
RSA Replay: A Brief History of Humankind
What this covers
This is a single-speaker lecture at the RSA in which Yuval Harari moves through the whole of human history in three stages: the cognitive revolution, the agricultural revolution, and the scientific revolution. He starts about 70,000 years ago, when at least six human species shared the planet and fewer than a million humans, all species combined, had an ecological impact comparable to gorillas today. He says it is unknown how or why Homo sapiens alone developed language able to describe things that do not exist. He also notes that Homo sapiens probably had a hand in the other species' disappearance, though there is no smoking gun. Along the way he argues that a lone human would lose to a chimpanzee, and that the Dunbar number of about 150 sets the limit on communities that run on personal acquaintance.
The middle of the talk turns to the costs and ironies of progress. Harari calls the agricultural revolution a terrible development for ordinary people, citing peasant women in ancient Egypt who ate worse and worked harder than hunter-gatherers. He claims the human brain has shrunk over the last 10,000 years because individuals need to know less. He also holds that most wars, World War I among them, were fought over stories rather than scarcity, which is contested. On the history of ideas, he treats human rights as an invention rather than a natural fact, and describes capitalism's meta-narrative as shifting from zero-sum scarcity to a win-win picture of growth. He also remarks on the improbable rise of Christianity. The scientific revolution, in his account, was above all a discovery of ignorance.
The final stretch is the most speculative. He argues that medicine is shifting from healing the sick to upgrading the healthy. Because an upgrade has no norm to reach, the wealthy could keep moving ahead, opening real biological gaps between rich and poor for the first time. He also predicts that the religions that will matter in the 21st century are emerging in Silicon Valley rather than the Middle East, because the people there understand the modern world better. These are forecasts, not established claims. Lactase persistence serves as his example that natural selection is still operating on humans.
Harari argues that Homo sapiens' unique ability to create and believe in shared fictional stories enables large-scale cooperation, which is the true source of human dominance over other species, not individual intelligence or physical superiority.
- Humans can cooperate flexibly in large numbers because we can believe in imaginary entities (gods, nations, money) that don't exist in objective reality
- Other animals either cooperate inflexibly in large numbers (ants, bees) or flexibly only in small groups (chimpanzees, dolphins) based on intimate knowledge
- This capacity for shared fiction underlies all human institutions—religions, economies, legal systems, armies—and explains why we dominate the planet while other species remain constrained
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The greatest discovery of the scientific revolution was the discovery of ignorance—the realization that revealed religion and scriptural authorities don't provide correct answers and that we must go out and find the answers ourselves through investigation.
“the greatest discovery of the Scientific Revolution was the discovery of ignorance and the discovery that wait a minute we don't understand the world we don't know what's happening here what's all these Revelations and scriptures they don't give us the correct answers to the most important questions we still have to find out these answers”
Humans are selfish like other animals, but from a biological perspective, humans are fundamentally social animals who cannot survive without the social system around them; the mythology that humans began as selfish individuals who then formed society through social contract is biologically incorrect.
“humans are like other animals they are selfish but from a biological perspective I think the sent feature of our species is that we are social animals we cannot survive by ourselves the idea that humans began like this social construct mythology that humans were at first individuals pursuing their own egotistic aims and at some point they began to come together by some social contract to form Society H it's as far as I know incorrect from a biological perspective Society or the group comes before the individual H human being cannot survive without um the social system around him or her”
There were at least six different species of humans on the planet 70,000 years ago, not just Homo sapiens, which is similar to how there are many species of bears (grizzly, polar, black, brown) but only one human species today.
“there is Big controversy about what happened to all the other species we know now for for almost for certain that 70,000 years ago there were at least six different species of humans on the planet which may sound strange because we are used to thinking about ourselves as the only humans and how can it be different species of humans but we just need to look around the other animals and as you said there are many species of bears like grizzly bears and polar bears and black bears and brown bears so why have just one species of humans and in fact it wasn't like this 60 70,000 years ago there were many many species of humans”
There exists a magical border of approximately 150 individuals—the Dunbar number—beyond which humans cannot intimately know people; this limit creates a fundamental constraint: communities of 100 people can function without shared fictional beliefs, but communities larger than this are impossible without shared myths, money, or religion.
