
Tyler Cowen on Your Inner Economist 9/10/2007
What this covers
This EconTalk conversation has Russ Roberts questioning Tyler Cowen about his book on applying incentives to everyday life. The territory is deliberately domestic: parenting, reading, dentists, art museums, universities. Cowen says writing the book pushed him back toward subjectivism, an old starting point running from Adam Smith and Carl Menger, in which incentives matter only through what people believe is true.
The dentist is the central case. Patients give up control once they are in the chair, third-party payment leads providers to assume no one minds the cost, and both sides fool themselves about risk. Cowen extends this to medical quality, which he treats as a public good that society resists creating. Museums and universities get a similar analysis: both are shaped by donors rather than consumers, so museums are hard on ordinary visitors. His workaround is to ask which painting in a room you would steal. On paying for performance, he supports paying students in the worst inner-city schools but opposes it in comfortable suburbs. He also argues that paying people to read risks a "me factor" that turns readers into mercenaries.
The conversation also wanders into more contested or idiosyncratic positions. Cowen calls brainstorming mostly useless, yet credits small, competitive groups such as Picasso and Braque with extreme results. He describes expressive voting as correct but not predictive. He recommends Alexander Kotov's chess method of annotating a game yourself before checking the expert's, and he suggests blogs as a way to learn the artful side of economics. The publisher's notes add his favorite art museum and the difficulties of touring Morocco.
Cowen argues that economics is the logic of matching means to ends, and that people improve their choices by understanding subjective beliefs, autonomy, affiliation, and the non-monetary motives that money-based incentives often crowd out.
- Money incentives often backfire because people resent feeling controlled and need to feel autonomous
- Motivation runs through affiliation and identity, which standard economics underweights
- Incentives only work through people's subjective beliefs, so the economist must study perception
- Institutions such as museums, universities, and medical care are shaped by who pays rather than who consumes
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The biggest challenge for universities is the certification role of education, since students attend for many purposes beyond intellectual exploration, so a university pursuing education for its own sake might not attract many students.
“I think the certification role of education is the is the biggest challenge that we have students are here for such a wide variety of purposes”
Theories of expressive voting are fundamentally correct but lack enough substance to be predictive; they explain why people vote but not who abstains, and voting is best thought of as like writing a letter to the newspaper.
“they predict that people vote which is really not the most interesting... they don't predict who doesn't vote I tend to think of voting is like writing a letter to the newspaper”
Consumers know remarkably little about the dental and health care they buy, and information about medical quality is a public good that society resists creating, because people are uncomfortable letting others take chances on stochastic medical outcomes and prefer the illusion that everyone is being taken care of.
“we're quite unwilling to let people behave on stochastic medical information and take real chances and generate more information that's a public good”
Brainstorming is mostly a waste of time in typical workplaces, but small groups that talk regularly and have a competitive spirit do great things at the extremes of a power-law distribution, as with Picasso and Braque, the physicists who built the atomic bomb, and the classical political economists and Austrian school.
“I think it's a power-law distribution there's a lot of evidence most of all in the arts but also in science that small groups that talk to each other regularly and have a competitive spirit they can do great things”
Third-party payment makes the problem worse because the dentist or doctor presumes the patient is not paying and will accept any procedure, which Cowen says is not his own reaction since he worries about unintended side effects, wasteful spending, and the value of his time.
“the role third party payment it's a huge factor as well the dentist presumes or the doctor presumes when you're not paying that of course you'll have it”
Alexander Kotov's chess method of writing one's own annotations to a game before checking them against the expert's, rather than playing through the moves, is the most effective way to learn; Cowen says it is how he learned to play chess well, though it is unbearably challenging.
“keep each future move a secret and write out your own annotations to the game”
Writing the book moved Cowen back toward Austrian subjectivism: incentives only matter through people's subjective perceptions, so the key question becomes what people believe is the case, which is an old starting point going back to Smith and Menger that economists neglected.
