
Jean-Francois Lyotard: The Post-modern Condition
What this covers
This is a single-lecturer talk by Michael Sugrue on Lyotard's The Postmodern Condition, running about 46 minutes. It is a critical exposition, not a neutral survey. Sugrue sets out Lyotard's anti-essentialist, anti-foundationalist position, which he places alongside Barthes and Foucault. He then tests it, arguing that postmodernism is less a coherent system than an organized set of emotions: systematic suspicion aimed at sites of power while its own claims are exempt from scrutiny.
The exposition begins with Language Games, which Lyotard takes from Wittgenstein. Sugrue explains how the idea undercuts positivism's hope for a universal standard of meaning, and how Lyotard turns it against every grand narrative). The targets are Hegelian history, Marxist class conflict, populist and national socialist folk narratives, and the ideology of performativity in science and advanced capitalism, meaning maximum output for minimum input. The most pointed target is Jürgen Habermas and his hope of grounding legitimacy in rational consensus. Lyotard counters that consensus silences alternative discourses. Against performativity he proposes paralogy, a proliferation of counter-discourses, and he describes the differend) as a site where incommensurable discourses cannot be translated, so that calling either one right or wrong is only a matter of preference. Sugrue also covers Just Gaming, a dialogue that ends in laughter without resolving whether paralogy can ground ethics and politics.
The criticism takes up much of the second half. Sugrue holds that Lyotard defines ethics as judgment without criteria, a kind of inverted Kierkegaardian leap. He says Lyotard invokes justice without ever explaining it or why anyone owes it to another. He argues that valorizing paralogy amounts to valorizing alienation, and that treating marginal discourses as equally valid lets opinion stand in for knowledge. His most contentious claims are that Lyotard's "terror" inflates personal worry into political principle, and that postmodernism is an intellectuals' project serving intellectuals. He compares its rebellion to Edmund Hillary climbing Everest "because it was there" and to Marlon Brando's biker. He concedes one point: the lack of consensus on questions like abortion may protect plurality from totalizing discourse turning totalitarian.
Lyotard's postmodernism is a radical inversion of Enlightenment critique that treats the rejection of totalizing meta-narratives as an end in itself, but this position collapses into relativism, solipsism, and the inflation of personal sentiment into political principle, ultimately failing to legitimize ethics or politics while claiming to liberate human discourse.
- Lyotard borrows Wittgensteinian language games to argue all grand narratives are illegitimate, but this logic undermines the possibility of communication and justice itself
- The valorization of paralogy and dissensus as intrinsic goods leads to criterionless judgment and the equation of opinion with knowledge, collapsing meaningful distinction
- Lyotard's concept of 'terror' as silencing the different inflates personal worry into political principle, leaving no principled basis for distinguishing actual oppression from disagreement
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Lyotard is an anti-essentialist, anti-foundationalist thinker who rejects the idea that there is some fundamental reality we can disclose through demythologizing procedure, similar to Barthes and Foucault.
“leotard is what i would describe as an anti-essentialist anti-foundationalist thinker he rejects the idea that there's some fundamental reality that we can disclose through some sort of demythologizing procedure in this case his views are rather similar to those of bart or foucault”
Lyotard makes a sustained engagement with Wittgenstein's concept of language games, using it as his paradigm for knowledge and as the foundation for his theory of little narratives versus grand narratives.
“what leotard does is take certain vikkenshinian ideas specifically the idea of the language game and uses that as his paradigm for knowledge and he uses that because it is the key to his idea of little narratives as opposed to big narratives or grand narratives”
Lyotard defines ethics as 'judgment without criteria', a criterionless choice analogous to Kierkegaard's leap of faith but inverted, where there is no ground for judgment yet judgment must be made.
“he defines ethics as judgment without criteria something like a kierkegaard who has affirmed this world rather than the next so we have that agonizing jump into nothingness but he's decided to go in the opposite door from kierkegaard so criterionless choice criterionless judgments that's what ethics turns out to be”
Lyotard directly targets Jürgen Habermas's project of founding moral and political legitimacy on the basis of rational consensus achieved through ideal speech situations, arguing that consensus is inherently unjust because it silences alternative discourses.