“the main problem is that at least with Homo sapiens as as we know it it's very difficult if not impossible to intimately know more than 150 individuals there have been many sociological and psychological studies about this and somewhere around the number 150 there is this magical border line you can know quite well 100 people 120 but you cannot know intimately 200 people or 500 people or 1,000 people and therefore it is possible to create a well functioning intimate community of say 100 persons which is not based on belief in some gods or national myth or money or whatever it's just based on intimate knowledge and relations between one another but as you cross the mark line and you try to construct cooperation between 10,000 people or 100,000 people it's impossible as far as we know at least we don't have any example of a big Society say of 100,000 people that manages to survive and to work effectively without some kind of these communal stories that everybody believes in”
The human brain has been shrinking over the last 10,000 years since the agricultural revolution because humans need to know less and less on an individual level to survive; we become increasingly dependent on others for knowledge and skills, so selection pressure favors smaller brains.
“actually as history evolves the individuality of humans decrease we become ever more dependent upon larger and larger groups and the best evidence for that is the shrinking of the human mind over the last 10,000 years since the Agricultural Revolution our not not the mind sorry the brain and over the last 10,000 years the brains of homo sapiens is has been shrinking and uh the reason for that is that we need to know less and less on the individual level in order to survive and we become more dependent on the other on as a hunter gatherer I needed to know a lot of things myself how to hunt how to gather how to prepare my food how to prepare my clothes how to prepare my weapons and tools as today a historian I just need to know history I get paid for that and then I take this money and I buy everything I have no idea how to grow wheat I have no idea like my shoes if you put a gun to my head and tell me you need to produce now these shoes or you die then I die I have absolutely no idea even what is it made of how how do you start even making a shoe I don't know I just know history so I need a smaller brain”
Capitalism's meta-narrative has shifted from viewing the economic situation as zero-sum (scarcity: if I get more, you get less) to viewing it as win-win (abundance: through trade, specialization, and connection, the pie grows so everyone can have more).
“the meta narrative is in fact The Meta Narrative of capitalism uh for most of history people viewed especially e the economic situation as a zero sum gain there is scarcity if I have a bigger piece of the pie somebody else must have a smaller piece that that's the way it goes and then enter Adam Smith and he says no it can be a way win situation the P can grow and the P grows through this connections through trade through specialization on the collective level so that everybody can have more and more”
Homo sapiens likely had a hand in the disappearance of all other human species, though there is no smoking gun proof, making this one of the biggest questions and thought experiments in history.
“apparently I think it's quite obvious that homo sapiens had a hand in The Disappearance of all our siblings we don't have like The Smoking Gun that we can prove it but it seems very uh credible that we had something to do with it it wasn't just pure coincidence and I think it's not only one of the biggest questions of History it's always it's also one of the biggest thought experiments to try and imagine how the world would have looked like if at least one other species of humans had survived”
The vast majority of human conflicts throughout history were not about scarcity of food, mates, or territory—they were about different stories in people's minds; biological explanations of human conflict (we fight over food like chimpanzees) are largely incorrect.
“there is a widespread belief that it's a kind of struggle kind of conflict H resulting from biological reasons that humans fight for the same reasons that chimpanzees or wolves fight that they fight on about food and about mates and I don't think it's true I'm a military historian by profession I mean before I became a world historian and my impression is that with some exceptions the vast majority of human conflicts during history were not about food were not about mats were not about actual scarcity they were about the stories in people's minds”
On an individual level, humans are not uniquely superior to other animals—a human placed alone with a chimpanzee in a survival scenario would likely lose to the chimpanzee.
“on the individual level we are not so unique we are not so smart we are not so powerful if you put me and the chimpanzee on a Long Island together and we had to struggle for survival I would definitely put my bets on the chimpanzee not on myself and it is not something special about myself I think it's true about most people that if you put them alone with a chimpanzee that's the end I mean the chimpanzee will definitely win over”
The cognitive revolution is the moment at which unique human language capable of talking about things that don't exist appeared; it is unknown exactly how or why this ability emerged, distinguishing Homo sapiens from other species like Neanderthals.
“the cognitive Revolution is the point at which this new sapience language appeared we don't know exactly how whose unique feature is this ability to talk about things that don't exist because communication is very common in the animal kingdom all animals almost all animals communicate but they communicate about real things the strange thing about us is that we communicate more and more about things that exist only here”
Science's greatest feature is that scientists can admit 'I don't know' about things like why Homo sapiens evolved unique language instead of Neanderthals, and they can continue researching; this is fundamentally different from religious authority which must provide definitive answers.
