Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay on the Enemies of Modernity
What this covers
James Lindsay and Helen Pluckrose join Russ Roberts on EconTalk to argue that modernity—democracy, reason, and individual liberty—faces simultaneous threats from opposing extremes: a pre-modern far-right rooted in tradition and religion, and a post-modern far-left that rejects objective truth in favor of subjective experience and power-constructed knowledge. The conversation maps how these ideological enemies, despite their opposite content, converge toward authoritarian conventionalism, and why moderates across the political spectrum should recognize each other as allies rather than opponents in defending the modern project.
The discussion traces how existential polarization—the belief that the opposing side threatens human civilization itself—pulls ordinary citizens toward the fringes out of fear, even though these extremes remain genuinely marginal. Central to their argument is that classical liberalism underestimated human moral tribes and groupish tribal behavior, leaving modern political philosophy incomplete. They invoke Horseshoe Theory, Moral Foundations Theory, and Arnold Kling's three-axis taxonomy to show why people from different political traditions talk past one another. The conversation also examines how partisan media and social media, by flooding feeds with agreeable content punctuated by caricatured opponents, convince users that their side is correct and the other dangerously extreme—a mechanism that amplifies polarization rather than reducing it.
Pluckrose and Lindsay argue that modernity—democracy, reason, and individual liberty—is under simultaneous attack from pre-modern (far-right, traditionalist) and post-modern (far-left, anti-objective-truth) enemies, and that defenders of modernity across the political spectrum should recognize each other as allies against authoritarian extremism rather than as partisan opponents.
- Both pre-modern and post-modern extremes converge on authoritarian conventionalism despite opposite content
- Existential polarization, amplified by partisan media and social media, skews moderates toward the fringes out of fear
- Classical liberalism underweights human tribal/groupish nature, which must be accounted for to defend modernity
Pre-modern and post-modern extremes threaten modernity itself, unlike ordinary policy disputes, while media incentives for outrage systematically prevent informed civic discourse.
- Unlike ordinary policy disagreements between liberals and conservatives, the pre-modern and post-modern extremes do not merely differ on policy—they want to destroy modernity itself, which is why modernity is genuinely at risk rather than merely contested.
“the Pre- and the Post-Moderns want to destroy Modernity. It's not just, 'Oh, we don't see policy the same way you do.'... You're making the point that Modernity is really at risk right now.”
- The media marketplace—including Fox News, the New York Times, and morning talk shows—is structured to make people angry rather than to inform them, deliberately picking unpleasant representatives of the other side to make them look foolish or dangerous because outrage is more entertaining and sells; news framed as civic education is largely an illusion.
“it became very fashionable to find the most extreme lunatic on the other side from your own, and then present them as if they are typical, in order to fear monger, or to whip up a base, or to radicalize. And this works.”
Three ideological worldviews—civilization versus barbarism, oppressor versus oppressed, coercion versus freedom—create irreconcilable perspectives that prevent mutual understanding.
- Arnold Kling's taxonomy holds that conservatives see the world as a fight between civilization and barbarism, progressives/liberals as a war between oppressor and oppressed, and libertarians as a struggle between coercion and freedom—and these distinct lenses explain why the three groups talk past one another.
“Conservatives look at the world through--the world is a fight between civilization and barbarism... The Liberals see the world as a war between the oppressed and the oppressor... And, the Libertarians see the world as a fight between coercion and freedom.”
Different life domains warrant different epistemic standards—poetic narratives for personal matters, scientific evidence for public safety.
- It is wise to use different narratives for different parts of life—idealized, non-scientific narratives for love, marriage, and family (which should not be subjected to data and regressions), but scientific, evidence-based narratives for matters like the safety of air travel.
“I don't think it's a good idea to scientifically analyze one's marriage or one's love for another person or my connection to my children... But, when I think about getting into an airplane, I'm really focused on the scientific part of the narrative”
Moral tribes and group identities form spontaneously through human nature, not deliberate design, and resist centralized management.
- Moral tribes and forms of group identity—from sports to religion to politics to a neighborhood norm against buying store-bought snacks—emerge spontaneously without anyone's centralized control, and humans are not actually good at deliberately managing them.
“I don't think we're very good at managing these tribes in any dimension whatsoever. They emerge without anyone's centralized control.”