“it's not possible for us to generate a totalizing meta-narrative around the idea of a communicative linguistic ethics and very clearly here he is taking a shot at habermas habermas as you know was the one of the last exponents or one of the final products of the frankfurt school of marxism and what he did was generate a kind of quasi-rationalistic idea that it was possible to reasonably legitimize moral judgment based upon the possibility of a rational consensus about ethics leotard objects to that idea”
Postmodernism endorses the idea that we can't have totalizing discourses anymore; we can't have one unified story that accounts for and legitimizes all moral, political, and scientific claims.
“post modernism endorses the idea that we can't have totalizing discourses anymore we can't have one unified story which accounts for and legitimizes all our moral and political and scientific claims”
Specific examples of grand narratives that Lyotard rejects as outmoded include Hegelianism (the idea of the geist organizing all human history), Marxist class conflict narratives, populist and national socialist folk narratives, the ideology of performativity in natural science, and Habermas's communicative linguistic ethics based on rational consensus.
“for example hegelianism referring back to the career of the geist as organizing all of human history clearly a modern sort of an idea which can no longer be taken seriously along with the geist we're going to chuck out class conflict the marxist perspective the marxist totalizing narrative because that won't fit the bill either the folk right the idea of the various populist and or national socialism are generalizing totalizing meta-narrative which has purely mythic status no one can take that seriously anymore same sort of thing is going to apply to things like performativity which is what leotard calls the ideology or the ideological value structure of modern natural science”
A differend is a site of non-communication between incommensurable and untranslatable discourses where in the modernist framework one side must be right and the other wrong, but postmodernly it means nothing to describe either as right or wrong; it's just a matter of preference.
“a different is is it's a sight and here i mean in a metaphorical not a literal sense a site of non-communication between incommensurable and untranslatable discourses and the problem with the different is that in the modernist conception of the world there should be no such thing if there is one big totalizing meta discourse that whenever people have a fundamental disagreement an untranslatable conflict about the nature of the world one of them has to be right one of them has to be wrong they can't both be right leotard says no the simple brute fact of the world is that there is no totalizing meta discourse it's not the truth that one of them has to be right both of them can be right or more precisely it doesn't mean anything to describe either of them as being right or wrong it's just what you like and what you don't like”
Wittgenstein's concept of language games undermines positivism's aspiration for a universal standard to judge meaningful from meaningless utterances, showing instead that language operates through overlapping pragmatic interactions without a single organizing principle.
“wittenstein with his idea of language games says that the domain of the social practical use of language doesn't have one architectonic skeleton key that the positivists had longed for which would allow us to discern the truth value of every meaningful utterance just isn't possible instead what we have is an overlapping set of language games a sort of pragmatic interaction”
Lyotard's book Just Gaming, written in Platonic dialogue form over seven days with playful puns and wordplay, attempts to investigate whether paralogy can legitimize postmodern politics and ethics, but ultimately provides no solution, ending instead in laughter.
“he wants to investigate the question of is it possible to use perology and the idea of keeping the different alive not silencing terroristically the different is it possible to use that as the source of a new legitimation for paralogical postmodern thought well it's a beautiful little discourse it's done in the sort of form of a platonic dialogue and it's done over seven days and there's different parts and lots of witty plays on words and he deals with the many of the important themes in the western intellectual tradition this very dense and interesting little book but the ending of the book is the most important and interesting part they never really achieve an answer to the question of can we legitimize politics and ethics and such with parology as a matter of fact he defines ethics as judgment without criteria”
Alienation from the mainstream of discourse is another way of describing paralogical status, and if Lyotard valorizes paralogical thinking, he is asserting that alienation is an intrinsically good state of affairs, meaning any real intellectual must be alienated from dominant discourse.