“I think until today as a scientist myself the thing I like most about science is that if you don't know something you can just say I don't know if it's not like I don't a rabbi or a priest which must have the answers if we don't know for example and we don't know as far as I know why Homo sapiens evolve this unique language how come sapiens and not neandertals so I'm I'm perfectly within my right as a scientist to come to and say I don't know we are still researching that and that's I think is a wonderful wonderful thing”
World War I in 1914 is an example of a war not caused by scarcity—there was enough food in Europe, so the war cannot be explained by biological factors like competition for resources.
“there is a gentleman next to you there um there are certain communities who have rejected a number of uh the de velopments of society such as the ariss who who have say they they've taken themselves outside of the Realms of what we would call normal society but they still have their story they still have the background to what why they are living in that way do your knowledge are there any communities who have rejected the sort of conditioning of these intangibles these fictions um and if there haven't been could you speculate as to if we tried to do this would we be able to do it would we be able to fall back on animal instincts both of compassion and cooperation which don't rely on fictions or do you think it would be complete disaster I think that the main problem is that at least with Homo sapiens as as we know it it's very difficult if not impossible to intimately know more than 150 individuals”
70,000 years ago there were less than 1 million humans of all species together and their impact on the ecosystem was minimal, comparable to gorillas today or less than that of jellyfish or bumblebees.
“70,000 years ago you find that the planet is populated by many different kinds of humans many species of humans Homo sapiens was just one of them and all these humans the most important thing to know about them is that they were unimportant creatures 70,000 years ago there were less than 1 million humans of all species together and their impact on the ecosystem was minimal like that of gorillas today far less than that say of jellyfish or bumblebees”
Christianity is an example of a surprisingly successful story that conquered the Roman Empire and the world despite seeming unconvincing—an esoteric Jewish sect with a creative but implausible narrative about God incarnating as a human, born to a virgin, crucified for sins—the success likely involved accidents rather than the story's inherent logical force.
“it's sometimes extremely surprising when you look at the world in the year say 100 AD who could have imagined that the story of Christianity would become so successful and um it why was it I don't know it's a very big surprise I mean you see this esoteric Jewish sect with this kind of extremely ER creative story let's say about God incarnating himself as a human born to a virgin crucified for our sins doesn't sound very convincing but but it was the Roman Empire reason yeah it takes over and conquers the world and how how how it manages to do so I don't know I think that in many cases the successful stories there are a lot of accidents behind their success”
Throughout history, wealthy people have believed they are better, smarter, more moral, and more ethical than the poor, but according to historians, social scientists, and philosophers, this is not true—the rich became rich not because they are better. However, in the future with biological upgrades, rich people really may be better than the rest.
“throughout history the rich always believe usually believed that they are better they are smarter they are more moral more ethical more rational whatever this is why we are rich of course but as far as many historians and social scientists and philosophers believe this is not the case the rich did not become richer because they are better there was no real difference between rich and poor but in the future we might reach a situation in which this will be a fact that rich people really are better than the rest because they have all these kind of of new up new upgrades sapiens 2 sapiens 3 and so forth”
The transition from healing the sick (egalitarian) to upgrading the healthy (elitist) represents a revolutionary shift in medicine—healing has a norm to reach, while upgrading has no norm and involves perpetual enhancement, opening the possibility of real biological gaps between rich and poor.
“science and medicine in particular is undergoing a a a big revolution in the 20th century medicine the main aim of Medicine of the medical establishment was to heal the sick in the 21st century the main aim will probably be to upgrade the healthy so from Healing The Sick we are moving to upgrading the healthy and when you deal with Healing The Sick this is basically egalitarian project because you have a vision of some kind of Norm this is what we means to be a healthy human being and you try to push anybody who falls below the nose Norm you try to push them up so they reach the norm until in a perfect world everybody are the same everybody are healthy but now as we move on and they say no we want to upgrade the healthy not just heal the sick there is no more Norm the only idea of upgrade is to go beyond the norm and this is in essence an anti-egalitarian project it's an elitist project”
Even if a particular medical upgrade becomes very cheap and available to everyone, the wealthy will always seek the next upgrade, creating perpetual biological inequality—a real possibility of opening 'for the first time in history big biological gaps between rich and poor.'