“the key question is no longer what's the incentive that is a key question but to understand the incentive you have to ask what do people believe is the case”
Economics is best understood as the science of the logic of choice: matching means to ends, thinking about how incentives operate, and understanding what costs really mean, so it is about getting the most out of life rather than only financial matters.
“economics I view is the science of the logic of choice matching means two ends making better decisions”
Using money as an incentive often backfires when applied too brutally or too frequently, because people feel controlled, resent it, and rebel against the incentive scheme altogether.
“if you use it too brutally or too frequently people start to feel controlled and they resent feeling controlled and they rebel against your incentive scheme altogether”
Affiliation, the desire to belong to and be part of something meaningful, is a central human motivation that economics underweights; it explains why people donate to causes and contribute to open-source software and Wikipedia without monetary return.
“a central motivation of human beings it's not in economics nearly enough it's this idea of affiliation”
Patients often say no to their dentist but then cancel the appointment rather than argue on the spot, and the same holds for doctors; the psychological loss of control is compounded by third-party payment, which leads providers to assume patients will not object to costs.
“people even when they want to say no to their dentist they're much more likely to say yes and then cancel the appointment than to argue on the spot”
Universities that depend on donors are over-specialized in networking, producing an image, and selling status and affiliation, rather than pursuing a dynamic educational vision, because donors give for a warm glow rather than educational results.
“universities of that kind their over specialized in networking and producing an image and selling status and affiliation”
Paying students to do well in school is a good idea in very bad inner-city schools, where there is literally no downside because conditions cannot get worse and intrinsic motivation is often absent, but it is a bad idea in upper middle-class suburban schools where it would displace intrinsic motivation.
“for very bad schools it's a good idea there's literally no downside things are so bad they can't get worse”
Marketing understands identity and affiliation, and economics should treat marketing as an under-explored frontier: making sense of marketing's insights would enrich the economic model of human behavior, even though much marketing is crude and painful to read.
“I think of marketing which I understand it's an art not a science a lot of it's very crude... it's the great under explored frontier in economics”
The single most underrated problem with using money as an incentive is that people have a deep need to feel autonomous and in charge, and their own priorities can clash with the priorities set by the payer.
“the single most underrated problem with using money is simply that we all have this need to feel we're autonomous we're in charge it's our project we're setting priorities and often those two things can clash”
Following Robin Hanson's logic, one should ask in which direction a bias is likely to lie; Cowen's advice to walk out of books and movies may produce unintended side effects, but his coded story of needing to see things through is most valuable in relationships, family, and parenting, where commitment is essential to integrity and virtue.
“to take a clue from Robin Hanson we need to ask in which direction is the bias likely to lie”
No one fully understands why live teaching works better than a DVD of the best lecturers; the market has rejected replacing teachers with recordings, and live education is largely social theater with immersion and wrestling with ideas that a lecture alone does not provide.
“the market test has voted against this pretty decisively but exactly why it wouldn't work I don't think we understand that”
Reading four or five blogs regularly may be as good a way to learn the artful part of economics as listening to lectures or reading formal narrative books, because hearing people discuss and analyze stories, especially people who respond to each other, mirrors the dinner-table discourse that teaches well.
“reading a blog handful of blogs four or five it's probably as good a way to learn economics as sitting and listening to a lecture”
The dentist problem is a major failure of markets: a dentist has more information about your teeth and is motivated by money, yet patients accept recommended procedures without argument because they have ceded control while in the chair.
“your dentist has more information than you do about your teeth... the dentist is motivated by money”
Both patients and dentists are subject to self-serving delusion about risk: patients want to assume a problem is unlikely to avoid pain and expense, while dentists have an incentive to believe the risk is high, so neither side reasons about actual odds over time.
