2007 found that each additional robot displaced between three and six workers with no offsetting net gains across other industries, a similar effect was found in French firms, and this occurred during a period of relatively low robot uptake, suggesting larger losses as robotization increases.97 | John Danaher on Our Coming Automated Utopia
- Munger is less concerned about the income effect of BIG (people working less because they have money) than about the substitution effect of the current system, which encourages the very poor to substitute toward leisure because of cliff effects and benefit cutoffs; he believes most poor people want to work and the main barrier is the disincentive structure, not laziness.Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee
- When a scarce metal runs short its price can triple or quadruple, prompting redesign, substitution, and new mines, after which prices fall but spike in other metals, so commodities will move in up-and-down patterns rather than the old downtrend.An Uncertain Crisis
- In the short run, substitution effects of tax changes usually overwhelm income effects, so AI productivity gains that raise the return to work may likewise push people to work more rather than deliver a leisure dividend.Conversations with Tyler - Luis Garicano
- For high-tech intellectual workers, the long hours enabled by the computer and internet are a source of pleasure and a sense of impact rather than hard labor, fundamentally unlike tedious, wearing manufacturing work that exhausted workers by age 55; this enjoyment, more than income or substitution effects, explains why high-skill workers choose long hours.Ed Leamer on Manufacturing, Effort, and Inequality