primary qualities
In Locke's philosophy, objective properties of material bodies (size, shape, weight, density) that exist independently of perception and produce sensations in observers.
As defined in A History of Philosophy | 41 John Locke
Where it comes up · 5
- A History of Philosophy | 42 John Locke's Theory of Ideas4 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 30 Thomas Hobbes3 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 44 George Berkeley's Idealism2 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 41 John Locke1 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 39 Leibinz's "Monads"1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “primary qualities” →
- Monads themselves do not have spatial extension, size, shape, density, or other spatial occupancy characteristics (what are called primary qualities); only bodies (composites of monads) occupy space and have primary qualities.A History of Philosophy | 39 Leibinz's "Monads"
- The distinction between subjective secondary qualities and objective primary qualities makes it possible for later empiricists like Berkeley to ask whether a tree falling in the forest when no one is present produces any noise, because if noise is a secondary quality (subjective), then without consciousness to register the sound waves, there is no noise.A History of Philosophy | 30 Thomas Hobbes
- Berkeley's strategy was to use John Locke's own epistemology against him by denying that there is sufficient evidence for the objective reality of primary qualities (the properties Locke thought represented matter), thereby undermining Locke's representational theory of knowledge and realism about matter.A History of Philosophy | 44 George Berkeley's Idealism
- When describing a colored object (e.g., 'my blue shirt'), the shirt is not actually blue; rather, the shirt's primary qualities cause the observer to see blue—the shirt causes blue appearance in consciousness, not the shirt possessing the quality of blueness.A History of Philosophy | 30 Thomas Hobbes
- Substance is a complex idea inferred from the presence of particular qualities—we infer that there must be something that 'has' those qualities, but this substance is 'something I know not what,' an utterly unknown substratum underlying the qualities we perceive, whether material substance or mental substance (mind/spirit/soul).A History of Philosophy | 42 John Locke's Theory of Ideas
- The Newtonian scientific worldview strips the world of secondary qualities—color, sound, smell—creating a world of purely primary qualities (shape, size, density, motion) that is fundamentally alien to human sensory experience, which prompted Romantic poets like Tennyson to lament this loss of a world alive with sensory richness.A History of Philosophy | 42 John Locke's Theory of Ideas
- Locke distinguishes between ideas of primary qualities and ideas of secondary qualities (pages 178-181): secondary qualities (smell, taste, color, sound, texture) are associated with different sense organs and are produced in us but have no objective reality in external things; primary qualities (size, shape, weight, density) are objective properties of material bodies that produce sensations through causal influence.A History of Philosophy | 41 John Locke
- Our ideas of primary qualities are indeed representations and copies of the way things are (a 'copy theory of knowledge'), whereas our ideas of secondary qualities are not copies, so truth as correspondence between idea and thing applies only to primary qualities, not secondary qualities.A History of Philosophy | 42 John Locke's Theory of Ideas
- Secondary qualities are subjective and relative to the perceiver's sensory conditions (e.g., a color appears different depending on lighting; a sound is clearer or fainter depending on ear condition), and the same relativity and dependence on observation conditions applies to primary qualities like shape: a distant castle appears as a small round blob, but when approached appears as a large square shape.A History of Philosophy | 44 George Berkeley's Idealism
- Primary qualities are those qualities that material bodies objectively possess whether or not they are perceived, including spatial properties such as shape, size, and density—the properties of material bodies as understood in Newtonian science.A History of Philosophy | 42 John Locke's Theory of Ideas