The distinction between subjective secondary qualities and objective primary qualities makes it possible for later empiricists like Berkeley to ask whether a tree falling in the forest when no one is present produces any noise, because if noise is a secondary quality (subjective), then without consciousness to register the sound waves, there is no noise.

causalpending

Speaker

Lecture instructor

Evidence Quote

“when we get to Berkeley for Berkeley to say does the tree that falls in the forest when there's nobody around to hear make any noise? Because if noise is a secondary quality, it's subjective. Is there a noise as noise when there's nobody to hear it?”

Source

A History of Philosophy | 30 Thomas Hobbes— wheatoncollege
Created: 8/11/2026, 1:09:07 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...