“of course my natural delusion is to assume that the odds of this happening are much smaller of course the dentist is also diluted”
Museums are funded mostly by private donors and a small share of admissions (about 10 to 15 percent of budget in the United States), so museums are geared to donors who want high-status, serious, overwhelming displays, making them hostile environments for ordinary visitors unless visitors adapt.
“the admission charge is for museums would maybe be ten to fifteen percent of budget if that most of what the museum gets it gets from private donors”
Asking yourself which picture in a museum room you would steal, or which is your favorite or least favorite, turns a serious viewing into a low-status game that makes art digestible; Cowen says this approach worked with his children aged seven to fourteen, who looked at paintings closely when competing for the best one.
“in this room what picture would I steal or what's my favorite picture or what's my least favorite and make it into a kind of a load deliberately low status game”
Paying people to read risks interfering with the framing of reading by making it about the reader's own payment rather than the book's content, which Cowen calls the 'me factor,' and this is why he thinks paying for reading generally does not work.
“making the reading about you know the reader than me what I call the me factor in the book and that's why I think it generally doesn't work”
Replacing an intrinsic desire with a money-based reason can be harmful because people form a few major inspirational stories about themselves that are hard to swap out; paying someone to read risks turning them into a mercenary reader rather than a lover of reading, since payment rarely continues and reading remains valuable.
“we can only have a few major stories and we need to have the right ones because if you're stuck with the wrong story you can't just sub in the right story”
Requiring students to defend a proposition in an oral exam, pushing them until they cannot defend it, produced learning within about two minutes, but was extremely unpopular with students because it is painful to admit ignorance.
“most of them learned it within the first two minutes it didn't take an hour of pushing”
Using money within families is unhealthy for two reasons: it symbolically places a transaction on a relationship that should rest on loyalty and obligation, and it creates a slippery slope where payment for chores leads children to ask to be paid for grades, dating choices, and majors.
“let's say you try to pay your daughter to do the dishes she then thinks well will they pay me to get good grades to date the right boy to choose the right major”
Books come to life for readers when they connect to some private concern, such as a person they know, a role model, a parent, or a religion, and the book must be framed in the right way; even young people can love demanding books when they are framed to matter to them.
“the way most people start loving books is they see that the book somehow matters to them it matters to some very private concern”
There is a tension between flitting out of books and movies and the valuable irrational desire to see things through to the end; Cowen's personal code is to finish books he starts, which meant he chose books carefully but sometimes skipped worthy ones, and he has walked out of very few movies.
“there's something important about the quote irrational desire to see things through to the end”
Open-ended problem sets that students avoid by glancing at answers and feeling reassured when the answer is given in class teach little; far more learning happens when students struggle first-person with the questions and argue them with classmates.
“they glanced over the question they take a quick stab at it and then they're comforted by the fact that they've heard the answer in class”
Finishing every book one starts has value as a form of perseverance and integrity, but it carries the cost of wasting time, so the question is which bias is more likely to be harmful; Cowen's own moral code to finish books may be a bias that a more critical approach should correct.
“it's an interesting trade-off there between gumption and perseverance versus wasting your time”
As societies become wealthier, the economic problem shifts from meeting basic needs like food, shelter, and schooling to marginal areas of life such as happiness, well-being, and virtue, which become increasingly important for people.
“the wealthier society becomes the more likely it's the case that economics is about some unorthodox area because food is what really matters when you're poor”
American culture has a harmful expectation that nothing should hurt, so people shy away from the discomfort needed for hard study and work; forcing methods of study that embrace difficulty pay off in the long run, such as doing well on comprehensive exams rather than flunking out of a PhD program.
“there's something in American culture today that is in some regards harmful it's this feeling that nothing is supposed to hurt”
Hiring a guide in a Moroccan medina like Marrakech is a no-win incentive problem: guides who appear free still take tourists to shops that pay commissions, shopkeepers outbid any payment, and leaving a guide leaves you lost, so the incentive problem often cannot be solved.
