What this covers

Patrick interviews Jeremy Grantham of GMO in June 2020. The pandemic is the starting point, but the conversation ranges much wider. Grantham sets the virus against its backdrop: the end of a ten-year upswing with record corporate and sovereign debt. He calls it a shock that hits supply and demand at once and falls hardest on the poorest quarter of workers. He then goes back through bubble history to ask what has and hasn't changed. The cases are Japan in 1989, the S&P 500 at 21 times earnings in January 1998 before it climbed to 35, and REITs rising about 30 percent while the index fell about 50 percent after the 2000 peak.

The contentious middle concerns why old rules stopped working. Grantham says cheap-stock signals worked as a contrarian indicator for about 80 years, then faded around 2000 as quant machines and academic papers spread them. He ties this to a structural shift in American capitalism: rising monopoly power, weaker antitrust, fewer young firms, and CEO pay moving from about 40 times worker pay to about 300. He also weighs the Fed's roughly $2.5 trillion of money creation, which he calls inflationary when output falls while paper is thrown at the system.

The last stretch is about the physical world. It covers technology versus depletion in mining, with copper ore grades at about a tenth of 1900 levels and energy and metals at an 80 percent discount to the S&P 500. It then turns to flooding and drought, CO2 rising from 280 to 410 ppm, Midwestern soil carbon falling from about 6 percent to 1.5, and falling sperm counts.

Sharpest takeaway

Grantham argues this crisis is uniquely uncertain: markets sit in the top decile of P/E ratios on Fed-supplied liquidity while the economy is weak, so value and resource assets, sustainable farming, and venture capital offer better opportunities than the old 'don't fight the Fed' playbook.

  • Market valuations are near record highs while earnings and the economy face a large downturn, held up by Fed liquidity ('paper')
  • Structural changes since about 2000 (weaker competition, buybacks, corporate conservatism) mean 'this time is different' in some ways
  • Commodity metals and sustainable agriculture are undervalued relative to the S&P 500, while venture capital drives real innovation

The argument · threads4 threads · 73 claims
0.85

Valuations and asset returns mean-revert, so value discipline beats chasing dominant trends.

6 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Grantham does not accept a 'don't fight FAANG' rule; GMO has always played value first and bets against the market's dominant trends when valuations are extreme.

    “don't fight the Fed has had a pretty good record and has not applied to my life or GMO, we have always played value first.”

  • FAANG stocks are expensive but not as overpriced as Cisco was in 2000, since they are growing fast and are not trading at about 65 times earnings.

    “But, they are not Cisco of 2000. They're not 65 times earnings. They're growing fast”

  • The easy pickings from simple value factors are gone, leaving labor-intensive and risk-intensive stock-by-stock analysis, because the investor must bet both that fundamentals will change and that the market is wrong.

    “leaving, as I said, old fashioned, labor-intensive stock by stock analysis, not only labor-intensive, but risk-intensive”

  • In March 2000 the S&P 500 yielded about 1.6%, its lowest in history, and the argument that its faster dividend growth justified the gap did not hold up against GMO's data.

    “the S&P had the lowest yield in its history ever, in the March of 2000. It yielded, I think, 1.6.”

  • GMO's asset allocation and seven-year forecasts rest on the observation that asset classes mean revert toward historical levels, because abnormally high returns attract competition that drives them back toward norms.

    “Basic mean reversion is the bedrock idea. So we studied the rate at which asset classes tended to mean revert”

  • The cheapest price-to-book assets are those the market thinks are least useful dollar for dollar, and the lowest P/E stocks are those whose earnings the market least believes will be sustainable, so cheap metrics are expressions of market skepticism rather than free money.

    “the cheapest price-to-book are really the assets which dollar for dollar the market thinks are the least useful”

0.66

Central bank easing misread the housing bubble and inflates prices without creating jobs.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Greenspan and Bernanke were wrong to dismiss the housing bubble as a reflection of a strong economy, since a simultaneous bubble across diversified US regions was a rare event that their statistics should have flagged.

    “it took them to miss the point of Bernanke saying that the US real estate market merely reflected the strong US economy.”

  • GMO predicted that the housing market's decline, with a slight overshoot below trend, would wipe out about $10 trillion of homeowner wealth, and that this would create a severe economic problem given subprime deficiencies.

    “the housing market coming back down, we calculated with a little bit of overrun below trend, would remove $10 trillion worth of perceived wealth”

  • The Fed is flooding the system with money that does not create jobs, which can push stock prices up in the short term, while the market has returned to its June 2019 level even though the economy is worse.

    “You have today a market that is at the same price it was last June when everything looked great, and everything is not great now”

  • Pumping money into an economy whose output of goods and services has fallen is intrinsically inflationary, and a thought experiment of unemployment with $25 trillion of paper equal to 100 percent of GDP would leave people with lots of money and nothing to buy.

    “So of course, it intrinsically inflationary process. We are cranking out paper as the output of goods and services drops way down.”

  • After the market hit its low, the rally occurred while expectations about the economy worsened, so Grantham became more pessimistic about earnings and employment than on the day the market bottomed.

    “So we're more pessimistic than we were at the very day the market hit it's low.”

0.43

Scarcity and supply responses make commodity prices cycle up and down rather than trend.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Fracking may explain about half of the US economic outperformance versus Europe over the last 10 years, concentrated in Texas, North Dakota, Pennsylvania, and New Mexico.

    “You can back out fracking and say might have been at least half of the difference between us and Europe.”

  • When a scarce metal runs short its price can triple or quadruple, prompting redesign, substitution, and new mines, after which prices fall but spike in other metals, so commodities will move in up-and-down patterns rather than the old downtrend.

    “What's going to happen as you get into a shortage, the price will triple, it will quadruple of say cobalt, people will redesign everything and substitute it”

  • Grantham's most favored investment is specialty metals such as cobalt and nickel, since their prices spike in shortages before substitution, redesign, and new supply bring prices back down, and the cycle moves between metals rather than producing a clean trend.

    “the price will triple, it will quadruple of say cobalt, people will redesign everything and substitute it and open new plants”

0.34

Short-term thinking distorts corporate culture, climate response, and crisis-era investment choices.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Corporate culture has become more conservative, with returns prioritized over growth and being first to new products, though some firms still pursue that aggressively.

    “Conservatism and high return is put ahead now of growth and being the first and the biggest at something new.”

  • The Grantham Foundation has about 60% of its portfolio in venture capital with a 70% target, reflecting a view that venture opportunities, including greentech, are exciting and that crisis-era valuations may create cheaper entry points.

    “the Grantham Foundation has 60% in venture capital if you can believe that. Our target is 70.”

  • The kindest thing Grantham recalls is Alan Abelson's Barron's comment that in a world of mountebanks and scoundrels, Jeremy is the model of virtue.

    “In the world of mountebanks and scoundrels, Jeremy is the model of virtue.”

  • Humanity is responding to climate change far too weakly because species tends to favor short-term gains over inconvenient long-term risks, with a few governments acting while others dismiss it as a hoax.

    “We're simply under responding as a global species big time.”