meta-narrative
A grand, overarching story a society uses to explain and legitimize its knowledge and history; post-modernism is defined by skepticism toward such grand narratives.
As defined in Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay on the Enemies of Modernity
Where it comes up · 6
- Jean-Francois Lyotard: The Post-modern Condition4 claims
- Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay on the Enemies of Modernity2 claims
- Foucault: Power, Knowledge and Post-structuralism2 claims
- Barthes, Semiotics and the Revolt Against Structuralism1 claim
- RSA Replay: A Brief History of Humankind1 claim
- Conclusion: Political, Social and Cultural Criticism and Theory1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “meta-narrative” →
- Althusser tried to unify Marxism and structuralism as the last of the modernist paradigms—giant deterministic systems shown to operate simultaneously as part of a larger meta-system—but Barthes rejects this, arguing that structuralism and Marxism inhibit and prohibit human freedom and entail totalizing meta-narratives that people no longer believe inBarthes, Semiotics and the Revolt Against Structuralism
- Modernism's narratives were too naive and simplistic while post-modernism over-compensated with cynicism and superficiality; meta-modernism proposes to restore meaningful narratives while remaining slightly skeptical of them, ideally by grounding narratives in truth and reason or at least clearly separating what is provisionally true from what is merely emotively or morally meaningful.Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay on the Enemies of Modernity
- Capitalism's meta-narrative has shifted from viewing the economic situation as zero-sum (scarcity: if I get more, you get less) to viewing it as win-win (abundance: through trade, specialization, and connection, the pie grows so everyone can have more).RSA Replay: A Brief History of Humankind
- Specific examples of grand narratives that Lyotard rejects as outmoded include Hegelianism (the idea of the geist organizing all human history), Marxist class conflict narratives, populist and national socialist folk narratives, the ideology of performativity in natural science, and Habermas's communicative linguistic ethics based on rational consensus.Jean-Francois Lyotard: The Post-modern Condition
- Lyotard directly targets Jürgen Habermas's project of founding moral and political legitimacy on the basis of rational consensus achieved through ideal speech situations, arguing that consensus is inherently unjust because it silences alternative discourses.Jean-Francois Lyotard: The Post-modern Condition
- Examples of totalizing meta-narratives include Marxism, which explains all history through class conflict, and Freudian psychoanalysis, which legitimizes all judgments through the hydraulic model of the mind.Foucault: Power, Knowledge and Post-structuralism
- Postmodernism's claim that there can be no overarching legitimizing meta-narrative is not merely an epistemological claim but a gesture at the fact that we are no longer whole selves but fragments; we cannot achieve the Cartesian cogito because we lack the Delphic self-knowledge Socrates sought.Conclusion: Political, Social and Cultural Criticism and Theory
- Post-modernists view knowledge as a construct of power, holding that science and reason are merely the way white male Westerners have constructed knowledge; this leads them to reject objective truth in favor of multiple 'truths'—lived experience, cultural narratives, and the epistemologies of marginalized groups—which must now be elevated above the previously dominant Western truth.Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay on the Enemies of Modernity
- Foucault believes that what characterized intellectual life from about 1800 to 1950 was preoccupation with grand narratives—one big story that legitimized all claims to knowledge, political legitimacy, and moral judgment—and that all these grand meta-narratives have disappeared and are no longer plausible.Foucault: Power, Knowledge and Post-structuralism
- Performativity is the fundamental ideology of advanced capitalist society, defined as maximum output for minimum input, and is understood as intrinsically rational and self-justifying, but it is merely an ideological construct without legitimate grounds.Jean-Francois Lyotard: The Post-modern Condition