“any guide you hire will take you where the guide wants to go which is two shops where the guide will get Commission's”
Students spend much of their university time and energy on cultural, social, and entertainment pursuits rather than education, and universities avoid criticizing curriculum through a least-common-denominator approach, so administrators speak in ways that offend no parent, and the prevailing incentive punished Larry Summers for saying something unpopular.
“when that's the prevailing incentive larry summers said something it was unpopular and paid a severe price”
For Cowen the most interesting parts of economics are an art rather than a science, centered on mixing incentives and knowing when markets apply and when they struggle, so he does not teach undergraduates first-order conditions and considers the art very hard to teach.
“for me not for everybody but for me the most interesting parts of economics are an art not a science”
Some incentive problems cannot be solved, such as asymmetric incentives in urban car-watching or touting guides, and knowing which incentive problems are unsolvable is a big part of economics, as opposed to the usual can-do focus.
“some incentive problems just don't get solved I think is the lesson and just knowing which those are I think is a big part of economics”
A simple rule for moviegoers is to walk out when in doubt, because a movie usually does not get better and staying wastes time; asking at the start whether one is willing to walk out, and following through, saves time and lets one take more chances on movies.
“when in doubt walk out the movie usually does not get better”
Cowen is not much worried about reading in general, since much computer use involves reading, but he worries about long-form novels and serious fiction and poetry, which are ebbing as formative influences, with teenagers increasingly shaped by nonfiction.
“I really do see interest in fiction serious fiction is ebbing away and I don't know how to reverse that trend”
Blogging is an important form of economic education, and it persists at George Mason's economics department because its members are generalists with something to say who find it easier to dialogue with other bloggers and colleagues.
“I think it will last here as long as our department is anything like the way it is now because we're mostly people who have something to say we're less specialized”
Economists should break down the old distinction between economics and psychology; disciplines such as sociology, social psychology, and experimental economics are essentially doing the same thing and should not be separate fields of inquiry.
“more radically we need to break down the old distinction between economics and psychology”
The dinner table, a small group in dialogue, is an underappreciated educational device compared with the lecture hall, because a learner absorbs ideas more effectively when a small set of people is discussed repeatedly, as when Cowen blogs about Robin Hanson, Brian Caplan, and others.
“I think the dinner table which is what this is emulating is a underappreciated educational device”
Monetary incentives work well for 'nerdy' personality types who are often less socially aware; paying them to do a task creates a win-win with no resentment or loss of control, so the key is to analyze the social context of the payer and recipient and ask what the control issues are.
“you can figure out cases where monetary incentives will work well a lot of what I would call nerdy personality types”
Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments is largely an exploration of non-monetary motives, examining what we care about beyond money and which images stir sympathy, including proximity and similarity as drivers of whether we act to help someone.
“Theory of Moral Sentiments is to a large extent a an exploration of the non monetary side of our lives”
Blogging is hard, and most academics cannot blog well because the entry barrier is high; Cowen finds it easier because his research is generalist and he reads widely, and his experience with guest bloggers has been mixed.
“I think that entry barrier will keep out most academics in my opinion it's really hard to blog”
Hard-to-find odds information on tooth complications such as a tooth growing down into a fang reflects a fear factor: people do not want to know medical information even when it exists, and hospital death-rate comparisons across doctors are highly imperfect and unpopular.
“it's interesting that it's hard to find reliable information on the odds of a Fang whereas other things we have lots of information”
Most academics cannot blog well and never will, because blogging requires generalist breadth and reading widely, which creates an entry barrier that keeps most academics out, though it should not be required of them.
“I think that entry barrier will keep out most academics in my opinion it's really hard to blog”
Zoos are funded more by admissions and so guide visitors along explicit paths, while museums rarely provide such routes, which is why visitors get lost and wander aimlessly in museums but rarely at zoos.