“we might want to say that perology that the status of being an outsider to the majority or to the mainstream of discourse is another way of talking about the condition which intellectual sometimes call alienation and if leotard wishes us to pursue parology as an end in itself i think that what he's telling us is that alienation is an intrinsically good state of affairs and that any real intellectual has to be alienated elsewise you're being coerced by the dominant regime of discourse”
Although we may long for ultimate coherence and objectivity in discourse, we have no good grounds for believing in such unity; it is an act of faith rather than an act of knowledge, and our longing for it is shaped by our modernist intellectual tradition.
“there's a deep fact about the social about social reality here that although we may long for some ultimate coherence to our discourses we don't know what that is and we don't have very good grounds for believing in such a thing it's an act of faith rather than an act of knowledge”
There exists a structural flaw in postmodernism where it claims to be a generalized critique of the world but is actually used by intellectuals for the purposes of intellectuals, serving their professional and career interests rather than liberatory goals.
“the difficulty is is that while post-modernity claims to be a sort of generalized critique of the world in fact it's used by intellectuals for the purposes of intellectuals and i'll try and articulate that uh how that works a little bit later on”
Performativity is the fundamental ideology of advanced capitalist society, defined as maximum output for minimum input, and is understood as intrinsically rational and self-justifying, but it is merely an ideological construct without legitimate grounds.
“performativity is the value that is built into advanced capitalism what performativity means is maximum output for minimum input in other words it's the ideology of efficiency right and all capitalist undertakings does within this sort of an economic and social system regardless of what people are trying to produce all genuflect towards that value whether you're producing cars or stereos or lectures on philosophy you want to get the most kicked out in the minimum amount of time and that efficiency is understood as being intrinsically rational and intrinsically logical and intrinsically self-justifying and leotard's point is that it's not it's an ideology it's an ideological construct which only can be taken seriously if you're willing to accept that as a totalizing meta-narrative”
Western culture since Plato has been essentially totalitarian because totalizing discourses that claim to access ultimate truth necessarily silence all alternative perspectives, making them inherently terroristic.
“leotard believes that that has been what's wrong with western culture since the time of plato it has been essentially totalitarian because all totalizing discourses gesture at the necessity of silencing all other discourses so they are what leocard calls terroristic”
Postmodernism simultaneously treats its subject matter as both serious and facetious, undoing binary distinctions while making it unclear whether one should take postmodern claims seriously, reflecting the self-undermining character of the entire postmodern project.
“this is a huge practical joke and you can see that this game is in fact both serious and facetious at the same time which is so post-modern it has both qualities simultaneously don't take it too seriously but then again don't ignore it either because it is simultaneously serious it sort of undoes the category does undoes all those binary distinctions which is a big post-modern project”
Postmodernism is not a logically coherent system but rather an organized set of emotions: systematic distrust, organized skepticism, and systematic suspicion that targets sites of power (science, politics, ethics) while exempting itself from critical scrutiny.
“post-modernism is not a logically coherent system it is a sort of organized set of emotions it is systematic distrust organized skepticism um systematic suspicion and what does it suspect it suspects all those sites of power in the modern world it distrusts science it distrusts politics it distrusts ethics it distrusts everything except itself”
Lyotard proposes paralogy (counter-thought, counter-speech, alternative systems of thinking) as a solution to performativity, advocating for infinite plurality of perspectival stances none of which can claim superiority, thereby maximizing discursive diversity.
“he says i have an idea instead of looking at the theory of science let's look at the practice let's look at what he calls the pragmatics of scientific activity to see the way in which the everyday concrete interaction of society biases science and alters its allegedly objective domain and activities and what he says is something like this he says that science has caught us up with this idea of performativity and the way out of this is to advocate what he calls parology in other words counter logos counter speech counter thought counter ideas or thinking in other words alternative systems of thought”
Postmodern theory valorizes marginality by taking discourses that have been marginalized, vilified, and condemned and declaring them equally valid as any other discourse, effectively democratizing knowledge by treating opinion as equivalent to knowledge.
“this will be the valorization of marginality which is a very important word nowadays it takes discourses that have been ignored and vilified and condemned and marginalized and says they're just as good as any other kind of discourse... it's a very democratic sort of a theory in the sense that it wants to say that what opinion is the same thing as knowledge because we have no way of gesturing at any substantial reality which would legitimize our knowledge”
Postmodern negation and rejection have become ends in themselves rather than means toward any affirmative goal, resulting in intellectuals gesturing in the void with no reasons to give, drifting toward isolated self-referential discourse where meaningful communication becomes impossible.