“because there is even if some particular up raade becomes very cheap and everybody has it so you want the next thing and the next thing and you have here a real possibility of opening for the first time in history big biological gaps between rich and poor”
The agricultural revolution was a terrible development for most ordinary humans—peasant women in ancient Egypt experienced a much worse diet, longer working hours, and harder physical labor than hunter-gatherers 20,000 years earlier, while also introducing social stratification and exploitation.
“agriculture is usually seen as a Great Leap Forward for humankind and from the perspective say of the affluent middle class today in the west it does seem a good idea because it's the basis for everything we have but uh we are not the typical post agricultural uh human the much more typical and important perspective is for example of a simple peasant woman in ancient Egypt if you think about the Agricultural Revolution from the Viewpoint of a simple peasant woman in in in fonic Egypt then agriculture looks like a terrible idea because the life the daily life of the average woman as far as we know in ancient Egypt was much harder than the life of the average hunter gatherer at 20,000 years earlier you had a far worse diet you had to to work much longer and most importantly the work was much harder the human body and the human mind were adapted by hundreds of thousands of years of evolution to the life of hunter gatherers running after gazel and sniffing for mushrooms in in the forest it wasn't adapted to the grueling work of Agriculture of digging canals and carrying water buckets and then then harvesting and all that and that even without mentioning social stratification and exploit which are also apparently the result of the Agricultural Revolution”
Modern secular liberals believe in human rights as if they are natural facts, but from a scientific perspective this is obviously untrue—human rights are invented by people, not decreed by nature; yet many people today still believe in stories claiming external, non-human origin, a form of religious belief.
“this kind of story is still with us today this is the way that many people think about human rights they think they are natural it's not something that people invented it's something that humans naturally nature decreed that we have a right to life a right to Liberty now from a scientific perspective it's obviously not true it's obvious no people invented that it's not nature but many people today liberal seculars who don't believe in God still have this idea of a a an order coming from above”
A successful story needs to understand the situation it addresses and be updated accordingly; Middle Eastern religious authorities don't understand the 21st century and cannot construct good stories for it, so their stories have less chance of taking over the world than those created by people in Silicon Valley who understand the modern world better.
“a successful story needs to be updated it needs to understand the situation IT addresses I think the molas and rabbis and and priest in the Middle East don't understand the 21st century therefore they cannot construct a good story for that Century I think the people in Silicon Valley understand the world much better and therefore their stories they can be completely imaginary but they will be far more relevant and therefore they have a much better chance of taking over the world”
The most interesting place today from a religious perspective is not the Middle East but Silicon Valley, where new religions that will take over the world are beginning to emerge, because the Silicon Valley figures understand the 21st century better than Middle Eastern religious authorities.
“I think that the most interesting place today from a religious perspective is not the Middle East but it's Silicon Valley the new religions that will take over the world that are beginning now to take over the world will come from Silicon Valley”
Homo sapiens lives in a dual reality: an objective reality of trees, rivers, lions, and mountains, and a fictional reality invented by humans containing nations, money, gods, and human rights; over time, the fictional reality has become more powerful, such that the survival of objective reality depends on imaginary stories humans have invented.
“homo sapiens in contrast to all the other animals in the world Homo sapiens lives in a dual reality other animals like the baboons or aligators Lions they live inside an objective reality made of trees and rivers and other animals and clouds and winds and whatnot we humans also live in this reality we also encounter trees and lions and and rivers and mountains but we also have another reality in addition to this objective reality we also live inside a fictional reality reality a reality that we invented that exists only in our imagination a reality that contains things like Nations which are just the stories that we invented which contains money which is populated by gods which includes things like human rights which again it's our invention and what is amazing about history is not only that humans inhabit this dual reality the the layer of objective reality and on it another layer of fictional reality what is really amazing is that over time fictional reality has become more and more powerful until we reach the situation today when the very survival of trees and rivers and lions and chimpanzees depends on the imaginary stories that homo sapiens has invented”
A baby transported from a hunter-gatherer society 20,000 years ago to today's UK would be largely indistinguishable physically, emotionally, and cognitively to a modern child, with the exception of lactase persistence, showing humans are unchanged despite massive cultural change.