“zoos are funded much more by admissions charges and zoos tend to be pretty easy so often you go to the zoo and they give you a path”
Museum quality depends heavily on curatorial understanding of how to hang a room; the Museum of Modern Art in New York hangs rooms well, the Menil Collection in Houston is well hung, but the National Gallery in Washington ruins half its rooms by placing clashing aesthetics together, and the older Cowen gets the more this matters.
“half of their rooms are in some sense ruined because they put clashing colors next to each other”
Society prefers the illusion that everyone is being taken care of, and this comforting mindset makes it hard to accept the statistical information that would let people judge doctors and procedures, a mindset Cowen thinks society should move away from.
“we feel the need to recreate this illusion you're being taken care of everyone's being taken care of”
Students often look over complex ideas and conclude they understand them, rather than immersing themselves; the remedy is to sit down with a clock and write out answers, but most people lack the discipline to do so.
“the tendency to look over something and say oh yeah I got the idea of that rather than really immerse themselves in it”
Cowen's children read because the parents read and modeled reading, and the family deliberately limited PowerPoint, video, and computer games in early childhood; he regards this as a good parenting strategy.
“I suspect my kids read because I read my wife and I read and we've read to our kids we've modeled that behavior”
Long fiction is hard to sample because the package is too large, so people cannot dart in and out, which makes it a social event like joining a club; the fiction decline is therefore not primarily caused by Harry Potter-style popularity.
“the package is too large it's hard to sample it's hard to dart in and out”
Harvard economics and the Kennedy School are the most willing among top schools to tolerate different ideas and generalist thinking, which explains why Harvard and George Mason are the two main blogging centers, while MIT and Stanford are less generalist.
“Harvard economics and the Kennedy School has been the most interesting for a while now and the most willing to have different ideas”
People in general do many things to feel in control and avoid things that make them feel out of control, and this desire for control is a theme that runs through the book.
“I think we do lots of things to feel in control and we avoid things that that make us feel like we're not in control”
Everyone already makes economic decisions every day by weighing benefits against costs and matching means to ends, and becoming more self-reflective and self-critical lets one's 'inner economist' produce better results.
“all of us are already making economic decisions every day we're weighing benefit in cost we're trying to match means to ends”
Visual media is replacing books because it is shorter and cheaper, and movies are dying as viewers find two-hour films too long at home, so people switch to YouTube and TV shows since a two-hour movie on a small screen must be very good to hold attention.
“I think movies are dying two hours for so many people it's too long”
The book is about discovering one's inner psychologist as well as one's inner economist, placing it at the interface between economics and psychology.
“a lot of the book is about discovering not just your inner economist but your inner psychologist”
Paying for a task can be a fine decision for some professions, such as a proofreader who does not care about books, but it should not be generalized into a story about how to get people to love reading.
“for some professions let's say you're a proofreader and that's all you do and you don't care about books”
A tongue-in-cheek test for reading is to ask whether the book is the very best possible book one could be reading right now; many readers took the joke seriously, and one even set down a book after deciding they had not read Pride and Prejudice.
“when you're reading a book ask yourself is this the very best possible book in the world I could be reading right now”
Cowen has read most Western classics two to five or six times, rereading Shakespeare, the Bible, and Plato at least five times, and he treats rereading as both pleasurable and educational, in contrast to Harry Potter which many people reread.
“so like Shakespeare or the Bible or Plato I'll read you know a minimum of 5 times”
Alfred Marshall's teaching, as an apocryphal story tells it, is an example of a lecture-hall format misapplied: when Pigou was the only student, Marshall still read his lecture for the whole semester instead of having an intimate conversation.
“supposedly the GU comes in the first days he only students he sits down Marshall comes in starts reading from his lecture”
Cowen hopes that people who are freed from finishing a hard book like Kierkegaard's Fear and Trembling will pick it up voluntarily, so that those who will love it do so and those who would not like it are not forced through it.
“a lot of people out there will say hey I don't have to finish Kierkegaard so now I'm free to pick it up”