“it means that naysaying negation rejection it means that undermining of established verities and suspicion has now become an end in itself it's not a means towards any substantial reality now it just gives us something to do all right so we really are gesturing in the void gesturing in the dark and at the dark towards god knows what for god knows what reason because there are no reasons to give and here we end up in a position where we're drifting in the direction of bart we're drifting in the direction of talking to ourselves right”
Nicholas Luhmann's systems theory is a modernist totalizing metanarrative that presents a deterministic closed system and has a hidden agenda of legitimizing performativity as fundamental value.
“what leotard dislikes about lumen and dislikes about systems theory is first of all the idea that it is deterministic right it is a closed system in that sense it is a modernist totalizing meta-narrative and he says first of all there is no such thing that is not intellectually respectable anymore second of all and this is the big point that leotard makes there is a hidden agenda built in to systems theory built into nicholas lumens project and that's the legitimizing of what leotard calls performativity”
Lyotard claims justice is important but never explains what he means by justice, and never explains why someone's justice should be my obligation if we each have our own discourse and I can be confused on my own, raising a question of what grounds shared political commitment.
“leotard doesn't make it any easier he says that justice is still an important value even though consensus is not but never tells us what justice is and not only that but it does beg the question of what do you now what do you mean by justice but is your justice the same as mine one assumes not so why do i have to pursue your justice what's it to me i have my own little discourse i don't need your help i can be confused on my own right”
The inability to achieve consensus on major social questions like abortion may be a good thing because it ensures freedom and plurality of perspectives, preventing totalizing discourse from becoming totalitarian.
“perhaps there's just no such thing and not only that perhaps the fact that we can't achieve a consensus about abortion or a great many other matters is a good thing because that's what ensures freedom that's what ensures a plurality of possible ways of looking at the world and that's what prevents totalizing discord whether that's where prevents discourse from becoming totalitarian we want to let a hundred flowers bloom and if you were able to reduce them all to one universal question and answer format where you get substantial reality that makes democracy superfluous”
Lyotard's reason for adopting postmodernism and poststructuralism resembles Edmund Hillary's motivation for climbing Everest ('because it was there') or Marlon Brando's character in a motorcycle film ('what are you rebelling against? what do you got?')—rebellion for its own sake.
“the sense that i come away with though is that leotard's reason for adopting post-modernism and post-structuralism is something like edmund hillary's for climbing mount everest because it was there uh if you know that movie by marlon brando where he's playing a motorcycle hood and he comes in and he's and somebody asks what are you rebelling against and marlon brando says what do you got well that's pretty much what post-modernism is what are your rebellions well what's here we're revealing against that we're opposed to it why there it is”
Postmodernism generates a philosophy of resistance and negation that allows inquiry into the status quo and world as it is, enabling recreation of the world through small narrative interrogation rather than reference to grand narratives.
“what this generates is a sort of philosophy of resistance a philosophy of negation and the advantage of this is it allows him to inquire into to interrogate the facts of the world the status quo the world as it is and to recreate that world on the basis of this small narrative interrogation”
Lyotard believes the real intellectual breakthroughs and achievements of tomorrow exist among marginalized and suppressed discourses, so by systematically undercutting new and creative discourses through totalizing frameworks, we truncate human freedom and limit human possibility.
“the more you systematically undercut these new and creative discourses the more you are truncating the domain of human freedom and limiting the domain of human possibility so this is a philosophy of resistance it is a philosophy of negation it resists and negates the modernist tendency towards subsuming all of thought under one aegis and the result of this is is that we end up with something like well something analogous to what freud called polymorphous perversity we end up with a polymorphous perversity of discourses some of them are what we might call orthodox science but others of them might be scientifically dubious astrology sociology is a soft science”
The abortion debate exemplifies the différend: pro-life and pro-choice positions presuppose incompatible understandings of personhood and freedom that make neutral, objective evaluation impossible—asking 'is abortion a good thing?' presupposes the answer depending on whether one frames the question in terms of killing babies or protecting freedom.