“if we again do a thought experiment if we take a baby born to hunter gatherers 20,000 years ago and transported in time and raised him or her today in say the UK I don't think that there will be a big differences either physical or emotional and cognitive yes he or she probably would not be able to digest milk but in many many other respects I don't think there will be a big difference”
Natural selection continues today as shown by the example of lactase persistence in humans—20,000 years ago humans didn't drink milk as adults, but over the last 10,000 years certain populations in the Middle East, Africa, and Europe evolved the ability to digest milk through natural selection.
“it is true that Evolution never stops it's not that like 70,000 years ago or 10,000 years ago somebody hits the brakes and that's it no more evolution it goes on and the example with the milk is an excellent example 20,000 years ago humans did not drink milk as adults certainly not cow cow's milk but over the last 10,000 years since the Advent of Agriculture certain population of humans especially in the Middle East parts of Africa and Europe evolved with natural selection this ability to digest the milk of certain mammals like cows”
Computer programs now create art (music, visual art) that most people find indistinguishable from and sometimes better than art created by humans, questioning what will remain uniquely human as computers take over more fields.
“and even with art sometimes people think okay when the computers will take over everything we still have art and everybody will become artists and everybody will be a betan or a Picasso or whatever but the thing is that we now have computer programs who create art they write music that most people find indistinguishable and even better than music created by humans”
The real secret of Homo sapiens' success is the ability to cooperate flexibly in large numbers—something no other animal can do, as opposed to social insects which cooperate inflexibly in large numbers or social mammals which cooperate flexibly only in small groups.
“if you put a thousand chimpanzees and a thousand humans on a lone Island then the humans will win quite easily for the simple reason that a thousand chimpanzees can never cooperate effectively this is the real secret secret of success of homo sapiens the ability to cooperate in large numbers and flexibly now there are other animals that can cooperate effectively in large numbers the social insects ants and bees are the obvious example however ants and bees are very inflexible in the way that they cooperate if they encounter a new situation a new danger a new opportunity they cannot reinvent the social system the way that they cooperate in the in the colony or in the beehive in order to face this new challenge so they cooperate in very large numbers but in a rigid way other social animals like the chimpanzees like the Dolphins like the elephants they can cooperate in a much more flexible way however they do so only in small numbers because cooperation among them is based on intimate knowledge”
The Israeli-Palestinian conflict cannot be explained by scarcity of food or territory—there is enough to feed and house everyone in that region; the problem is two incompatible stories, and a solution would require 'some genius Storyteller' who could create a third story acceptable to both sides.
“if you think about say the the conflict in my country between Israelis and Palestinians there is plenty of food between the Mediterranean and the Jordan River you can feed everybody there is no scarcity of food there is no scarcity even of territory everybody can build their houses there is enough but the problem is that you have two very different stories and so far we didn't have the fortune to have this genius Storyteller who could come up with the third story and convince everybody to agree on the on the same story”
Evolution has not stopped but is proceeding much more slowly through natural selection; however, we may be moving from evolution by natural selection (which dominated for 4 billion years) to a new era where natural selection is replaced by intelligent design through genetic engineering, brain-computer interfaces, and nanotechnology.
“we are I think moving from a evolutionary process by natural selection which was the um dominant principle of life for four billion years on Earth to a kind of new era in which natural selection is replaced by intelligent design we can start re-engineer other animals and ourselves with genetic engineering with direct brain computer interfaces and all kinds of nanotechnology and other new technologies and this this opens up immense new opportunities for a new kind of evolution”
The unique capacity of Homo sapiens is the ability to talk about and believe in things that don't exist in objective reality—gods, money, nations, human rights—which exist only in shared imaginary stories, unlike other animals that communicate only about real, existing things.
“the real secret of success of our specie is that we alone can talk about things that don't exist at all anywhere except in our own imagination in the stories that we invented all the an other animals they too communicate chimpanzees communicate and dolphins communicate and elephants communicate but they communicate information about things that really exist they talk about trees they talk about rivers they talk about lions about D about predators about things like that humans know how to talk about all these things but also humans can talk about things that don't exist at all like Gods like money like Nations like human rights all these things that we areel invented and that exist only in our shared stories”
Only Homo sapiens can be motivated to action by belief in fictional stories about things that don't exist, such as religious promises of an afterlife, whereas no other animal (e.g., chimpanzees) can be convinced to act by such imaginary narratives.
