means of production
The capital goods, resources, and tools used to produce other goods—factories, machinery, land—ownership of which (private vs collective) is the central issue in the calculation debate.
As defined in Who Won the Socialist Calculation Debate (with Peter Boettke)
Where it comes up · 12
- Who Won the Socialist Calculation Debate (with Peter Boettke)3 claims
- Peter Boettke on Mises2 claims
- Margaret Atwood1 claim
- Matt Ridley on the Evolution of Everything1 claim
- Elizabeth Anderson on Worker Rights and Private Government1 claim
- Kimberly Clausing on Open and the Progressive Case for Free Trade1 claim
- 324 - Debating The Future Of Ai1 claim
- 327 | Cass Sunstein on Liberalism1 claim
and 4 more
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “means of production” →
- Mises's calculation argument is distinct from and stronger than the incentive critique of socialism: granting for the sake of argument that a 'Socialist Man' is transformed to work selflessly for the common good, socialism still fails because without private property in the means of production there are no markets and no prices for those means, leaving the planner unable to calculate how to allocate scarce resources among competing ends—so socialism cannot achieve its own ends.Peter Boettke on Mises
- The bottom line of Mises's Socialism is a syllogism: without private property in the means of production there is no market in the means of production; without a market there are no prices for those means; and without prices reflecting relative scarcities there is no way for an economic planner to allocate scarce resources among competing ends.Peter Boettke on Mises
- Mises argued in 1920 that abolishing private property in the means of production abolishes markets in the means of production, which abolishes relative prices; without relative prices indicating relative scarcities, planners cannot perform economic calculation to choose between investment projects, so socialism would systematically produce less with more rather than more with less, failing on its own productivity terms.Who Won the Socialist Calculation Debate (with Peter Boettke)
- Mises's critique was a positive analysis, not a normative objection: he accepted the socialists' ends (moving from the kingdom of necessity to the kingdom of freedom) and adopted their own language, then showed that their means—abolition of property, prices, and profit—could not achieve those ends.Who Won the Socialist Calculation Debate (with Peter Boettke)
- Marxist socialists claimed that replacing private ownership of the means of production with collective ownership and replacing prices with planning would rationalize production, increase productive yields, and thereby move society from the kingdom of necessity (scarcity) to the kingdom of freedom (post-scarcity), eliminating class conflict, business cycles, and monopoly.Who Won the Socialist Calculation Debate (with Peter Boettke)
- Ludwig von Mises argued in the 1920s-30s socialist calculation debate that centrally planned economies cannot rationally allocate resources because planners lack market prices for means of production; without prices generated by private property and exchange, planners cannot determine whether specific production plans are efficient or wasteful.Top 9 Economic Lessons of the Past 35 Years | InFi #54
- Any complex organization needs an internal governance structure that, once scaled up, becomes a hierarchy; the default constitution of the American workplace is a top-down dictatorship where unelected executives own the means of production and govern workers, making bosses 'small-c communist dictators.'Elizabeth Anderson on Worker Rights and Private Government
- In the late 18th and early 19th century economic liberals who believed in free markets were also social liberals favoring abolition of slavery and disestablishment of the Church; by the mid-20th century social liberals had become believers in a big state, a shift Ridley attributes mostly to Marx, leaving free-market advocacy to social conservatives like Reagan and Thatcher.Matt Ridley on the Evolution of Everything
- Liberals oppose monopolies of both kinds: government monopolies (a key reason liberals reject socialism understood as public ownership of the means of production) and private monopolies (as even the pro-market Hayek opposed); so Elizabeth Warren's concern about big-tech monopolies speaks within the liberal tradition, even though whether breaking up specific companies like Apple, Google, or Meta would improve things is not determined by liberalism itself.327 | Cass Sunstein on Liberalism
- If people are rational utility maximizers, the interests of factory owners and wage laborers are fundamentally opposed: employers seek to minimize wages to maximize profits, while workers seek higher wages, creating structural class conflict.Smith's Wealth of Nations