“take an example from contemporary politics abortion there's a group of people who are members of a linguistic community who regard the legality of abortion as a question of killing babies there is another group of people a separate community of discourse within the society that regards the legality of abortion as being a question of personal freedom and personal choice... if you formulate your question about abortion within the confines of their linguistic system within the confines of their discourse you will have already presupposed the answer in other words there is no neutral middle ground in language we can dispassionately and objectively search for knowledge there's just an infinite set of perspectives”
The absence of neutral middle ground in language means that we cannot dispassionately and objectively search for knowledge because any formulation within a linguistic system already presupposes the answer by virtue of the conceptual framework it employs.
“there is no neutral middle ground in language we can dispassionately and objectively search for knowledge there's just an infinite set of perspectives”
Since there is no substantial reality we can gesture toward, there is only persuasion rather than conviction; different people with different life experiences and inclinations are simply persuaded differently, with no ultimate grounds for choosing between perspectives.
“there's just persuasion rather than being convinced because you can only be convinced by certain knowledge substantial reality and there's no such thing so we just have persuasion and some people are persuaded of some things some people are persuaded of others some people are persuaded to look at the world in one way some people have different life experiences different inclinations are persuaded to look at the world in another way but there is no ultimate ur stuff that we can gesture at which would give us good grounds for choosing one over another”
Gorgias, the great practitioner of paralogy in Plato's dialogues, responds to being asked what human virtue is by simply laughing, a move that dissolves the domain of communication into giddy self-indulgent laughter, showing paralogy as both serious and facetious simultaneously.
“in the mino he's talking to a guy named mino who was taught by the greatest of the sophists named gorgius and in that dialogue it comes out that when gorgeous gets asked what human virtue is instead of answering he just laughs that's the answer gorgeous is the great practitioner of perology and what this does is dissolve the domain of communication into a sort of giddy self-indulgent laughter”
Lyotard's goal is not merely to critique modernism but to construct a politics that respects 'the desire for justice' and 'the desire for the unknown,' positioning postmodernism as a liberation project.
“the goal of his thinking of his undermining or sabotaging of the modernist tradition of totalizing meta discourses is the liberation of human beings particularly the construction of a politics that would respect the as he puts it the desire for justice and the desire for the unknown”
Postmodernism emphasizes heroic individuals performing indeterminate tasks with powerful internal activities and unrestrained narcissism, characteristics that mark its continuity with Romanticism rather than genuine novelty.
“we emphasize heroic individuals performing their own indeterminate tasks with powerful internal activities and with an enormous amount of unrestrained narcissism”
The conflict between Socrates and the Sophists in Plato's dialogues illustrates paralogical difference: they operate from different assumptions about the world and talk past each other rather than resolve their disagreement through dialogue.
“you might want to go back and look at something like that say the conflict between i don't know plato uh socrates and any of the sophists that he talks to in the dialogues it's perology that they're based upon different assumptions about the world and they're talking past each other”
Lyotard's epistemological critique reveals that the legitimation of science and the legitimation of the state are always bound together; therefore, if nothing holds knowledge and science together, we are also unable to legitimize our political preferences in the traditional sense.
“the legitimation of science and the legitimation of the state are always bound up in other words the condition of knowledge and the circumstances and the way in which we legitimize knowledge claims always has reference and connection to the way in which we legitimize political claims particularly claims about political coercion and its legitimacy”
Lyotard's concept of 'terror' as silencing the different is a unique and enigmatic use of the word that inflates personal worry into a political principle, divorced from the actual terror of revolutions, Nazi atrocities, or Cambodian genocide.