“you can never convince a chimpanzee to do something say to give you a banana by promising that chimpanzee that after you die you know what happens you will go to chimpanzee heaven and there you will receive lots and lots of bananas for your good deeds no chimpanzee will ever be convinced by such a story to do anything only us only Homo sapiens can believe such stories and can be motivated for Action by such stories and this is why we control the world and the chimpanzees are locked up in zoos and research laborator stories”
Money is a fictional story—a piece of worthless paper or metal without inherent value—that billions of people believe in and that becomes extremely effective at coordinating economic behavior because of this shared belief.
“money is also just a story chimpanzees and dolphins and wolves none of them men uses money none of them they can exchange things I give you a banana you give me coconut but the idea of money this is something unique to humans because again it is based on a story about something that exists only in our imagination we take say a piece of paper or a piece of gold which is worth nothing you can't do anything with gold you can't eat it you can't drink it you can't wear it you can't even make weapons out of it because it's too soft so you take something without any inherent value and you tell a story look this piece of worthless metal or this piece of colorful paper it is worth 10 bananas and if enough people believe that story then it becomes an extremely effective story”
Every year or two, companies like Google and Microsoft announce new technological capabilities that seemed impossible 5-10 years earlier: 20 years ago, beating a chess champion seemed impossible; 10 years ago, self-driving cars seemed impossible; now Google has achieved autonomous vehicles.
“every year or two we hear about a new invention from Google or Microsoft or somebody that um does things that even five or 10 years ago when were considered completely beyond the capability of algorithms and computers like 20 years ago nobody believed that a computer could could beat the a chess champion of the world in in chess and 10 years ago nobody thought that that it would be possible for a computer to drive a car and now Google has done that”
Aboriginal Australians have an accurate understanding of human existence—the concept of 'dreamtime' depicts that humans inhabit a dream world created by the dreams of mythical beings, analogous to how modern humans live within fictional realities created by stories about the European Union, Google, and the dollar.
“Aboriginal Australians they explain the world what is happening in the world by one of their key Concepts is the concept of dream time According to which we actually inhabit a Dream World created by the dreams of mythical beings these beings dream the world and we live inside that the dream of of these mythical beings and this in my view is an extremely accurate depiction of the world we are living inside the dreams of mythical entities like the European Union and like Google and like the dollar which exist nowhere except in these fictional stories”
Art is far more important than mathematics, physics, or chemistry for large-scale cooperation because while these sciences create tools, art is what convinces 10 million strangers to believe in and support the same fictional story.
“because uh again our success depends on large scale cooperation and large scale Corporation depends on inventing a story and convincing lots of strangers to believe all of them to believe in the same story and in order to do that art is far more important than mathematics or physics or chemistry you need mathematics and physics and in chemistry to create tools to create cars to create airplanes but when you try to convince 10 million people to believe in the same story invented story fictional story mathematics is not going to help you here you need art”
Traditional theist religions centered around great gods are probably having their day and are on the way out; however, religion in the broader sense—belief in some superhuman order from which norms and values emanate—will not disappear because it's the basis for human cooperation.
“I don't think that religion is bound to disappear it depends on the definition of religion if by religion we mean a very narrow Definition of belief in some great Gods then it wasn't even H it wasn't even common to all people during history you have many religions in history for example Buddhism in which which gods are not very important so if you have this narrow definition I think religion is characteristic of only part of humanity part of history and it's probably had its day and it's on the way out these traditional theist religions centered around great Gods H still billions of people believe in that but I think that um the direction of history that history is taking we leave those kinds of religions behind however if you think about religion in the broader sense of a belief in some superhuman order that there is some law some principle some power which is stronger than human more which humans cannot change and that all our norms and values emanate from this higher order then this is something that every every society has including modern secular society and this is something that is not going to disappear because it's the basis for human cooperation”
People convince others to believe in stories by telling them the story doesn't come from human invention but from a superhuman source—either God or the laws of nature—making the story seem necessary and unchangeable.
“the way that you convince people to believe in a certain fundamental story is to tell them this is not something I invented this story comes from some superhuman Source the two main sources are either some God all the laws of nature you come to people and you say this story it's not my invention these are the laws of nature and therefore we cannot change it therefore we must follow it”
When different groups have incompatible stories, this creates major problems, but history shows that some stories expand and unite more people—not necessarily the best or most rational stories, but the most successful ones in spreading and gaining adherents.
