puerperal fever
A deadly post-childbirth infection (childbed fever) that killed up to 20% or more of women in maternity wards before doctors understood that handwashing prevented it
As defined in Russ Roberts on the Information Revolution, Politics, Yeats, and Yelling
Where it comes up · 4
- 312 | Thomas Levenson on the Mutual History of Humans and Germs4 claims
- Dan Klein on Truth, Bias, and Disagreement 03/16/20092 claims
- Russ Roberts on the Information Revolution, Politics, Yeats, and Yelling1 claim
- Megan McArdle on the Oedipus Trap1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “puerperal fever” →
- Major scientific paradigm shifts often occur not because the old guard changes its mind but because they die out, allowing a new generation to adopt the better view—illustrated by Semmelweis, whose correct handwashing theory of puerperal fever was dismissed by older doctors (who blamed vapors and closed windows) and only accepted after time and a new generation, costing thousands of women's lives.Dan Klein on Truth, Bias, and Disagreement 03/16/2009
- Puerperal (childbed) fever was sparse when childbirth was a local affair handled by midwives, but as European cities grew and male doctors took over childbirth in hospitals where many women gave birth together, lying-in hospitals created perfect conditions for pathogens to move from patient to patient, producing epidemic puerperal fever.312 | Thomas Levenson on the Mutual History of Humans and Germs
- In 1795, decades before the conventional 1840s story, a local Aberdeen doctor purely empirically tracked sequences of puerperal fever infection, concluded that he and the midwives were carrying the disease from patient to patient, and explicitly published that they were the cause—but the work was ignored, he was driven out of town, and the idea was lost.312 | Thomas Levenson on the Mutual History of Humans and Germs
- Ignaz Semmelweis, an early pioneer of germ theory, observed that the doctor-attended maternity ward had a higher mortality rate than the midwife ward because doctors went straight from dissecting corpses (a bloody jacket being a badge of honor) to deliveries, transferring sepsis into the open wound of the postpartum womb; he found that dousing hands in carbolic acid dramatically reduced mortality.Megan McArdle on the Oedipus Trap
- When Oliver Wendell Holmes Sr. studied case records in 1840s Boston and concluded that doctors carried puerperal fever and needed to cleanse between births, he received contemptuous pushback from senior obstetricians, with a leading Philadelphia doctor (Meigs) dismissing his conclusion on the grounds that 'a gentleman's hands are clean.'312 | Thomas Levenson on the Mutual History of Humans and Germs
- The Semmelweis case shows that even in the physical sciences, correct theories backed by some evidence can be suppressed for years: Semmelweis correctly identified that doctors moving from the morgue to the delivery room transmitted puerperal fever (preventable by handwashing), but a poorly-executed experiment and his abrasive personality let the older establishment, wedded to the 'bad vapors' theory, dismiss him while thousands of women kept dying.Dan Klein on Truth, Bias, and Disagreement 03/16/2009
- Ignaz Semmelweis discovered that the difference between Vienna General Hospital's two maternity wards was that doctors and students did pathology (dissecting corpses) before delivering babies; by requiring them to wash with a chlorine solution until the smell of death was gone, he rapidly brought the doctors' ward—where up to 10% of patients died—down to the midwives' low infection rate, without knowing about germs.312 | Thomas Levenson on the Mutual History of Humans and Germs
- The story of Ignaz Semmelweis—who around 1846 showed that doctors washing their hands dramatically cut childbirth mortality from puerperal fever, yet was ignored for decades until germ theory emerged—demonstrates that people resist even life-saving truths when those truths are unpleasant, because accepting that doctors themselves were killing women was too painful, so they found reasons to dismiss the work as mere correlation.Russ Roberts on the Information Revolution, Politics, Yeats, and Yelling