The Semmelweis case shows that even in the physical sciences, correct theories backed by some evidence can be suppressed for years: Semmelweis correctly identified that doctors moving from the morgue to the delivery room transmitted puerperal fever (preventable by handwashing), but a poorly-executed experiment and his abrasive personality let the older establishment, wedded to the 'bad vapors' theory, dismiss him while thousands of women kept dying.
factualpending
Speaker
Russ RobertsEvidence Quote
“it's very difficult for truth to out data matters empirical evidence does matter but my memory of Kuhn's structure of scientific revolutions is that major paradigm shifts often occur through the death of the proponents of the old regime”
Created: 6/16/2026, 2:03:33 PM
Your notes
Loading notes...