“when different groups have different stories this is a big problem but what we see as history Evol unfolds is that some stories spread around and manage to unite more and more people behind them it's not necessarily the best stories it's not necessarily the most rational stories it's the most successful stories and what makes a story successful”
Luck plays a strong role in narrative success—you must be lucky rather than having the best or most logically appropriate story to achieve dominance, as historical narrative success often involves accidents and contingencies.
“you have to be lucky rather than being best or most logically appropriate story”
Successful stories don't need to be true, rational, or even clear—some of the most successful stories in history are actually unclear, and this lack of clarity is part of the magic that makes the story powerful.
“a story again it doesn't need to be true it doesn't need to be rational it doesn't even need to be very clear some of the most successful stories in history are actually unclear you don't understand exactly but this is part of the magic of the story”
Small family businesses with say 20 employees function effectively without rules, regulations, or hierarchies because everyone knows everyone; but as a business grows to 500 or 5,000 employees, it becomes necessary to create hierarchies, rules, and regulations or it will collapse.
“you can see it in many in many areas like in the economy you have small family businesses of say 20 employees everybody knows everybody else everything works fine even without rules and regulations and hierarchies but if this small h family firm succeeds and grows and grows and now have 500 employees or 5,000 employees it will have it will it is necessary that it will start having these hierarchies and rules or regulations or it will collapse you must have them at at that point”
All large-scale human cooperation—political networks, economic systems, trade systems, religions, churches—is based on large-scale networks of cooperation between many different individuals, particularly strangers, not the accomplishment of any single individual.
“all the various things that humans have managed to accomplish during their history are not the accomplishment of a single individual but they are always the accomplishment of a network of cooporation of many different individuals and in particularly many strangers take even this lecture as an example what's happening now in this Hall cannot happen with chimpanzees chimpanzees never give lectur to strangers”
The possibility of creating artificial things that are more powerful than ourselves is very dangerous, analogous to the scientific mythologies of Frankenstein and The Matrix, where humanity tries to create something better but ends up creating a monster; however, the danger doesn't stop us from trying.
“um I don't know if if it will work but we are trying to do it this is why it's also very dangerous and um most you know there is this scientific mythology like every like other religion science too has its own mythology and the main theme in scientific mythology is this Frankenstein story or the Matrix story in which people try to create something better but they mismanage it and they create some terrible monster and it is a possibility but it doesn't stop us from from trying”
Money is the most successful story in history because even people who hate American culture and politics—like Osama Bin Laden—will still accept and use American dollars without objection, showing that money transcends ideological and cultural conflicts.
“perhaps the best example is money if you think about the story of the dollar everybody believes in it even people like Osama Bin Laden who hated American culture and American politics and American society and everything to do in with America he hated except American dollars these evil quite fond of had no objection at all to getting American dollars”
There have been no examples of large societies of 100,000 people that manage to survive and function effectively without some kind of shared communal stories that everybody believes in.
“we don't have any example of a big Society say of 100,000 people that manages to survive and to work effectively without some kind of these communal stories that everybody believes in”
Art is the immense importance for human history because it shapes and spreads common stories and common myths among millions of strangers, which is the basis for large-scale cooperation.
“artart is extremely important of the utmost importance for our species and for our success as a species... the real the immense importance of artistic creation for a for human history it's this ability to shape and to spread these common stories these common myth among millions of strangers”
Most people spend very little time thinking about real things like trees and rivers during their daily lives; instead, they are constantly preoccupied by fictional inventions like money, nations, gods, and corporations.
“you can test yourself you can check for yourself try to see what are you thinking about what are you worried about during your day-to-day life many people find that they think very little about real things like trees and rivers and lions and most of the day they are constantly o preoccupied by these fictional inventions like money and like Nations and like gods and corporations and things like that”
The cognitive revolution 70,000 years ago created homo sapiens' unique ability to talk about things that don't exist; this is unknown exactly how it happened, which makes humans inability to explain the source of our own dominance.
“I don't have a explanation for how we gained the the the ability to invent stories and art and all that but given this ability artart is extremely important of the utmost importance for our species and for our success as a species”