“this idea of terror and the idea of silencing the different as being a terroristic kind of politics now i'm pretty sure that we're supposed to think terror is bad get the idea i mean it's hard to think of the nice connotations of terror there aren't very many of them and yet what say the french revolution meant by terror or what the victims of nazi atrocities or the camerooge atrocities might have meant by terror is not what leotard means by terror because he's pomo what he means by terror is silencing the different which is a very unique and enigmatic use of the word terror”
Restricting presidential debates to mainstream parties (excluding fringe parties) means everyone in America is supposedly 'terrorized' by silenced discourse, though most people don't realize they're being coerced by the modernist tradition.
“think about the fact that in contemporary america when we have presidential debates we don't have every party we don't have the friends of the moon fringe party in to debate with president clinton instead we have a limited domain of people that we are willing to extend free air time to apparently everyone in america is terrorized apparently you're terrified and the bad part of it is that so few people realize that it shows how benign and modernistic you are”
Postmodernity is not genuinely new but rather a rehearsal and reconstruction of Enlightenment-era Romantic criticism, where postmoderns relate to moderns the way Romantics related to Enlightenment figures, perpetually in opposition and perpetually discontent.
“postmodernity is nothing new oddly enough in fact what it is is a rehearsal and a reconstruction and a refurbishment of certain ideas characteristic of the criticism of the enlightenment which is being used in the same way that the romantics criticize the enlightenment in order to criticize the contemporary status of politics science and ethics so i would be intended inclined to say that postmoderns relate to moderns the way romantics related to the great scientific figures of the enlightenment”
Singapore exemplifies the problem with Lyotard's terror concept: it has soft authoritarianism and press censorship, yet its citizens appear happy and satisfied, contradicting the postmodern claim that they are terrorized by silenced discourse.
“let's try something like singapore contemporary intellectuals hate singapore it's a technocratic government has very little use for the eternal verities of humanistic discourse the extension of rights and freedom and subjectivity and all that and what really irked contemporary intellectuals about it is the fact that the singaporeans really love singapore they seem to be happy and they resent that unbelievably because it gives the lie to all their claims about politics”
Only by constructing a fictitious mythological totalizing discourse could one escape paralogical difference and incommensurability; absent such construction, paralogical incommensurability persists as the fundamental condition of language and society.
“if you were able to reduce them all to one universal question and answer format where you get substantial reality that makes democracy superfluous so he says then that the only way to get beyond this is to construct a fictitious mythological totalizing discourse if you don't want to do that then perology is here to stay it's not something he recently invented he's just found a way of valorizing it and saying that he likes it of affirming it but it's been around all the time”
Lyotard's application of Wittgenstein's insights to the problem of grand narratives radicalizes Wittgenstein's own philosophical skepticism much further than Wittgenstein himself was willing to take it, resulting in more profound philosophical problems and skepticisms.
“leotard's idea of little narratives as the alternative to grand narratives is in some ways a recapitulation of wittgenstein's idea of language games and what he's saying then is to is reinforces the wittgensteinian message that there is no essence to language there's just a set of social pragmatics connected to language and what this does is undermine as wittgenstein saw the claim of positivism to be a universal standard a universal litmus test by which we judge meaningful and meaningless communication what leotard does is realize that this idea undermines all such structures and by radicalizing this he ends up with a deeper and more profound set of philosophical problems philosophical skepticisms that wittgenstein ever had within schneid didn't take it nearly so radically nearly so far as leotard himself did”
Lyotard's radical relativism of knowledge, speech, and language moves perilously close to solipsism, making communication and shared understanding impossible, and this problem is the subject of his book The Differend.
“this activity of subjectivizing and radical relativism for both knowledge and speech and language ends up moving perilously close to solipsism and making communication impossible altogether and he has written a whole book on this theme a whole book on this problem and it's probably his greatest book it's called the different”
The Post-Modern Condition is a remarkably transparent and lucid book of about 100 pages that covers substantial philosophical ground with minimal jargon, making it the most accessible entry point to postmodern thought.
“the post-modern conditions a remarkably transparent and lucid little book for those of you who have not had access to post-modern texts in the past i want to get a start on it i think that leotard is a very accessible start and the book is small it is not overwhelming it's not entirely loaded with neologisms although there are enough of them there and of all the texts on in the post-modern genre the post-modern tendency i would say this is the easiest most accessible and most digestible”